CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 274 DECEMBER 2021

Fusing Horizons: Reflections on Caring for Asylum Seeking and Refugee Youth

Mark Smith

Global movement has led to the need to care for thousands of displaced children and youth. Since late 2016 my family and I have been foster carers for an unaccompanied minor seeking political asylum and subsequent refugee status. This experience has afforded unique insights into the lives and needs of asylum-seeking and refugee youngsters and to the systems that come to frame their lives. I offer here a reflexive account of my own experiences in the hope that it might cast some light on the wider context of how we might care for such youngsters. For me, this has involved a continual fusing of horizons between past and present and between practical responses to everyday care informed by an awareness of the cultural context that frames these. My conclusion is that such work requires a child and youth care orientation, foregrounding ideas of everyday life within a context of cultural safety.

Keywords

unaccompanied minors, asylum, refugee, Muslim, Islam, foster care, cultural safety, Europe

 

Readers, certainly European readers, will recall the refugee crisis that erupted into public consciousness in 2015 as hundreds of thousands fled conflict-torn countries across the Middle East,

Central Asia and Africa. They will recall images of Jeeps with bodies hanging from them driving across the North African desert and of dinghies going down in the Mediterranean Sea, some of their passengers rescued by Italian coastguards, others not, their bodies washed up on Southern European beaches. Many of those who made it to Europe traversed the Continent before ending up in the Calais Camps on the north coast of France, waiting for claims for asylum to be processed or hoping that they might be smuggled to the UK in the back of a lorry.

There was a range of reactions, not all of them positive, to the events that unfolded across Europe, requiring destination countries to offer sanctuary and care of some sort to huge numbers of what Bauman (2016) termed the strangers at our door. There were many humanitarian responses at political and community levels. One such was associated with a politician, Alf Dubs, who negotiated an agreement on behalf of the UK Government to take 3000 unaccompanied asylum seekers from Calais. In the event, and in response to political pressures, the numbers were reduced to nearer 300. This cohort of, primarily, boys and young men was dispersed across UK local authorities. The Scottish city we live in agreed to take five. We were already registered foster carers, having offered respite care to disabled kids for over 25 years. So, when an email came around asking if we might consider extending our fostering remit, we felt a need to respond. We spoke to our kids and agreed to offer a placement.

This happened at a point in our family life, which impacted our capacity and motivation to respond. My wife had left social work practice after thirty years to undertake a PhD. I had made that move from practice to academia some years earlier and was about to go on sabbatical leave. Our own kids had left home to go to university, so we had both flexibility of time and space at home, but there were probably other things going on too. It can be hard to say this in secular times but it was approaching Christmas and the figure of a young person forced from their homeland and seeking refuge in a strange land held a particular resonance for us as Catholics. At another level, there may have been an element of personal vanity at play – I have a niggling concern about my credibility with practitioners the longer I am out of practice and this gave me an opportunity to keep my hand in, to practice what I preach.

Having made the offer, things moved quickly and Faisal (name changed) had moved in by the first week of January. The response from friends was mostly positive, although (and I will come back to this point), there was a sense that we were doing something beyond the ordinary and that others, even if similarly motivated, might not have the specialized knowledge and skills required. Interestingly, it was social work friends who were rather more sanguine – those seeking asylum were often older than they claimed to be, they told us; placements often broke down – cultural differences could be really difficult to manage and youngsters took off to be with communities of compatriots in bigger cities. We hadn’t actually considered that we might struggle in a caring role – although we have never considered ourselves to have any specialist ‘therapeutic’ skills, we both had years of experience of looking after kids in range of different capacities and settings and were confident that we had something to offer and that we would handle whatever difficulties that might crop up. This, however, was going to be a very new experience. Scotland has, until the past decade or so, been a particularly mono-cultural society. And while I’d like to think that I was politically and religiously internationalist, I soon realized that I actually knew next to nothing about majority world cultures.

In the event, our confidence was justified – our experience has been entirely positive. Over the course of the past three years we have gone on to offer respite to other asylum-seeking kids but, more broadly, our house became a meeting place, after Mosque on Fridays, for the group of boys who arrived together. My wife, primarily, has become an advocate for Faisal’s friends as they have negotiated the hurdles of settling in a new country with no existing support networks.

