CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 286 DECEMBER 2022

And Here We Are …

Hans Skott-Myhre

So, here we are in the final month of 2022. It has been a rough ride for young people, their allies, and friends. The world as it emerges in the early quarter of the 21st century is rife with a kind desperate uncertainty. For those of us concerned with creating a world of global relations founded on care, it has been a tough few years. While there have certainly been some improvements in reducing poverty and increasing access to medical care for some of the worlds most impoverished young people, there has also been an increase in violence of all kinds and a brutality of economic logic that creates a seemingly endless capacity for creating young people as disposable bodies.

It seems almost like a truism to say that we live in a time of massive transition. But I think if we are to make sense of what is happening to us and the young people we encounter in our work, then the inherent instability of our historical moment must be acknowledged as the lived experience of our time. In a very real sense, young people know this in their bones. For them, the world has always been unstable and very probably dangerous. For young people born at the turn of the century and now entering their early twenties, there has never been a 20th century to which they can return. It has always been the 21st century with all that implies. The call out, “OK Boomer” encapsulates the frustration of young people with their elders who seem intent on reproducing a world that no longer exists. I worry about this in terms of our own field of CYC where many of us are still repeating the mantras of the 20th century as though they can save us from the future.       

The stakes are high for the young people who may well live to see the late 21st century. Of course, it is impossible to read the future, but at a minimum the next 60 years looks challenging to say the least. While the political landscape is most certainly unsettled and possibly quite dangerous to anyone who finds themselves outside the dominant regimes of power, it is the material world that will very likely determine the quality of life for many of us. The planet and its climate are implacable and impersonal. The fact that we as humans believe we can bargain the future is an extremely fraught gamble. The material world does not respond to anything other than material actions. No amount of rhetoric or well-intentioned conversations will shift the direction of what is quite likely a massive transition in the life sustaining capacity of the planet. As humans, we are altering the biosphere to such a degree as to exceed our capacity to comprehend what we are doing.

Our level of denial is extraordinary. In the most recent climate talks, the wealthiest countries in the world agreed to pay to offset the economic effects of climate change. In other words, to acknowledge that things will get really bad for the poorer countries because we are not doing enough to reverse the effects. Instead of radical action that might shift the negative effects of climate change, the wealthy will offer money. To believe that this will somehow work over time, while crops fail, shorelines flood, people drown, and starve is truly remarkable shortsightedness.

This kind of example is emblematic of the ways in which times of transitions, such as ours, are seldom kind to the those who don’t have access to the protections of economic and social power. It has been argued that this is a historical moment of both unparalleled power for the ruling elites of global capital and a time full of portents of the end of what has been called global capitalist empire. Historically, empires often take a long time to decline and they seldom leave the stage of history gracefully. It is often a messy transition that is seldom kind and often brutal. Such times are defined by the riptides of social and political sea changes that are unpredictable and deadly for those caught up and swept away. The social landscape is indeterminate with what appear to be advances in greater levels of equity and justice met with reactionary brutality. The push and pull of a kaleidoscope of social investments swirls around and through us in ways that can be deeply unsettling. Our ability to seek the kind of consensus necessary to effectively care for one another has become profoundly challenging.

In such times, anxiety is rampant. For many of us the levels of uncertainty are unbearable and we are pretty much willing to do anything to feel less anxious. We turn to psychiatry for the balm of psychopharmacology, we seek solace in alcohol and an ever-increasing variety of opiates and their derivatives, we even turn to micro dosing psychedelics as a way to get through the day.

It all can seem too much and the attraction of feeling it less intently or not at all can be attractive. The prevailing system of dominant logic continues to center our relationships with chemical interventions as a personal problem requiring remediation by the very system creating the problem to begin with. That is not to say that psychiatrists and other drug dealers are the source of our pain and anxiety. But, what they do in the long run also doesn’t have the intended effect of making us feel better. Of course, we do feel better at first, but over time our dependency on any of these drugs (psychedelics being a possible exception) becomes a problem in and of itself. What I mean by the dominant system of logic that is at the center of the kind of bitterness and disillusion that can lead to crippling anxiety is the addictive propensities of global capitalism itself.

I would argue that the anxiety we feel and the remedies we seek are founded in the very nature of capitalist logic. The system itself is based on the ability to rip people out of their living sets of ecological relations and embed them within a world of relations driven by an abstraction called money.

Of course, these arguments are not new to anyone who has been following my columns here for the past few years. I have been arguing in every way I can think of, that if we want to assist young people through building a network of caring relations, we cannot continue to engage the tools offered us by the most comprehensive and effect system of domination and control human beings have ever devised. Audrey Lourde famously said, “You cannot use the masters tools to dismantle the master’s house.” Put in the simplest terms, you cannot build a system of care responsive to the material needs of young people by using tools provided to you by the system designed to parasitically take every bit of life and creativity young people possess and turn it all to the end of making more money.

