CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 294 AUGUST 2023

The Power of “Good Enough”

Hans Skott-Myhre

One of the most pernicious and subtle tactics of the current system of domination and control is the perversion of our desires. By desire, I am referring to two quite different expression of the forces that shape what we do and who we think we can become. One of these is founded in the idiosyncratic and unique capacity to live a life of profoundly powerful creative force. This aspect of desire is innate and can be seen easily in the way that an infant explores or encounters the world or a young person sings or dances with abandon in the sheer joy of the moment. It is powerful and responsive to the immediate moment of encounter with the living force of a rich and fecund ecology that flows around us and through us.

The other form of desire is an appropriation and perversion of the first. It is the way that any given system of domination and control makes every effort to turn our desiring capacities to its own ends. This form of social manipulation is what Pignarre and Stengers, following Marx, call a form of magic or sorcery. By this, they are suggesting that the way our desires are stolen from us is by a sleight of hand—a tricky bit of deception. Like all good magic tricks, the appropriation of our desires is accomplished through distraction—the ability to get us to look anywhere but where the trick is taking place.

Of course, this is also the heart of all good con games and we would have to say that the theft of our desires is indeed a form of con game, in which we are fooled into thinking that we are doing what is best for us, when really we are giving away all that is precious to us to a system that will spend every bit of it without any real appreciation for what it is worth. All of which is to say, that the trick is to make us believe that our desiring capacities should be shaped and designed to serve the system first and foremost. The set up for the trick is to convince us that we are inherently flawed and that the only way we can remedy this is through the beneficence of the system of rule in which we are embedded.

This bit of capitalist sorcery has taken a number of different forms over the last 400 years or so. From the production of the work ethic, wherein we have come to believe that our very worth can be defined by how hard and diligently we slave away for the ruling class, to the internalization of the importance of self-discipline or emotional regulation, where we learn to shape our desires and emotions to the dictates of the workplace as the ultimate site of our worthiness. To be a good and reliable worker who comes to work every day and causes no trouble, but gets the job done, has relegated millions to a truncated life of thwarted desire and limited creative possibility.

And yet the trick is so effective, we often seem to be willing participants in our own subjugation. We give the very core of our being, our creative capacity to act and do, to the whims of capitalist production. If they need us to work in the factories for the majority of our adult lives, spending hour after hour producing products in which we have little personal investment, we do that. If we are told we should spend 16 years or more of our lives in a school designed to discipline and shape our bodies and minds to the necessities of corporate production, we do that. If we are needed to answer the phone, peer at a computer screen, solder components onto a circuit board, serve an endless stream of mass-produced food with a smile, we do that and so on. And it is not only our work life, but the very shape and contours of our sexual desires, relationships, and the limits of care are also integrated into the social web of discipline and training in which we are enmeshed.

The first 400 years of capitalist development might well be read as an ever more nuanced and subtle system designed to produce what Foucault called the docile body. That is the body designed as a willing cog in the machinery of production. And, it has been a very successful project inducting most of humanity’s creative force into working for a system that has little or no interest in the well-being of life or living things. The results have been catastrophic in terms of epidemics of loneliness, anxiety, depression, alcoholism, various other addictions, wars, interpersonal violence, despair, and alienation. Not to mention, massive rates of species extinction, rising sea levels, record breaking heat waves, storms, and droughts as a result of the capitalist mode of production for the past four centuries.

Of course, there have revolts and acts of resistance, some of which have had some degree of impact, although not enough to seriously slow the system. However, as we engage the early decades of the 21st century, there are two notable shifts in our set of social coordinates that are worth noting. The first of these is the shift into an increasing virtual mode of production, More and more of what we do is driven by algorithms and virtual technology. This opens new possibilities for capitalist expansion, but also new and perhaps more effective modes of rebellion and resistance. The innovations are technological of course and seem to be expanding at an astonishing rate with unknown implications for who we are to become and what we will be able to do. In the midst of this ever-expanding new world, there are also significant shifts in the ways in which we are being shaped as docile bodies within this emerging phase of capitalist development and I want to turn my attention to one of these.

Towards the end of the 20th century the philosopher Gilles Deleuze wrote a short but extraordinarily prescient  essay called “Postscript on the Society of Control.” In it, he argues that the dominant society has shifted its method for extracting compliance from us. In particular, he noted that we are no longer subjected to the same direct regimes of physical discipline that were the hallmark of industrial capitalist schooling, factories, and families. Instead, Deleuze points to the ways that our lives are more and more controlled by codes that allow us to access levels of inclusion into the increasingly virtual world of the next iteration of capitalist production. He cites social insurance numbers, credit reports, passwords, and passcodes as the new machinery for determining who belongs and who doesn’t. He also delineates a shift from a society that had developmental milestones that signaled social inclusion, such as diplomas, marriage certificates, successful retirement after a lifetime with one company, a mortgage and so on.