Our motivation in fostering was certainly not that we might go on to research that experience but given our own backgrounds it was perhaps inevitable that we would reflect on the situation we found ourselves in and we quickly realised that we were gaining unique insights into the lives and needs of asylum seekers and how to care for them. A particular knowledge emerges out of the act of caring (Ricks, 1992), which, when combined with our practice experience and academic backgrounds intersects dialectically to bring a practical wisdom that isn’t available within policy or the psychological discourses that have come to dominate child care.

If I were to describe our position in research terms it would lend itself to a reflexive ethnographic approach, a genre of autoethnography (Ellis, Adams & Bochner, 2011). Autoethnography ‘seeks to describe and systematically analyze personal experience in order to understand cultural experience’ (Ellis et al, 2011, online source, para 1). So, in many ways this is an account of my experience of caring for Faisal, making connections between this and the wider cultural context within which that caring relationship is set.

Autoethnography brings particular ethical considerations. In foregrounding myself in the writing, I risk compromising Faisal’s anonymity in a way that cannot be glossed over merely by changing names or through claiming procedural consent. Faisal knows what we do professionally, and we have spoken to him about speaking publicly about our experiences caring for him. He is perfectly happy with that (and genuinely, as a teenager, although now legally an adult, seems not to care), although I have to be conscious that this seeming consent is offered in the context of a relationship within which he might be seen to be dependent on or beholden to me. In such situations, MacFarlane (2010) claims that it is more important to exercise personal virtue and ethical imagination than to merely follow ethical guidelines and that properly ethical consent can only reside in the relationships of trust that exists between Faisal and myself in the context of wider family relationships (Ellis, 2017 or 2007). Nevertheless, mindful of the potential ethical complexities, the focus of this article is not so much on Faisal but on my reflections of caring for him in the hope that these can offer wider insights. 

A starting point: cultural safety

Fulcher (2003) notes that the care and supervision of young people relies heavily on Western theories of child development and interpersonal relations and fails to sufficiently recognise the significance of culture in providing care. It might seem odd that this is the case as social work training since the early 1990s in the UK required the demonstration of anti-discriminatory practice, which included attention to cultural difference.

However, critiques of this are that it was tokenistic, and that was certainly our experience. Social work discourse gave us little we could draw upon in our new caring roles.

Fulcher goes on to observe that carers’ personal experiences of acculturation and socialisation leave them with taken-for-granted assumptions and mindsets. We realised very quickly that we knew very little about other cultures. Faisal, as his name might suggest, was Muslim. But he was African. Brought up within a tradition of Christian missionary activity in Africa, it had not really occurred to us that so much of the continent was Muslim. We, also, had a very surface knowledge of Islam, even down to not knowing the significance of terms such as halal (which we associated only with a way of slaughtering animals for meat but not with its wider connotations of what was permissible in life more generally). We likewise had little conception of the flip side of halal, haram, those acts that are forbidden. We also had to come to terms with daily prayer, with wudu, the ritual ablutions that Muslims are called to perform, with dua, the invocations recited silently on entering everyday situations, with fitrah, the idea of modesty and with zina, which I return to. Mostly, we had to come to terms with Ramadan, the requirement that Muslims fast between the hours of sunrise and sunset for a period of 29-30 days in the year. This becomes particularly problematic when Ramadan falls in June, where, in Scotland, we get perhaps only four hours of darkness. I recall one of the boys, who had lived most of his life in the West, telling me that I just didn’t understand how all-encompassing religious adherence was for Muslims; it wasn’t a matter of just religious belief or practice but an entire way of life.

Rituals of encounter

The cultural dissonance between Islam and our own cultural backgrounds required that we became aware of and practiced in a way that Faisal experienced as culturally safe. Fulcher describes cultural safety as involving ‘the state of being in which a child or young person experiences that her/his personal wellbeing, as well as their social and cultural frames of reference, are acknowledged – even when not fully understood’ (2003, p.20).

A starting point in beginning to show this respect was to do some homework (easy with the internet) around basic geographical, linguistic, religious and cultural features of Faisal’s homeland which, in turn, led to us needing to be aware of the wider geo-political situation across much of Africa and the part this plays in the conflicts behind the movement of people as they seek to escape the ramifications of these. We obviously had to place Faisal’s own experiences within this wider global context. And it was in this regard that everyday experience became so important in linking the particular to the general. Early on in placement I took Faisal to the gym and he showed me the scars on his legs caused by beatings from the security forces; we were able to use this information with lawyers preparing his claims for refugee status. This fusion of the immediate with the bigger picture becomes possible and emerges serendipitously through the sharing of everyday life events, which is at the heart of a child and youth care approach to practice (Garfat, 1998).

