Recently I had the unique opportunity to see Yo-Yo Ma, the world famous Chinese-American cellist, in concert. I was no more than 10 meters away from where he was seated on his chair deeply engaged with his cello. Surrounded by the Toronto Symphony Orchestra, he played for 45 minutes straight. As I watched, I could clearly see that from his perspective, he was communicating, not just with the audience, but with his cello, profoundly set in a human-non-human relationship. What was readily apparent was the presence of both human and non-human this relationship, with the audible music representing the relational context and to some degree the inadvertent product of a deep and mutual engagement between the two. Needless to say, it was a spectacular and deeply touching experience.
Over the past year, I have been hearing a lot from colleagues that their students in child and youth care programs (and other human service programs) are behaving badly; that they are communicating rudely; that they are demanding and entitled; and that they seem to have lost respect for professors and for their own role as learners. This, my colleagues, say, is different from what it used to be. Sure, there were always some students whose interactions with professors was challenging, but currently, it seems to have taken on a whole new level. Most of my colleague’s attribute this to the pandemic, arguing that the two years these students spent in virtual learning contexts may have disabled some normal social skills development processes. This argument is sometimes fine-tuned to include references to changing norms in North American society, driven by the rise of the far right, in which expressions of racism and white supremacy, as well as the individualistic pursuit of entitlement and privilege, have become normalized.
One response to these developments I find particularly worrisome. This response usually involves new student conduct policies, warnings about consequences on course syllabi, and uniting as a faculty team in the response to individual incidents, regardless of context. These kinds of efforts give rise to surveillance mechanisms and disciplinary regimes that I have spent my entire adult life criticizing in the context of youth work, and particularly school-based and residential child and youth care practice. I am devastated that I see the very same dynamics that are common amongst staff teams that have lost their way now emerge amongst the educators of the future staff teams in those settings. I am also disappointed that we seem oblivious to the patterns of colonial practices, where surveillance and disciplinary measures have always, and quite intentionally, disempowered and sometimes directly and severely harmed racialized peoples in disproportionate ways.
On the other hand, I love and respect my colleagues and of course want them to be able to do their job without being treated badly. I know that it is enormously challenging to deal with rudeness and a lack of respect in a context in which the work of teaching is often already a precarious undertaking with insufficient support resources. So what can be done to avoid the pitfalls of imposing control and containment on the one hand, while strengthening and rendering more positive the experience of my colleagues on the other hand?
Having observed young people before, during and after the pandemic in myriad settings ranging from group homes, to school-based treatment programs and of course post-secondary education settings, both during formal programs (classroom-based teaching in colleges and universities, social skills groups in group homes), as well as in informal contexts (riding the elevator with a group of students, watching youth interact during school lunch hours), I can’t help but notice how transactional and instrumental such interactions are. Essentially, it feels to me like social relations have largely been commodified to serve immediate purpose and gratification without any connection to the social world. Even in post-secondary classrooms, where pedagogic methods are creative and often highly engaging, there is a degree of superficiality embedded in both the student-student interactions and the student-teacher/professor interactions. “Excellent point, Miriam”, “thanks for contributing, Abdul”, “I like your reflections, Kwesi” are the kinds of responses one often hears from the teacher/professor. Nice enough, validating, inviting, but also not particularly meaningful or deep. Quite to the contrary, such responses strike me more as value assessments of a product instead of meaningful engagements, particularly when I often feel that what Miriam said wasn’t really an excellent point, and Abdul’s contribution was rather minimalist, and Kwesi’s reflection didn’t even scratch the surface of what might have been possible.
In saying this, I want to make sure the point is fully understood. I am identifying as superficial not only the emerging youth communication culture, often attributed (without meaningful evidence) to social media usage and excessive use of handheld devices more generally, but also adult (including professor, child and youth worker, social worker) communication cultures. Everywhere I look, what we say and how we say it seems disconnected from the complexity of social relation and the social world. Quick judgments, easy answers, moment-based analysis seems to have crept into our communication culture across generations and pretty much everywhere. Perhaps this is not a surprise; after all, no matter how significant and serious the context, superficiality, non-responses to questions, and empty rhetoric is modeled for all of us by political institutions and governments, band-aid solutions to chronically embedded social problems, and an innovation culture that puts flashy product ahead of meaningful experience and structural change. I am always a little disturbed when even in our field discussions about ethics, racism, and purpose tend to be shorter and less animated than discussions about developing a new logo, a fancy letterhead, or a motto for some new initiative or organization.
So where might we find relief from these emerging trends? I am finding myself increasingly drawn to the world of performance, theatre, music, and the arts more generally. These are the spaces where I can still see a level of depth in relational contexts that speaks to transcending the obvious and connecting across social contexts and worlds. I referenced Yo Yo Ma and his connection to the cello as a way of exemplifying what can happen in dialogues that are challenging and engaged without seeking outcomes. And I think this level of depth can be replicated in approaches to child and youth care practice, as well as approaches to teaching emerging practitioners (in child and youth care, social work, nursing and other service-oriented fields). Examples of this kind of practice abound; performance arts are especially powerful in the context of trauma-informed work, but this approach extends much beyond such work and includes approaches to advocacy, self-discovery, and social connections. Wolfgang Vachon has been working at the cutting edge of this way of being with youth for many years, and recently produced a series of fictional podcasts with young people that give expression to themes and issues at a level of depth rarely heard in the daily context of residential care, schools, or post-secondary education. Heather Snell has used theatre as the medium for child and youth care practice and has taken to making every speech a performance involving in depth explorations of themes and issues acutely reflective of relational care. Juanita Stephen has used Afrofuturism to create spaces of deep engagement with racism and a future beyond racism through nouveau art and creative design. Peter Amponsah uses drums (specifically West African drumming) to tune into relational spaces with youth that reflect similar kinds of human-nonhuman as well as inter-human connections as Yo-Yo Ma does with his cello.
These are approaches that fit well with - in fact that reconstruct - in a powerful and better way, child and youth care practice. But they must be understood as approaches that undo what is really the worst aspect of our more traditional, talk-oriented practice: They undo the notion that this practice flows change from the practitioner to the young person. Change, in whatever form, is as necessary for the practitioner as it is for the young person, because it is not the individuals who are in need of change, but the cultures and contexts in which they co-exist. Furthermore, these approaches to practice allow for challenge, intensity, and depth in ways that our strength-based rhetoric does not. The interdependency and constant co-creation in performance arts pushes everyone to assess and re-assess how they are with one another. There is no room for empty praise or scolding invalidation. The performance moves us, all of us, together, and within that movement, we learn respect, social reflexivity, and relational engagement simply because the movement itself is precisely these things.