CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 274 DECEMBER 2021

Owning It

Hans Skott-Myhre

Sometimes apparently good news is more complicated than you think. Here in the second decade of the 21st century, the world we live in is so full of contradictions, antagonisms, and oxymoronic formulations that our ability to draw a straight line from one point to the other is often extremely difficult. Part of the reason for this is that the discourses of our time are saturated with layer after layer of sheer perversity. That is to say that meanings emerge and dissolve at such speed as to make us dizzy as we attempt to discern what might actually make sense. We are lied to, and lie to ourselves, in stories that tangle and untangle, unravel and spin, cast webs that dissolve upon contact, and weave tales so full of holes as to become invisible upon any kind of close examination. In short, our ability to reason is profoundly impacted by what Spinoza would call the superstitions of our time.

One of those superstitions is the belief that we can escape the consequences of our history through partial or complete refusal. In other words, that we can rewrite the past in such a way as to step aside from any accountability we might have here in the present. We can act as though we have the innocence that is sufficient to go on as though we have a full right to everything we can accumulate and own. That whatever brought us to this point of enfranchisement is simply an act of grace, in which we are gifted by whatever divine force to live the life we have. In this way of thinking, we don’t have any real responsibility to the past, but perhaps more importantly, we have little or no responsibility to how we are producing the present either. And oddly enough, this kind of dissimulation makes the future utterly opaque, in terms of how our current mode of life might shape the world for future generations.

There is a moment in Antonio Negri’s book Art and the Multitude, where he is writing to his former comrades who had been involved in revolutionary activity in Italy in the 1970’s. The revolution has failed, and he is writing from prison where he has been sentenced to serve time for an assassination he didn’t commit. Negri notes that his comrades have become dispirited about the failure of the revolt and the way in which Italy and the world have succumbed to capitalist values. His comrades are bemoaning the inherent injustice of the failure of their revolutionary project and expressing cynicism about the state of things and how the future is unfolding. Negri admonishes them for their idealism and reminds them that, as revolutionaries, there is no room for idealistic visions of what could have been. He argues that he and his comrades created the revolution, and it was their tactics and strategies that led to its failure. He tells them that, as Marxists, it is essential that their actions be dealt with on strictly materialistic terms.

He reminds them that, according to Marx, we create the conditions of the world in which we live. If we have created a world with which we are dissatisfied, it is up to us to create a new world, not bemoan an ideal world that never existed. This is the basis of the struggle for new worlds and new peoples. The future must be founded and rooted in the actuality of current material conditions. We must be accountable to the effects of our actions, both in their failure as well as their success. There is no room for stepping aside from the accountability we have, to continue to act in ways that change the world as it is now, not as we wish it to be or as we imagine it was.

This insistence on accountability to the actuality of the world as it is, is consistent with Negri’s larger political project that sources its materials, both physical and intellectual, from the world as it is lived and produced now. There is no nostalgia for a past world, nor any denial of the depth of struggle to be engaged in cobbling together the elements of life around us into configurations of a world to come. Nothing should be discarded that could be turned to revolutionary purpose. This is not a call, however, to deny our history. Instead, it is a reminder that our history is never lived in the past. We create our history as we live its effects in the present. In that sense, how we articulate and account for the effects of history now is what matters.

I was reminded of this, when I heard a Ted Talk by Indigenous activist Nikki Sanchez on decolonization. In her talk she tells us that, for settlers, “this history is not your fault, but it is your responsibility.” Obviously, the current generation of settlers were not there during what was arguably the most brutal periods of genocide and land theft. But we are here now as beneficiaries of land theft, slavery, and the attempted erasure of Indigenous peoples. Our current way of life is saturated with the blood of those our ancestors enslaved, killed, robbed, and marginalized to the hardest and most desolate fringes of the land we stole. As Negri points out, we must take a full accounting of the current effects of our history. What level of suffering and hardship still endures as the legacy of settler actions? History is never in the past. It is always created over and over in every moment of the present in both material and ideological terms. The brutality of our past actions is only matched by the brutality of our current levels of denial.

As it happens, I live in the part of the world where the ethnic cleansing of Indigenous people from the east coast, of what is now commonly known as the United States, began. Just down the road is a beautiful nature reserve called McIntosh Reserve. It is named after the Indigenous chief, slave holder, and early capitalist William McIntosh Jr. In 1825, McIntosh signed the second treaty of Indian Springs which sold all Creek land in Georgia and Alabama to the state of Georgia. The sale was against tribal law. Indeed, any land sale of Creek land was a capital offense, McIntosh was assassinated for the sale, but it went forward, and the Creek people were relocated initiating what came to be known as the trail of tears.

The trail of tears today would be called ethnic cleansing. Under President Andrew Jackson, all Indigenous people were forcibly relocated to the Oklahoma Territory against their will and without any legal recourse.

The supreme court ruled Jackson’s action illegal, but he proceeded nonetheless. This ethnic cleansing of Georgia allowed for settlers to make the land claims that laid the foundation for the expansion of slavery and the plantation economy that followed. It is a shameful and bloody history without which no one living in Georgia today could have the way of life we now enjoy.