While we deliberately held off from directly questioning Faisal about his experiences, concentrating instead on helping him settle into the routines of family and school, we came, through chance remarks and snippets of conversation, to find out about not just his journey but the wider global movement of people which is, of course, more complicated and nuanced than we can be led to believe. Sure, there were the traffickers, so central to popular and policy discourse, making money out of this, but there were also humanitarian motives to remove sons and daughters and neighbors from harm, but mostly, the whole process just seems to have taken on a life and momentum of its own. Faisal did not set out to leave his homeland and had no idea where he was going, but once he joined the caravan of other youngsters in a similar situation, it just kept rolling with various interludes, in his case as with so many others, across Northern Africa to the Mediterranean, into Italy and from there, across Europe to the Calais Camps.

Fulcher (2003) makes the case that the rituals of encounter that emerge between carers and children of different cultures are fundamental to the personal meanings ascribed to help-giving and help-seeking behaviours, and to the relational dynamics of child and youth care practice. These rituals are played out in everyday events. A key ritual of encounter is around food practices. 

Food

Food assumes a social and symbolic significance in caring (Dorrer et al, 2010; Rees, Holland & Pithouse, 2012) quite beyond its necessity for sustenance. Rituals around food and its preparation take on particular connotations within certain religious traditions. For refugees in foster care, it is implicated in a sense of comfort and of finding sanctuary, negotiating belonging and evoking a sense of ‘home’ in a new land (Kohli, Connolly & Warman, 2010).

Food has always been important to us as a family. So, when Faisal arrived, my wife (in particular), entered into all sorts of elaborate arrangements to source halal meat, particular spices and breads and we all took our turn at trying to cook traditional meals. Although we enjoyed these new dishes, our efforts were not particularly appreciated by Faisal whose eating habits remained a mystery to us. He would go for long periods without eating and when he did, his diet, apart from eating copious amounts of fruit, was not healthy. His friends, on the other hand, ate everything we put down to them. It was only after a couple of years, by which time he had the language to explain, that he was able to tell us that he used to drive his mother mad as he was a ‘fussy eater’. So, our efforts to cater for Faisal’s cultural needs in respect of food had to be set against his own fussiness.

Language

This led to another realization on our part and that is to do with the role of language in how asylum-seeking youngsters can make sense of and articulate their experiences. Although Faisal’s English was remarkably good, and he understands and can communicate to a high level, there are, understandably, particular words and concepts that he did not have; it took him a couple of years to be able to explain that he was a ‘fussy eater’. That led me to think about how he and others might be able to pick up the gist of a conversation but there would inevitably be gaps as they came across words and concepts they just didn’t get. So, whilst we might be pushed, increasingly, in child and youth care and every other sphere of people work, to apply a narrow ‘therapeutic’ lens to understand what might be going on for youngsters, we need a far broader perspective that recognizes and pays attention to the importance of language as the gateway to the intellectual and moral habits appropriate to conversation and attunement to cultural frames of reference (Standish, 2005).

The comfort of strangers

One of the gratifying experiences for us was around how well received Faisal was once he came to live with us. Neighbors brought gifts and offered help. We enrolled him in the local school, which was great with him. Teachers looked out for him, gave him presents, marked special occasions. My own wider family also rallied round. My mother, a former English teacher, helped him pass the English exam that was the gateway to college and subsequently university. Friends of my sons and daughter offered him tuition in particular school subjects. Although shy, Faisal made friends at school, mostly among other non-indigenous kids. He also maintained links with a couple of boys from his homeland, who were placed in a neighboring local authority and with other Muslim boys through the mosque.

Football

But the most powerful support network and, arguably, the strongest signifier of cultural safety converged around football. All the asylum-seeking boys were football mad and each had a favorite English team. One of the defining moments in his settling into our family was when, early in placement, one of our sons, who coincidentally followed the same English team, took him to London to take in a game. Family members also involved him in playing in a regular five-a-side football game that has gone on now for almost three years. Football provides a sense of identity and belonging for kids (Steckley, 2005) and for asylum-seeking and refugee kids it does so in a context where they do not need to know the language to know what is going on, to express themselves, to be understood and to gain status. Faisal also joined a local boys club team and, as with the teachers in the school, the football coaches and other boys were incredibly kind to him. In a male and largely working-class context that we can be led to imagine to be breeding grounds for intolerance, he has experienced nothing but kindness.

