At what point will be ready to acknowledge that the world we lived in no longer is the world our young people will navigate? As we approach the end of 2021, a year that started with a great deal of
hope after 2020 took us by surprise with its thoroughly negative pandemic developments, we realize that this year was no better, and perhaps much worse for most people around the world. Of course, there have been difficult years before this pandemic; and there have been other developments around the world that seemed to transform our social reality. We can think of World Wars, the Cold War, the fear of nuclear annihilation, the collapse of communism, and many other things. But at least over the course of the past fifty years or so, there was some consistency in what was happening around the world, not all of which was pretty. With the rise of neoliberalism, it felt like a slow decay of human spirit, love and care, but one in which one could still carve out spaces for social justice and hope. I think we are about to enter an entirely different world (really, we have already entered it), and this makes me wonder how we can prepare our youth to navigate in that new world and what exactly the responsibilities of child and youth care as a way of being in the world, and as a professional field of practice, might be.
At a macro level, we have at least three developments that are fundamentally changing how we live together as communities and societies in local, transnational and global contexts. The first of these is of course the pandemic itself. I think we are pretty clear now that this is not a temporary phenomenon that we can simply incorporate into our daily lives much like we did with influenza and many other contagious health hazards. My most optimistic prognosis is that we will experience waves of worrisome case levels for at least another five years, with the Global South clearly and unequivocally in a worse position. Realistically, I think it will take much longer to find stability in the face of this public health hazard, and pessimistically, I worry that by the time corona virus settles down, another public health crisis will emerge and replace it. We may have reached a threshold within the nature-humanity relationship in which bio-health hazards are simply going to be a permanent feature of life on the planet. At the very least, our sense of precarity of life from the threat of biohazards is something we will live with for generations to come.
The second development that I think is quite transformative for how we live life, and for how our young people will live their lives, is the decline of liberal democracy everywhere. I remember when the American author and historian Francis Fukuyama proclaimed “the end of history” in the early nineties, based on his analysis that no matter what sort of system of government was in place anywhere in the world, everywhere people claimed to either be or to aspire to become liberal democracies. Even at that time, this idea seemed absurd; much of the world did not at all look like liberal democracy. But what is changing right now, and very rapidly, is that even the idea of liberal democracy, characterized by stable and transparent structures, institutions, and political processes, is no longer the central idea driving political cultures, much less political processes. Those countries most closely associated with liberal democracy, such as the United States, much of central and southern Europe, Australia, New Zealand, Japan, and my country Canada, have largely abandoned any pretense to the integrity of democratic action, as evidenced by the intentional manipulation of physical and virtual realities and facts, the spectacle of lies, deception and corruption at the highest levels of government, and the continued empowerment, and their total entanglement, of corporate interests over public governance.
And the third development that dominates news cycles and yet seems completely irrelevant in terms of coordinated action, is of course climate change. We can see the impacts of climate change very clearly and very dramatically, most of which associated with extreme weather incidents that are wiping out individuals by the thousands, entire communities, as well as eco-systems we rely on to produce food. Climate change is driving migration patterns, generating famines, wiping out the life spaces of Indigenous peoples everywhere, and, just as a minor addition, sinking entire island nations in the South Pacific.
There is of course a lot more happening in the world that is of concern, including the digitization of social relations, the hyper-liberalism of transnational capital, the violence and polarization associated with immigration and new diversities, and more. The difference between all of those things and the three I identified above is that we have a way of navigating, resisting, and fighting against those things, at least at local levels; but we really have nothing to offer in the context of biohazards and the crash of any semblance of balance in the nature-humanity relationship, the decline of liberal democracy and climate change. These things are just happening, and for the most part, as child and youth care professionals, theorists, and researchers, we have stayed silent and made few adjustments to how we think about our field.
What can we do? Where do we go from here?