It is one of many perversities, that on this ethnically cleansed land, the descendants of settlers have named so many places and communities with mispronounced and misunderstood Indigenous names. Equally appalling is the naming of Atlanta’ baseball team, the “Braves,” complete with stadiums of settler descendants making mockery of Indigenous chants and doing the “tomahawk chop” on the very land that was stolen and ethnically cleansed. It is a savage repudiation of any form of accountability, however symbolic, for a brutal and ignominious history.

To be so willfully and publicly oblivious is stunning. Of course, this sort of performance is not limited to the American South or even the United States. The settler capacity for an infinitude of acts of aggressive denial is a daily occurrence across the landscape of global capitalism. Such acts may appear to have no discernable effect on the inheritors of the settler legacy. After all, the beat of global capital beats strongly in the hearts of its subjects. As settlers, we are quite attached to what was stolen on our behalf. We are fierce in our sense of ownership and entitlement.

That said, I do worry that every act of willful denial and coded celebration of genocide has a corrosive effect on the spirit of settler people. In a way, over hundreds of years it has little by little hollowed us out. We are in many ways the Hollow Men of T.S. Elliot’s poem,

Shape without form, shade without colour,

Paralysed force, gesture without motion;

. . .

Remember us-if at all-not as lost Violent souls, but only

As the hollow men 

It is precisely this hollowness that the foundations of CYC in phenomenology and existentialism was designed to remediate. These philosophies at the heart of humanistic psychology focused on the encounter between living subjects as an invigorating exchange intended to awaken our common interests and the power of transformational investments of mutual and reciprocal care. Regrettably, the initial political impetus of figures such as Sartre, with his warnings of bad faith, were largely betrayed by psychological investments in self-actualization, rather than social revolution. A kind of narcissistic investiture of self-care replaced what Sartre called for in owning the actions that form our life and our world. We might surmise that his intentions were far greater than becoming a well-cared for bourgeois consumer of psychotherapy and self-help. Indeed, the project of the radical figures that informed the foundations of CYC was centered on taking a profound accountability for creation of the world. Of course, this can all be minimized into more digestible pablum that mistakes accountability for consequences and existential crisis for mental illness.

There is little doubt in my mind that such thinking is leading us down the path to social, cultural, and physical suicide. As a citizenry saturated in the logic of global capitalism, we carry with us a socially encoded cultural DNA that shapes our thinking in profoundly dangerous patterns. Certainly, one of the more perverse modes of thought that permeates what we might call the settler unconscious is the idea of ownership. The belief that it is possible to own the soil, the forests, rivers, mountains, crops, buildings, and even each other, has been central to the settler project. Without it, capitalism would not exist and slavery, ethnic cleansing, and land theft would be impossible. Property ownership is an idea deeply rooted in the settler perception of the world and our place in it. Perversely it even shapes our methods of repatriation and reconciliation.

I mentioned at the beginning of this piece that in our current society even good news can be complicated. This is certainly true when we apply settler logic to projects ostensibly rooted in social justice. I was reminded of this, when I saw a recent story about an African American family (the Bruce family) who purchased a tract of ocean front property in Los Angeles in 1912 in order to provide a beach front resort for Black families. From the beginning they were harassed by the Klu Klux Klan and their white neighbors, until the city of Los Angeles seized the land through a process of imminent domain in 1924. In 2021, the City of Los Angeles returned the land to the descendants of the original African American family. The decision was hailed as a victory for socially just repatriation. After the vote by the city council LA County District supervisor Janice Hahn stated that

When I realized that the county now had ownership of the Bruce's original property, I felt there was nothing else to do but give the property back to the direct descendants of Willa and Charles Bruce . . . I hope that other cities, other counties, and other states will see what we are doing here . . . And I hope that they will be inspired to look at their own histories and identify opportunities to begin to repair and make amends for injustices like these.

Of course, this sounds wonderful. But I would argue that it is saturated in colonial settler logic about land ownership. The land can’t be given by the county, because the county never owned it. The land was never ceded to the United States by Indigenous treaty. It was appropriated from Mexico who inherited it from the colonial incursions of the Spanish. The history here is complex and is full of attempts at ethnic cleansing and genocide. In the end, however, the fact remains that the land was stolen before it was sold to the Bruce family and then stolen back from them before being returned. Before we can accept the justice of Bruce family land repatriation, we must understand that it obscures an older injustice.

In this one example we can see layer upon layer of settler brutality that extends over hundreds of years, disenfranchises Indigenous and Black people, and then erases one set of injustices in order to attempt to address another. The one thing that is not addressed in this story is the question of whether the land can be owned at all. There is never a question as to whether the governance structures of settler ownership are foundationally illegitimate. The assumption is that the land is owned and therefore can be transacted. Nowhere in this attempt at repatriation are Indigenous peoples consulted or even mentioned. They are once again ethnically cleansed through omission.

Of course, we as CYC workers and scholars are subject to similar modes of erasure and omission. Our work is saturated with implied and overt notions of ownership of our bodies, our programs, our institutions, our field, our writings, and so on. We implicitly and explicitly indoctrinate the young people in our care in the narcissistic investments of self care and an almost fierce ownership of identity and personal property. I would suggest that if we seriously mean to do the complex and nuanced work of socially just practice, we might begin with an examination of the foundational logic of the settler project in private property and ownership. Until and unless we do, our work will be at best incomplete and at worst foundationally corrupt. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App