Zina

After a bit, it became apparent that girls were part of the friendship group at school. By this stage, I had some understanding of Muslim attitudes towards sex, set out in Islamic law in the concept of zina. Zina decrees that sex should only happen within marriage and stipulates eternal penalties for anything that happens beyond those confines. The need to commit zina is mitigated in Muslim countries through early marriage but becomes more complicated in Western cultures. The implications of carrying a cultural fear and weight of sin for even looking at or being alone with a member of the opposite sex got me thinking more broadly about the implications of sexual customs and beliefs in understanding and caring for youth from different cultures.

Faisal and thousands of other boys had spent the years of their sexual awakenings on the road. One can only imagine the conflicts they have to negotiate and what sense Muslim boys, who had left their countries of origin as boys having only seen sexually mature females draped in Muslim dress, might make of their arrival in the West as young men to be confronted with girls’ bodies and with their own sexualities in a cultural context where sex is not necessarily considered haram. This constitutes a fundamental challenge to the way the world, until that point, was understood. How might child and youth care workers acknowledge such matters with them? Having that conversation with kids is by its nature awkward at the best of times – as Fewster (2001) observes, talking about sex puts us in touch with our own sexuality, which we tend to put into cold storage when engaging with kids. It is more difficult in the Muslim culture where there are even greater taboos around speaking about sex. Others within Faisal’s friendship group came from still different religious and associated sexual traditions, each with their own peculiar features. So, one needs to grapple with what diverse sexual moralities and sensibilities might mean in terms of how asylum seekers negotiate relationships in a new and strange world.

All of this made me think about how inadequate instrumental or rights-based school and health-based approaches to sex education and to sexual identity are in such a complex and sensitive cultural web. None of this is mentioned or even considered in how social work engages or fails to engage with such complicated psycho-sexual issues. The social work response relayed to us did not go beyond the arguably racist stereotype that they (Muslim youth) don’t respect women. That has certainly not been our experience but even if it were, it betrays a Western view of gender that does nothing to illuminate the complexity and ambiguity brought about by radically different cultural and religious contexts.

Liminality

Attitudes to alcohol in Islam are, like sex, similarly restrictive. Although I quite consciously drink in front of Faisal, partly to challenge a preconceived notion that alcohol leads to a loss of control, he has not succumbed to joining me. Abstinence has its advantages; there has not been the clubbing and the nights waiting up for him to arrive home in various states of disrepair that is the ‘normal’ adolescent experience. Caring for Faisal has constituted an inversion of this – while with our own kids the adult role has been to shield them or to pace their entry into the adult world (Mollenhauer, 2013), the task with Faisal has been to try and push him to take a few baby steps so that he might reach a ‘position facing the world’ (see Smith, 2013) but to allow him to do so comfortably and without feeling that he is betraying his religion and his roots. He, and the other boys, exist in this perpetual liminal state, on the threshold of two very different worlds (Kohli, Connolly, & Warman, 2010). The task for us has been to try and maintain a healthy tension by which he (and they) can reconcile and embrace both worlds. While drinking alcohol has not been one, we have been conscious of marking other adolescent rites of passage such as getting travel documents, taking his first flight, learning to drive, picking up part-time jobs and going off to university.

The lifeworld and the system

While I have alluded to the kindness Faisal has encountered from those he has come across in his everyday life, the same cannot be said of the state apparatus; there is a disjunction between the lifeworld and the system (Habermas – see Houston, 2012). Engagement with the immigration authorities has shown the system to be obstructive and downright incompetent. Most egregiously, perhaps, one of the boys, for instance, was sent papers refusing him refugee status that detailed a journey through Turkey that he did not make; they were obviously someone else’s. But, more generally, their experience was one of what Bourdieu (1991) would identify as symbolic violence; small administrative acts such as sending documentation in English, knowing the boys would not understand it.