The short answer is that we really cannot remain complacent in the face of these changes. By complacency I don’t mean that we, as individuals, remain idle in our own responses to these developments. I mean instead that child and youth care, what it stands for and what it aspires to accomplish, needs to adjust to the changing world. In many respects, the field has already done that in some parts of the Global South, where much of child and youth care practice is really a driving force in national development. In South Africa and elsewhere, child and youth care has had an impact not only on the lives of millions of young people, but it has also generated a new social movement, a child and youth care workforce that lives life and pushes community differently than it is being pushed by shifting, largely corrupt, and definitely not democratic governments. Child and youth care is actively engaged with climate change, seeking new ways of designing communities to become resilient in the face of the consequences of climate change. And although the pandemic is wreaking havoc on the country itself, child and youth care in South Africa is drawing on its experience, and some would say its foundation, in the context of the HIV epidemic that has plagued the country for three decades and more now. Perhaps most importantly, in South Africa child and youth care is recognized not only by the field’s leaders but also by its practitioners and the communities they are connected to, as a source of hope and optimism. Despite everything, humanity and care might just stay the course in spite of active efforts to dissolve these.
But no such thing is happening in the Global North. We continue to reference community here and there, but primarily structure our engagement within our field through the institutional and quasi-institutional structures provided by child welfare, mental health and health care systems, and youth criminal justice systems, as well as within the broader context of public education systems. In Canada, students do their placements overwhelmingly in schools, group homes, hospitals and recreation centres. In their courses, they learn about things like social ecologies, child and youth rights, residential care and treatment, evidence-based practices, trauma-informed practices, and more. These are all great topics, but none take account of a changing world. In fact, in the Global North we teach these things, and practitioners practice these things, as if our youth were growing up and ultimately entering a life in democratic contexts, where public health is more or less stable, and where it may rain once in a while, but life itself is not directly related to mass flooding, hurricanes, draughts, poisoned water supplies, and other calamities. We still practice as if these things are extreme exceptions, perhaps more prevalent in the rest of the world, but not here.
I think this is short-sighted. The side-effects of the drivers of change are mass migration and its associated racism, extreme social inequalities, community violence, gender violence, and economies that are increasingly returning to the split of the ultra-rich and the devastatingly poor with impunity. Culturally and politically, we are seeing our societies polarized like they have never been before, and every indication is that such polarization is increasing and deepening.
Sure, we can talk about social justice. We can pretend that our focus on rights-based approaches will somehow move governments to enact different policies. We can retreat to the interpersonal context of relationships in the hopes that young people won’t notice that interpersonal relationships have a different role in societies that are not democratic, that don’t center care, and that are happy to stimulate the violence that comes with polarization. We can pretend that we are contributing to de-colonizing practice, to reconciliation and to anti-racism. But I am not sure we are at the moment. In fact, I think we are losing ground, becoming mere pawns in a changing world in which our relevance is highly questionable.
I believe we need new concepts, or at the very least, adapt the ones we have to a changing world. Again, the Global South has been dealing with all of this and the consequences of colonization and histories of genocide and oppression on top of that for decades. But in the Global North, we are toying with young people, offering our practices while surely knowing that nothing we are doing right now will prepare them to navigate what is to come. At a time when we are barely able to keep it together in the face of this pandemic and its consequences, we must rethink what we can bring to the table. We need concepts of relationship and relational practice, care and caring, engagement and participation, rights and civic belonging that are fit for a world in which formal structures are shifting quickly away from all of these things. Abuse and private experiences of violence will continue to be sources of trauma for young people. But state violence, climate change, and biohazards will take that trauma to a whole new level. Just ask Indigenous people; or the Black diaspora in North America; or any social group that has been made to watch the disappearing of their culture, land, identity, and future. They will tell you that under these kinds of conditions, what we talk about does not reflect their lives.
It’s December. Usually for December, I try to stay positive and end with “Happy Holidays everyone!” But this year, we can’t afford to start thinking about something different in January. We should start right now. Because if not this year, soon enough Christmas, Hanukkah, Kwanza and whatever other winter holiday you might celebrate, will just get cancelled.
I wish you peace and wellbeing.