The tools are inherently corrupted and they cannot be turned from the purpose for which they have  been designed. Entrepreneurship, diagnosis, treatment planning, mentorship, level systems, emotional self-regulation, natural consequences, job readiness, mindfulness, self-care, psychopharmacology, trauma based treatment, neurologically informed care (and the list goes on) all seem reasonable when read thought the lens of neo-liberal ideology. I would argue, however, that each in their own way actually interferes with our capacity to build actual living sets of relations. Neoliberalism through its allies in psychology, psychiatry, education, social work, and Child and Youth Care have taken the suffering and thwarted desires of young people (and ourselves) and turned them against us. In each of the perverse forms of care I have listed above, the pain and alienation young people feel is centered within them. Their hardships are based in something they lack. The system promises to fill that lack through providing missing chemicals in the brain, missing fathers in the community, missing job skills, missing self-care, missing self-regulation, etc. Of course, these new (and they are always new) tools promise that with the replenishing of whatever is missing, young people will become resilient, competent, working, citizens in the world economy. And yet, in spite of the fact that many, if not most of these tools have been in use for decades, young people continue to struggle and one might even say failing to thrive or in some cases even survive.

In short, the neoliberal incursion into our work with young people doesn’t seem to working for young people or ourselves. I would argue that this is not because the needs of the neoliberal agenda are not being met. Neoliberalism is doing fine. The richer are getting richer and more wealth is being created than ever before. The master’s tools are continuing to expand the master’s house very well. Regrettably, our backs are turned and our attention is not on the system that is brutally appropriating young people to its ever increasing appetites. Instead, we are focused on what is wrong with the young people. Why are they so unhappy, alienated, anxious, depressed, suicidal, prone to drug use, gang affiliation, homicide. It is a nasty bit of smoke and mirrors. A magicians slight of hand that keeps us thinking it is the kids that need fixing.

And so we keep constructing an ever more elaborate systems of care for which we require more and more financial support from the very system that has poisoned the well to start. We continue to build residential programs, group homes, corrections facilities, adolescent in-patient hospital units, counselling centers, runaway and homeless youth programs, foster care programs, drug and alcohol treatment programs, wilderness programs, street outreach services, transitional living programs, suicide prevention programs, gang intervention programs, programs for the survivors of sexual and physical assault, mentorship programs, psychoeducation programs, family therapy programs; the list is ever expanding.

This empire of programs designed to remediate the suffering of young people seems impervious to the fact that the system continues to fail young people inside and outside its reach. Don’t get me wrong there are successes: lives saved, addicts in recovery, families reunited, homeless, abused, and neglected young people safely homed, and young people employed. These things do happen thanks to the efforts of CYC workers toiling in the belly of the beast. But, as we all know, the successes are too few and the failures too many.

So, what to do? The answer is at once very simple and at the same time inordinately complex. I would argue that we need to quit building institutions designed to fix young people. We might take a page from the work of the anti-psychiatrist Franco Basaglia. Basaglia was the founder of the deinstitutionalization movement that closed the asylums in the late 20th century. As the chief psychiatrist for a large asylum in northern Italy, he determined that asylums were not at all designed to serve the interests of the patients within them. Instead, he argued they served the state by obscuring the suffering of the poor and marginalized by removing them from their communities and hiding them within the asylums. Basaglia felt that if he was to take his mandate of care seriously, as a psychiatrist, he needed to dismantle the very institution of which he was the head.

And so he did. He joined with the patients and gave them open democratic voice in the running of the asylums, he joined with the staff in creating more humane conditions, he joined with community and opened the asylums to anyone who would like to help. Finally, he began the process of emptying the asylums and recentering the work of remediating suffering back to the community. In 1978, he had both emptied asylums across Italy and got a law passed that closed them for good.

Of course, as we know Basaglia’s vision for a deinstitutionalized community-based system of care run by and for the patients themselves was quickly co-opted by the community mental health movement. The mental health movement put the professionals firmly back in charge and allowed the state to cut funding so profoundly as to make system of care essentially dysfunctional. So, there is a caveat here. I would argue that it is important to remember that the struggle is ongoing and that whatever we do it is likely to be coopted and perverted, at least for a time.

That said, in the failure if Basaglia’s project there remained sparks that in the 21st century have ignited a whole new generation of psychiatric survivors who are building grass roots alternatives to the mental health system all around the world. I am looking to see if we in CYC have the kind of dedication and courage that would allow us to dismantle the master’s house using the tools we share with the young people we encounter in the work we do. It is good work, it is essential work, and it is our legacy for the 21st century. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App