The response from our own profession of social work has been very mixed. While Faisal’s first allocated social worker went out of her way to find out about his cultural background and needs, she retired and subsequent workers just did not seem to be aware of the importance of doing so. But perhaps more concerning was the lack of any institutional awareness of the asylum-seeking boys’ unique situations. An example might be of one of them, placed in a group home, who went to visit friends in a neighboring city. He missed the last train back and phoned to say he would return the following morning. Despite knowing this and knowing where he was, the home applied missing persons protocols and informed the police, who visited several homes in the city he was visiting looking for him. Two police officers turned up at our house the following morning to speak to Faisal who had been the last person to have spoken to his friend who, by this time, was on his way home. You can imagine the incomprehension Faisal experienced in being faced with police officers concerned that a boy who had traversed Africa and Europe for 18 months might be unsafe among fellow countrymen in a Scottish city 50 miles away!

On another occasion, several of the boys were reported to the police for shaving their heads, mostly out of boredom, lest their actions were indicative of radicalization, which has become a political concern across much of Europe. This is what happens when we look to dubious concepts such as radicalization (McKendrick & Finch, 2017); we start to treat people as categories, the missing person, the radicalized youth, and when we blindly follow rules rather than seeking to understand individuals in their unique situations. One might also ponder whether ascribing such terminology could potentially introduce a political dimension to actions that would otherwise have remained in the realm of everyday messing about. It would be understandable that Muslim youth might come to recognize a political side to their experience when subject to such crass institutional practice. 

Discursive Lacunae

A further troubling feature of social work’s professional response is around its fixation with Western theories of child development and, in particular, ideas of attachment and trauma, which do not apply universally (Burman, 2016). In our case, it was a default assumption from laypeople and professionals alike that Faisal must, inevitably, be traumatized. But trauma is an ill-defined concept only really evident in its symptoms and there were few if any in Faisal’s case. He slept well, he was focussed on school, engaged in activities and was able to make and, although very shy, to sustain friendships. A doctor told us he must be traumatized and the symptoms would emerge at some point, but over three years in, we are still waiting. Of course, he has had experiences that were terrifying, but he is not traumatized. This observation actually has wider empirical support in a range of studies of refugee children (Summerfield, 2000). Despite this evidence, it is fascinating how a trauma perspective should take precedence over that formed through the experience of everyday care sustained over a prolonged period. This highlights the knowledge hierarchies in favor of what is imagined to be ‘hard’ psychologized approaches over everyday care when it comes to looking after kids.

In the UK, the latest incarnation of trauma’s empire (Fassin & Rechtman, 2014) converges around Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACES) (Felitti et al, 1998). As foster carers, we were invited to a training session on ACEs. As a framework for understanding the impact of early experience on current functioning, this is problematic in the best of circumstances (Edwards et al, 2017). Applied to asylum seeking kids it is at best unthinking but, more, broadly, might indicate social work’s complicity in oppressive and racist practices (Masocha & Simpson, 2011) for, in assuming past harm, it locates this within intra-familial difficulties (which, for most of those we know, were actually very good) and takes no account of the real reasons for their situations which are located in rapacious global capitalism, corrupt government and out-of-control security forces, none of which not feature in the ACEs framework! More generally, the default turn to ACEs and trauma perspectives in delivering training to carers provides an insight into the image of the child promulgated by the social work profession. It is an image of the ‘child in need’, haunted and held back by past experience.

This is in stark contrast to the ‘rich child’ of social pedagogic discourse, which recognises that children ‘have endless potential and capacities, are competent and resourceful, actively engage with and influence their surroundings’ (Eichsteller, nd). The very fact that Faisal and others are with  us and successfully marking out and negotiating new lives for themselves is testimony to the richness and fortitude of children and youth – we do them no favours by transposing Western ideas of trauma upon them.

None of this is to minimize the experience of asylum-seeking kids and, certainly, as parents, we found it hard to contemplate the hurt of separation from their families experienced by Faisal and his friends.

However, we came to realise that we were transposing our own assumptions and expectations of family life onto a very different context. It is only recently, having re-established contact with his mother after four years, that Faisal told us that we just did not understand just how different things were in his country and religion. Losing a son in conflict ridden societies (and in Faisal’s case in circumstances where his mother had no idea what had happened to him) was not the unimaginable catastrophe that we would experience it as, but was a fact of life for very many families, and parents are sustained in their grief but also their hope by a faith that what was happening was Allah’s will. Islam holds out the promise and certainty of the afterlife rendering this life and its problems as merely steps along the road to the next and thus able to be made sense of.

