CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 154 DECEMBER 2011

Choice, Empowerment, and Relationships

John Stein

I occasionally see an article advising parents that one way to avoid power struggles with their children is to give them choices. When dressing for school in the morning, “Do you want to wear this white shirt or this blue shirt?” Or at bedtime, “Do you want to brush your teeth before your show or after?” The first choice works pretty well because mom is holding both shirts. A clear and simple choice. (Some children I know will always want another shirt. “No. I want my pink shirt.” That can be OK, too. The child still made a choice instead of simply objecting to everything Mom chooses.)

The second choice can be a little more difficult. Greene (1998) tells of Danny, who regularly had a major meltdown over brushing his teeth. Nothing seemed to work. Finally, his mother asked him why he hated to brush his teeth. His answer: he couldn’t get the toothpaste onto his tooth brush. His little hands had not the strength nor the coordination to manage a task that seems so simple to the rest of us. Consequently, he did not have a choice he could manage. No choices, before or after his show, nor any other choices, were within his ability. He could not brush his teeth because he could not put toothpaste onto his toothbrush. The solution was simple. Mom decided she would put the toothpaste on his toothbrush. Then he had no trouble brushing his teeth and did so happily ever after, eventually becoming mature enough to master getting his own toothpaste. It not only solved the problem but also improved their relationship. Mom became a helpful ally instead of a coercive, insensitive ogre.

A professor of social work I knew in the 1980’s used to talk about empowerment rather than therapy, on empowering people to improve their lives rather than treating them for some disorder — not only the type of empowerment wherein people organize and march on City Hall to get their needs met but also the type of empowerment wherein people develop their abilities and skills to meet their own needs.

How many times do we demand that children behave, devising schemes to ‘incentivize’ or ‘consequate’ them? (My spell check does not recognize these words. They do not appear in my old collegiate dictionary, although I was able to find ‘incentivize in an online dictionary. But I could not find ‘consequate’ anywhere, even online. It is not a word. Where did these ‘words’ come from?)

What if all we have to do is simply to help children to develop the skills they need in order to behave well rather than struggling to find ways to motivate and coerce them with consequences, e.g., rewards and punishments?

Consider the child who is rude and demanding and abrupt. What if he simply never learned the skills and habits associated with being polite. In my culture, being polite means maintaining eye contact. In some other cultures, being polite means lowering ones eyes and avoiding eye contact. Then, being polite requires using polite greetings and titles and words with an appropriate voice tone: good morning, good evening, please, thank you, may I, excuse me, I’m sorry, etc. Knowing when to make or avoid eye contact and for how long is a skill. It requires practice in a safe environment. Saying the words, well, any child who speaks the language knows these words. But knowing when and how to use them is a skill that needs to be developed into a habit, as is using them with an appropriate voice tone and inflection. When a child is faced with a difficult emotional situation and the appropriate words do not come while inappropriate words flood his mind, well, we’ve all seen what happens in such cases. And when the appropriate words do come but the child uses them with sarcastic, oppositional, or defiant voice tones, well, we’ve all seen that, too.

Some of these skills we tend to take for granted, feeling that everyone has them. Really, how hard is it to say ‘please’ and ‘thank you?’ But children who have not spent as much time living in ‘polite society’ as others have may not be quite so comfortable with these skills as the rest of us. It may be much more difficult for them to behave ‘politely,’ especially in emotionally challenging situations. To put it another way, behaving well may not be an option for them, a choice that is readily available to them. When we teach them the skills, including providing ample opportunities for practice, we are empowering them with an additional choice. Then, they have choices. They may choose to behave politely, but they may also still choose to behave impolitely, telling someone to stuff pennies up her nose, or whatever else comes to mind.

Temper Control

Consider children who have problems with controlling their tempers. What choices do we give them? Don’t yell, don’t scream, don’t curse, don’t slam doors, don’t throw things, don’t smash things, don’t hit, don’t kick, don’t spit, don’t ... There’s no choice in there. Just control your behaviour. And suppress your feelings. I have known children who were experts in controlling their behaviour and suppressing their feelings. Eventually, perhaps due to fatigue or just being overwhelmed, they lost control and the dam broke. They became so out-of-control that it looked very much like a psychotic break. It didn’t happen often, but when it did, it was monumental. Such children often get the diagnosis of Intermittent Explosive Disorder and the search for medication that diagnoses often produce. I have not seen medication help with Intermittent Explosive Disorder. I have never seen it solve the ‘problem.’ The problem is not biological or wilful. Rather, the problem is a lack of reasonable alternatives, of choices.

