Over the years I have had an opportunity to work in, visit, examine and even evaluate many residential group care programs in many different jurisdictions, including Canada, the United States, Germany and South Africa. I have learned much about these programs and it will come as no surprise to anyone that in spite of my deep desire to see residential group care provide good care and good living conditions for children and youth, I remain critical of much of what I have encountered in this sector. From the physical appearance of many of the programs to the quality of staffing teams, and from the program designs to the incessant need of agencies to exert control over what children and youth do and think, I simply am not convinced at all that we have found a way of providing a home for kids that we, and they, can be proud of. Notwithstanding my misgivings, however, I will not write about the problems of operating group care this month, nor will I criticize what even I recognize to be sincere and well-intentioned efforts on the part of so many professionals to make group care a meaningful and beneficial approach to being with young people.
Instead, I want to articulate what I think is arguably an irresolvable dilemma for residential group care, particularly if we are prepared to think about this from the perspective of the young people themselves.What might the experience be like for a young person admitted to a group home? I would suggest that there are few environments that could possibly offer greater challenges. Here we ask young people to live together with six to ten other young people who they do not know.
Each of those other young people faces his or her own demons, sometimes through the medium of mental health challenges, or resulting from developmental challenges, or, all too often, from the impact of trauma incurred through earlier life experiences. While trying to navigate the challenges of group life, we also expect these young people to take comfort in being cared for by adults who are, at least at first, complete strangers. Amongst those adults will be those who at least appear to be caring and interested, but almost always there will also be those who seem disinterested, perhaps tired, and often not too competent. Sometimes the staff person most trusted calls in sick or goes on vacation, and then the young person must accept care from a relief staff person, someone who may not have been at the homes for days or weeks or perhaps ever. During holidays, the staffing schedules change, the most senior staff get time off, the supervisors are away and even some of the peers might be away on a family visit. From time to time, one of those peers might suddenly be discharged, and a new peer is introduced who might change the established peer dynamics altogether. These social dynamics are unfolding in what are often inadequate physical spaces that offer limited privacy, moderate safety, and furnishings and equipment that are well used, show signs of previous ownership by others and frequently are defective or in a state of disrepair. The neighbourhood is not always welcoming, and sometimes outright hostile. The food, even if attempts are made at maintaining quality and nutritional value, rarely offers the same comfort as a home-cooked meal. The young person has to share the bath-room with many others, deal with someone’s urine on the toilet seat, body hair in the shower, toothpaste stuck to the sink bowl. Every aspect of everyday life is governed by rules, many of which in place to maintain control that is necessary to manage the social and physical context of a building occupied beyond its intended capacity. Many items that would be readily available and accessible in a family home are locked up, including kitchen knives, razors, and sometimes valuable equipment like computers, gaming devices, cell phones, and other gadgets. People who are unknown to the young person walk in and out of the house, usually workers for one of the other kids, repair people hired by the agency, managers dropping by to see what is going on, tours for visitors, researchers, regulatory people like health inspectors, food inspectors, licensing specialists and a host of others. And virtually everything that happens is documented somewhere, including bad moods, performance problems at school or in the program, medication use, and indeed, the young person’s contact with family, friends, workers, doctors, dentists, recreation staff, soccer coach, and whoever else might be involved. The list of strange happenings could go on and on.
None of these things are signs of bad care, or are indicative of poorly functioning programs. These are just the things that happen in the semi-institutional context of residential group care; for the most part, these things are unavoidable, no one’s fault, and ever-repeating themselves. Neither the staff nor the young people can entirely control any of this. Even when everyone tries their best, approaches every day with every intention to be kind, helpful and generous, most or all of these things still happen.
Most of us know that living with others, even with family members, our partners, our own children, perhaps college roommates or good friends, has its challenges. At the best of times, sharing one’s living space can be difficult. But being admitted to a group home is hardly the best of times. Even before ever setting foot into the place, the day of admission is also the day of loss; loss of being at home, loss of the familiar (good or bad), loss of a world that is known and predictable. So what does it take for a young person to manage all of this? What skills, what competencies, what sort of resources will mitigate the challenges associated with that day of admission and the days that follow?
I would suggest that these challenges can only be mitigated through highly developed social skills, an ability to manage the unpredictable, a strong focus on one’s own strengths and capacities and the confidence to draw on these. Surviving these challenges requires excellent decision-making, the ability to think strategically and act both cautiously and courageously. One must be able to navigate multiple priorities, manage multiple loyalties, have the capacity to engage others positively, to initiate meaningful relationships, to draw on strong and healthy attachment habits. In other words, managing the challenges of residential group care, from the perspective of young people, requires strength, wisdom, maturity, and general competence to deal with the unexpected, the annoying, the painful and all things difficult.
But who do we typically admit into residential group care programs? In my experience, when young people demonstrate great competence, social skills, resilience, strength, and all those other characteristics cited above, we do not typically place them in group homes. Instead, they might gain access to a foster home, manage in a kinship care scenario or even receive support for early independence.
The young people we do place in group homes are typically those who have none of these characteristics. They struggle every day with just about everything for all kinds of different reasons. They are reactive, uncertain, scared, and suffer from acute trauma. They channel their insecurities into difficult to manage behaviours, they place themselves in harm’s way, they hurt and are in pain. Many face developmental challenges, concurrent disorders, co-morbid conditions, dual diagnoses. Some are impacted by ASD, others by FASD, and most can point to multiple acronyms in their psychological assessments. Their attachment is insecure and sometimes disassociated. They mistrust (for good reason, usually) adults, authority and even peers.
And yet, they too are resilient, but in their own unique way. Protecting their resilience requires activating their defensive shields the second they arrive for admission, or in many cases, not too long after having been admitted and running out of steam to uphold the pretense of comfort and confidence (sometimes referred to as the honeymoon period). And therein lays the dilemma. On the one hand, these are not the youth who should be placed in the most challenging social context imaginable. Surely it makes no sense to ask the most of those who have the least, to ask the fragile to be strong, to expect the most vulnerable to feel safe, and to hope for the least trusting to trust the power of relationship.
Indeed, it seems almost sadistic to ask the very young people who have been traumatized by relationships in their lives, often the closest and most important relationships in their lives, to then turn around and connect to strangers in a strange setting.
They are to believe that the very process that got them there in the first place (usually the collapse or corruption of relationship, but relationship nevertheless) will now be the process that saves them, further their growth and development and lead them to the much sought after place of emotional and physical safety, comfort and peace.
On the other hand, if not child and youth workers, trained to relationally become engaged with the most vulnerable youngsters, committed to an ethical, professional and also intimate and personal approach to being present, then who could we offer them as possible escapes from misery? If not residential group care, then what? Most of them already experienced failure in other forms of care. Many have travelled through multiple foster homes, various kinship arrangements and sometimes many different couches, basements and sheds in the homes of peers or strangers.
This is a dilemma indeed, and I am not sure we, the practitioners, or they, the young people, can escape it. But I think there is value in remaining conscious of the circumstances. They are not good circumstances. In fact, they are miserable circumstances that call for a level of understanding and empathy that I am not sure we always present to the young people. This dilemma ought to remind us that the task at hand is both profound and profoundly difficult. There is no place for mediocrity, for complacency or for taking for granted the young people’s acceptance of their situations. More than anything else I think this ought to compel us to reverse the increasing entrenchment of a fundamental assumption in residential group care. It is not the young people who need to prove their commitment to the program. It is the practitioners who need to prove they are up to the task.