Islam

Deference to Allah’s will nor indeed Islam’s certainty did not always sit comfortably with me. I could absolutely understand the religion’s cultural significance in maintaining individual and collective identities for a group of dislocated boys. And I could understand how the certainty of its beliefs might be fundamental to their survival and fortitude. On the other hand, I feel uncomfortable with Islam’s railing against modernity and the decadence it ascribes to Western culture. In such a worldview, sexual morality would seem to subsume other moral considerations to the extent that it is substantially constitutive of Muslim identity in the West. The focus on personal morality also seemed to take precedence over the kind of pastoral concern that one might have looked for from the mosque in response to asylum-seeking youngsters, but that we did not see.

The extent of the cultural gulf between Islam and my own religious social and cultural traditions have confronted me, at one level, with what the philosopher Ron Barnett (2004) identifies as a sense of existential ‘strangeness’. For me, I have found this sense of strangeness stimulating. But, we could only begin to imagine what it must have felt like to Faisal, coming to a country where he had to encounter overwhelming whiteness but even down to attempting to work out who this unknown family was that he was expected to go and live with and what the status of that relationship might be.

Coming to terms with this strangeness has required, on our part, qualities of curiosity and cultural humility, which Hook et al describe as the ‘ability to maintain an inter-personal stance that is other-oriented (or open to the other) in relation to aspects of cultural identity’ (2013, p. 2). This, in turn, requires an ongoing reflexive quality that involves interpretation of what might be going on in an encounter set against the interplay of past and present but also encompassing what I bring to the situation through pre-judgements born out of my own experience, all within a recursive process of interpretation and reflection. This might be understood through reference to Gadamer’s (1975) development of the idea of the hermeneutic circle, which involves a constant fusing of horizons between past and present, the particular and the general.

Over time and prompted by family members, I realized that perhaps this strangeness is a little less strange than I may have first thought and may be partly a matter of degree. They pointed out to me the resonances between Islamic injunctions on sexual morality and even food practices with my own Catholic past, which I had to recognize – perhaps it was aspects of that I was railing against. But it was not just at a level of institutional religion that experiences were not quite as strange as they might, on the surface have been. Doucet (2008) talks of the gossamer walls through which we begin to discern images of ourselves in the object or subject of our research, or in this case in our daily living. Despite our radically different experiences regarding age, geography and cultural tradition, I could begin to identify aspects of myself in some of Faisal’s traits and dispositions. We were both oldest children, with the sense of responsibility, inhibition and shyness that might go along with that, albeit these were amplified in Faisal’s case. It was perhaps these spectral connections that have allowed us to make some sort of relationship whereby we can begin to make some sense of one another however tentative and incomplete.

Some concluding thoughts

As mentioned earlier, autoethnography seeks to bring the personal to bear on wider cultural experience. In this concluding section, I offer some thoughts as to what our experience might illuminate in respect of caring for asylum seeking and refugee youth. Firstly, it has reinforced my belief that care is a practical moral task undertaken, not through any fancy therapeutic interventions but through joint involvement and presence in everyday life. Pithouse and Rees identify the essence of foster care as happening ‘within the interdependencies and everyday moral “workings out” between people in caring relationships. These relationships emerge from care itself as a social process and daily human activity in which the self exists through and with others’ (2011, p. 196). Care, they go on to assert, is demonstrated in broadly cultural and practical actions such as the symbolism of food, issues of the body and aspects of touch. This is a far more apposite description of the task than any that is couched in terms of the myriad psychological interventions that characterise much present-day discourse around foster care. Adopting Pithouse and Rees’ description of care might lead to carers striving for a process that involves the recursive interplay of interpretation and understanding rather than more conventional and seemingly expert notions of assessment and treatment. This involves a phenomenological fusion of horizons between past and present, between the immediate and the more general, between the personal and the cultural. It also involves a reflexive awareness of self and of the relationship of self to the Other within a context of the ungraspable alterity of such relationships.

This calls for a reorientation of the way that we think about care. It demands an understanding of why care might be necessary, a call to care, and openness, curiosity and confidence in offering care within youngsters’ life worlds. These are qualities that many possess but may be put off from offering through the narrow and restrictive assumptions about care imposed by the current system.

References

Barnett, R. (2004). Learning for an unknown future. Higher Education Research & Development, 23(3), 247–260.

Bauman, Z. (2016). Strangers at our door. John Wiley & Sons.

Bourdieu, P. 1991, Language and Symbolic Power, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press. Burman, E. (2016). Deconstructing developmental psychology. London, Routledge.

