Deliberate Practice in CYC
Doug Magnuson
In
my last column, in the October 2022 edition of this publication, I
discussed what research says about how to improve one’s practice and the
importance of feedback. The research in counseling suggests that one’s
deliberate use of feedback in practice is more important to one’s
effectiveness than one’s qualifications. Further, differences in
the abilities of practitioners are more important for effectiveness than
diversities among youth or in setting. I promised to take up the
question of how this is done in CYC.
The most important condition
for improvement is “deliberate practice,” as it is sometimes called.
Getting feedback is the first step; using that feedback to change one’s
approach and behavior is equally important. This seems obvious; despite
this, few practitioners do it, and few organizations encourage it as
part of the culture.
The basic steps of deliberate practice are:
- Isolate the skill. Break it
into small pieces and practice each piece separately.
- Develop the skill by repetitively doing it over and over and try
variations.
- Assess your competency.
Get feedback from youth and colleagues.
- Begin to recognize when it can be used. Eventually it will become easy.
This will seem artificial and inauthentic, in the beginning.
Remember that authentic incompetence is not that useful! Effective
practice is not “natural.”
Here are some related but more general
ideas for implementing deliberate practice, with feedback, in CYC
settings. These may need to be adapted to your setting and to your
clients.
- You have to start with feedback from youth, and you do not want to use
non-specific, open-ended questions to ask for it, like “Any comments?”
“Any feedback for me?” You want to ask concrete questions about
relationships, behaviors, incentives, rewards, consequences, values,
goals, activities, perceptions, and so forth. Not the youth’s behaviors
and values. Yours, or at least your role in the relationship.
- You want to measure whether you are helping youth, and you want to
measure your skill performance. You want the result to be something you
can track over time, so a simple quantitative scale works best. It
should be easy and fast to complete, and it should measure what you want
to know. The Session Rating Scale and Outcome Rating Scale, from Scott
Miller, are two well-known short measures, and you can find them on the
internet. There are hundreds of them, and you can also develop your own.
This does not mean qualitative feedback is bad or wrong—only that you
want consistent, regular, easy measurement, and the quantitative data
can be followed up with qualitative questions.
- Measure the skill regularly so that you receive feedback and so that
trends become obvious, early. These can be discussed with youth; for
example, you can point out a trend and ask what is going right—or wrong.
It directs both of you to the relationship and to scores rather than
personalizing feedback from youth to you and from you to youth. It
demonstrates seriousness to youth.
- Be alert to changes. Research demonstrates that we are often not aware
when something is not going well, and we are often self-deceptive about
this. Collect data and information consistently.
- You want to use some type of road map or guide to help you keep track of
the skills important to you. Use your agency’s guide, a list of CYC
competencies, or your own list of things you want to practice or learn
to do. Use a list that is useful to you. Document your progress.
- Ask a colleague or mentor you admire to watch you perform a skill, and
solicit feedback. Ask that same person to watch you practice that skill
before you need it.
- Recruit youth
to help you practice. You can do this before the circumstance requires
it, and it can be done light-heartedly and as a way to cue youth to your
intentions. If you’re very lucky, youth will volunteer to practice their
response.
- Try out your new skill at
work. Ask youth and colleagues for specific feedback about how well you
did.
- Collect some data about the
impact of your skill. Does it help? What are the unintended effects?
- There is often a lot of down time in CYC practice;
use that time for practice and thinking about how to obtain feedback.
- Break up your work shifts into small
units of time, and think about how that time could be improved. Are you
fixing dinner? Transporting someone to practice? What skill can you use
to improve the richness or impact of that small activity? What do good
colleagues do?
- What personal skills do
you have that could be brought to the workplace? Music, culture,
athletics, recreation, games, cooking, and academic talents make you
interesting to young people. Do them at work.
- Keep records of your goals and the work you have done to achieve them.
- Ask youth about their goals and help them
figure what steps are needed to achieve them. Help them track their
progress and do everything you can to assist with their progress. Link
your skill practice to their goals.
Your ability to implement
intervention activities and treatment goals in a program may not be that
important to your effectiveness. Treatment models and interventions come
and go! Instead, it is possible that your deliberate practice of
skills important to dynamic relationships with youth and to creating an
interesting world for them will be invaluable, and it will be
interesting to you as well.