But what choice can we give them? How about, “Tell someone calmly why you are angry”? That gives them a choice. Provided that there is someone available to listen calmly and provided that they have sufficient opportunities to develop and practice the skill of talking calmly about feeling angry. It requires lots and lots of practice in a safe environment. It is a most difficult skill to master. (My wife will tell you that I have yet to master it.)

Further, mastering the skill is compounded by the obsessive desire of some adults to ensure that every misbehaviour receives appropriate punishment. Oops, I meant ‘consequence.’ For example, when we are encouraging children to learn to tell someone calmly why they are angry, i.e., to express their anger verbally rather than by hitting and kicking and biting and spitting, then screaming and cursing may be a successive approximation for talking about their anger instead of hitting and kicking and biting and spitting. If we punish children for cursing, are we not in effect punishing their success in using words instead of hitting and all that. So, do we let them get away with cursing? I don’t think so. But I also don’t think that just because we impose no punishment that it means we are letting them get away with inappropriate language. We have to provide reinforcement for choosing verbal behaviour, no matter how aggressive, over physically aggressive behaviour. “I could see you were very, very angry. Yet you refrained from hitting anyone or busting the place up. If you can keep this up, we’ll be able to work on your language next.” Yet how many times have I seen children pushed over the edge in behaviour programs that emphasize consistency? “That’s Cursing. That’s two points.” Then the child, getting no empathy, curses a bit more. “That’s Cursing. That’s another two points.” Until the child throws a magazine at the staff. “That’s Physical Assault. That’s 16 points and Room Restriction.” And of course a take down and full restraint.

When we empower children by helping them develop their social skills, we give them choices they did not have before. We communicate that we respect children’s abilities to learn to control their own behaviour and make good choices when they can. We become allies in their struggles to master their behaviour and their social environment. We develop relationships based on trust and respect.

When we do not work on helping children develop their skills and abilities, we have little choice but to try to coerce children into behaving in ways that they cannot readily do. Whether we use rewards or punishments, such approaches are coercive and disrespectful. We communicate our belief that children will make good choices only when we reward or punish them. Relationships based on coercion are adversarial. They have little to do with trust or respect.

Accepting Requests and Instructions

Accepting requests or instructions is another social skill that many children have not mastered. There’s more to it than just doing what one is asked or told to do. Sighing, moaning and groaning, rolling eyes, then stomping away banging stuff around makes things miserable for everyone involved, no matter how well the task is completed. Acknowledging the request or instruction pleasantly, then doing it pleasantly and checking back to see whether everything is satisfactory makes things pleasant for the person giving the instruction and is likely to earn a gracious ‘thank you,’ making it pleasant for children, as well.

(One of may favorite staff members was remarkably skilled in accepting requests and instructions from me. He would simply respond, “I’ll be glad to. boss.” I always felt good about it. Interestingly, he very often did not do it. I usually found that he had been doing something else that was equally or more important and ended up doing it myself. But I could never get angry with him. I hired him three times in different agencies.)

Accepting Criticism

Accepting criticism is another skill with which children experience problems, not only from adults but also from peers. Accepting criticism requires no more than acknowledging the criticism. It doesn’t require that one change one’s behaviour, only that one acknowledge understanding the criticism. Arguing, attempting to justify one’s behaviour, becoming defensive, and returning criticism rarely accomplish anything other than making both parties unhappy. Saying, “Ok” often puts the matter to rest, whether or not one chooses to change one’s behaviour. When one chooses to change one’s behavior, things are really good. When doesn’t choose to change, well, the matter is deferred to another day. After all, not all criticism is valid.

In Conclusion

No matter what problems children may have, and no matter how serious they may be, mastering social skills makes their lives much, much better and easier, and leaves them so much more energy to work on other things.

Sadly, I worked in a program where I could not get a social skills curriculum into the milieu. They had a very strict behavioural program on what not to do. It had virtually nothing on what to do. The staff were enforcers, not allies. Their behavioural data showed the psychologists that it worked. The restraint data and the kids showed me that it did not.

This has been my experience, and that of many of my kids.

Reference

Greene, R. W. (1998). The Explosive Child. Harper-Collins: New York.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App