Dorrer, N., McIntosh, I., Punch, S., & Emond, R. (2010). Children and food practices in residential care: Ambivalence in the ‘institutional’ home. Children's Geographies, 8(3), 247-259.

Doucet, A. (2008). “From her side of the gossamer wall (s)”: reflexivity and relational knowing. Qualitative Sociology, 31(1), 73-87.

Edwards et al (2017) ‘The Problem with ACEs’. Edwards et al.’s submission to the House of Commons Science and Technology Select Committee Inquiry into the evidence-base for early years intervention (EY10039).

Eichsteller, G (n/d) Social Pedagogy and the Rich Child: Helping children unfold their potential, available https://www.academia.edu/15752578/Social_Pedagogy_and_the_Rich_Child_Helping_childr en_unfold_their_potential accessed 2nd May 2020

Ellis, C. (2007). Or 2017? P. 5 Telling Secrets, Revealing Lives: Relational Ethics in Research With Intimate Others. Qualitative Inquiry, 13(1), 3–29.

Ellis, C., Adams, T. E., & Bochner, A. P. (2011). Autoethnography: an overview. Historical social research/Historische sozialforschung, 273-290.

Fassin, D and Rechtman, R. (2009) The Empire of Trauma: An Inquiry into the Condition of Victimhood, Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.

Felitti, V. J., Anda, R. F., Nordenberg, D., Williamson, D. F., Spitz, A. M., Edwards, V., & Marks, J. S. (1998). Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. American journal of preventive medicine, 14(4), 245-258.

Fewster, G. (2001) Morality, empathy and sexuality. Journal of Child and Youth Care, 14(4): 1–16. Fulcher, L. C. (2003). Rituals of encounter that guarantee cultural safety. Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 16, 20-27.

Gadamer, H. (1975) Truth and method. New York, NY: Seabury Press.

Garfat, T. (1998) The effective child and youth care intervention: a phenomenological inquiry. Journal of Child and Youth Care, Vol. 12. No. 1-2.

Hook, J. N., Davis, D. E., Owen, J., Worthington Jr., E. L., & Utsey, S. O. (2013). Cultural humility: Measuring openness to culturally diverse clients. Journal of Counseling Psychology, 60, 353–366.

Houston, S. (2012) ‘Jurgen Habermas’ pp 13-24 in Gray, M., & Webb, S. (Eds.). (2012). Social work theories and methods. London, Sage.

Kohli, R. K., Connolly, H., & Warman, A. (2010). Food and its meaning for asylum seeking children and young people in foster care. Children's Geographies, 8(3), 233-245.

Macfarlane, B. (2010). Researching with integrity: The ethics of academic enquiry. London, Routledge.

McKendrick, D., & Finch, J. (2017). Under heavy manners?’: Social work, radicalisation, troubled families and non-linear war. The British Journal of Social Work, 47(2), 308-324.

Masocha, S. & Simpson, M. (2011) Xenoracism: Towards a Critical Understanding of the Construction of Asylum Seekers and its Implications for Social Work Practice, Practice, 23: 1, 5-18

Mollenhauer, K. (2013). Forgotten connections: On culture and upbringing. London, Routledge.

Pithouse, A., & Rees, A. (2011). Care as regulated and care in the obdurate world of intimate relations: Foster care divided? Ethics and Social Welfare, 5(2), 196-209.

Rees, A., Holland, S., & Pithouse, A. (2012). Food in foster families: care, communication and conflict. Children & society, 26(2), 100-111.

Ricks, F. (1992) A Feminist's View of Caring, Journal of Child and Youth Care 7(2) pp 49-57 Smith, M. (2013). Forgotten connections: reviving the concept of upbringing in Scottish child welfare. Scottish Journal of Residential Child Care, 12(2), 13-29.

Standish, P. (2005). Towards an economy of higher education. Critical Quarterly, 47(1-2), 53-71. Steckley, L. (2005) ‘Just a game? The therapeutic potential of football’. In: D. Crimmens and I. Milligan, eds. Facing Forward: Residential Child Care in the 21st Century, Russell House Publishing, Lyme Regis, pp. 137-147.

Summerfield, D. (2000). Childhood, War, Refugeedom and ‘Trauma’: Three Core Questions for Mental Health Professionals. Transcultural Psychiatry, 37(3), 417–433.

 

This article was originally published in Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 33, No.2, pp50-65

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App