Now, he says, we are entering a society in which no one ever arrives. There is no developmental trajectory. Everything is in constant flux and nothing achieves any kind of medium term security. As social subjects we are required to constantly shift and change our positioning by engaging an array of ever proliferating training regimes. No degree is terminal, one must always seek further certificates or higher degrees; no relationship is stable, we must receive ongoing professional advice and training in communication skills, emotional regulation, and intimacy; no job performance is satisfactory, the worker must constantly train and retrain; no financial situation is secure, we must always learn the new algorithms of investment. It is no wonder that our anxiety and sense of imminent failure is epidemic.

In all of this, I would like to focus on one aspect of this rather nasty bit of social engineering and that is the discourse of constant self-improvement. All we need to do is to look around us to see that we are bombarded on all sides by an constant imperative to be all we can be. We must excel and seek to perfect who we are and what we can do. On the surface, this doesn’t seem so bad, After all, what is so wrong with wanting to do better? Indeed, for those of us familiar with the foundations of CYC in the philosophies of humanistic psychology, this is a familiar mantra. The foundational work of Maslow, Rogers, and Pearls are all in some way concerned with self-actualization, expressing ourselves as fully as possible, and fearlessly seizing our potential.

However, there is a very serious difference between the imperatives of virtual capitalism and the possibilities implied by humanistic psychology. For the humanistic psychologists, they imagined that each of us could become self-actualized in ways that freed us from the social controls of the disciplinary society of the 20th century. In the virtual capitalist version, we are inducted into a cycle of self-improvement that entwines us more and more deeply into the control society of the 21st century. This difference is specifically the difference in desire that I noted at the beginning of the column.

The implications for CYC are significant. In the initial development of the field, in the 1960’s and 70’s, practice and organizational structures composed quite a range of what was considered care for young people. The founders themselves tended to be iconoclasts who challenged the delivered wisdom of conventional approaches to working with young people. The imperative was to establish genuine living relationships with the young people we encountered. Even a cursory examination of the key Characteristics of CYC indicates a field interested in complexity and nuance based in self-reflection, rather than meeting constantly shifting external definitions of “better than.” The foundations of the field are premised more in the admonition of Carl Rogers who proposed that self-actualization was not to be found in changing who you are, as much as becoming more of who you actually are. Being all you can be is a powerful perversion of this work, when change is premised in meeting externally determined rubrics of what constitutes good work and best practices.

When I peruse the journals and social media feeds across the field of CYC, I find a landscape of trainings, certificates, calls for professionalism, and all manner of expertise on what is wrong or right about young people today. At times, it seems to be that we have lost faith in ourselves as workers. We just don’t trust ourselves or the young people we work with. The magic trick of capitalist sorcery is in full effect here.

When we see young people who are poorly served by the institutions ostensibly designed to provide care, we seemingly see this as evidence that the workers are not properly or adequately trained. That they need to be professionalized and taught the necessary skill set to do the work. We gear up to train and re-train them; to measure the results of treatment; and to find the evidence that it is all working.

What we fail to take into account is that the game is rigged. The institutions are funded and regulated by a system that has no interest in the well-being of those in care or those doing the work. It is a shell game, in which best practices are moving targets based on algorithms rather than the experiential field of encounter between the worker and those they encounter in the work. No amount of training or professionalization will ever be able to overcome the toxicity of the current socio-political ecology in which our CYC programs are enmeshed. That would require a radical shift that would reassert the primacy of the complex and nuanced set of practices found in the struggle to establish genuine living relations in the work we do.

At the end of the day, perhaps a beginning step would be to step away from the constant demand to get better and better. Maybe, it’s enough to simply do the best you can and pay attention to what is happening in your work as it is. Maybe, we need to explore the power of good enough. Maybe, we don’t need to be superstars. Maybe, we just need to be complicated, struggling, creative, loving, and compassionate people who do the best they can under what are arguably impossible conditions. That kind of self-reflective work can’t be trained, but it can be found in learning from the day to day interactions we have in the work we do and the lives we lead. We can break the spell of capitalist sorcery. The antidote is right in front of our eyes – it is a return to us and nothing more. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App