CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 282 August 2022

How Do We Understand Development Now?

Hans Skott-Myhre

I have been wondering for some time, how the ever shifting world of 21st century capitalism has impacted the bodies that we work with in CYC.

The question is whether the bodies of the young people we serve are, in any meaningful way comprehensible to those of us raised in the late twentieth or even the early decades of the 21st century. Do the frameworks we teach about physical and emotional development still make sense or are we working in an environment in which the very categories of child, adolescent, and adult no longer work in the ways we imagine they should.

Of course there is a substantial literature arguing that these categories are social conventions that really never did describe young people’s bodies in an adequate fashion. In the first-place traditional theories of development have been quite reductive in the ways they teach us about neurology, biochemistry, hormones, and the differing physical capacities of the individual young person.

These developmental approaches to young people’s bodies tend to homogenize them into broad categories that focus on emotional and behavioral aspects that might require intervention by helpful adults. We have used these standardized metrics to measure what we consider to be appropriate developmental milestones of physical, emotional, and psychological well-being. This medicalized model of standardized development has become the primary, if not the only way, to assess the bodily well-being of young people.

Significantly, the norms implied by this approach have also found their way into how we assess our own well-being. We worry about whether our own bodies are sufficiently normed hormonally, chemically, and physically. We go to physicians who measure us against standardized measures of physical well-being. We modify our diets, take medications to alter our brain chemistry, other medications to regulate our immune systems, we exercise in hopes of living longer and worry of we don’t measure up to the body fat index for our age. In short, we are deeply inducted in a very personal way into the developmental standards for bodies. It is no surprise then, that we would bring that profoundly personal perspective into our encounters with young people.

The question I have to wonder about though, is whether the developmental frameworks we are using are taking account of the ways in which bodies are being reshaped within the ever-shifting landscape of virtual global capitalism. To start with what may appear to be a very small, but actually significant example, Tony Sampson notes the ways in which young people’s thumbs are reconfiguring their neurology outside of cognitive awareness. He notes that current accounts of emerging consciousness tend to focus on the ways in which our conscious awareness is being shaped by our interactions with the virtual world of gaming, cyberspace, and social media. However, Sampson points out that there is a simultaneous development of what he terms, non-cognitive ecologies.

He reminds us that before our brains became conscious, in the sense of processing the world in linear terms, our neurology was composed of a “complex intermingling of gut brains, vison brains, tactile brains, ear brains, brain matter connected to the full sensorium.” (p. 124) In focusing on the conscious brain as the site of human development, Sampson argues that we miss the fact that our brain is not one, but multiple and is not located within our skull.

This non-conscious full body neurological ecology comprises a great deal of what we understand as affect or desire. Such affect and desire precedes our capacity to make sense with our consciousness, and in some cases exceeds that capacity in ways that make it difficult to rationally apprehend our behavior at times. Sampson argues that this corporeal brain is now being integrated into the realm of digital networks and having a powerful influence on how we make sense. As an example he notes the way that our thumb has taken an entirely new and central role in our daily lives, particularly in the lives of young people.

As an example, he uses the virtual organizing of the Arab Spring a few years back, although his remarks could easily be applied to Black Lives Matter or any other contemporary movement.

The tweeting, facebooking crowds that made up the Arab Spring were clearly composed of a swirling mass of thumbs … in many ways, the inclusivity of body parts other than brains, begins to reorient the question concerning what can a brain do, towards a comprehensive model of neurodiversity, inclusive of the sense making capacity of the thumb brain. (p 124-125)

The thumb brain may sound a bit trivial at first glance, until we begin to actually consider how much time, in any given day, young people are using their thumbs to communicate with each other. Sampson argues that these actions are deeply embedded within a worldwide network of communication which might well begin to be thought about as a kind of collective consciousness that operates outside of our conscious ability to process its impacts on our lives. And when we add all the ever proliferating virtual extensions of our body into the realm of the virtual through devices that monitor and feeds back information to us that shapes our behavior at a very physical level, it becomes quite clear that young people’s bodies are becoming ever increasingly cyborg in ways we are only beginning to understand.

If bodies are being physically reshaped in ways that are altering our neurological ecology through their immersion into cyber space, then it might be worthwhile to consider the way we process time as well. Time, of course, is the foundational framework for developmental theory and thought. We base so much of how we think about development on our assumptions about linear progressive time. We operate as though time was both universal and predictable. That is to say that time is a constant that we can use to measure the movement of our bodies across the life span.

However, it is important to note that in the 21st century, time and its impacts on young people’s bodies shifts, as they are immersed in the sphere of cyberspace. The speed of 20th century life was much faster than the speed of the early 1800’s. Factory time worked in very different ways than agricultural time. Cars and airplanes move at velocities almost impossible to measure against a world of where the mode of transportation was the horse or walking. Our experience of the world in terms of speed is increased even more as we enter the realm of the virtual.

As we move from industrial time to virtual time, there are new tensions and new contradictions. Lohmeier, Kaun, and Pentzold sketch the complexities of our experience of time as we engage the world of virtual media. They note that it is not simply a matter of acceleration, although that has large implications for how we produce ourselves and are produced within a virtual context. Newly emergent technologies speed up the ways in which information is processed and presented to us. We have instantaneous access to an almost infinite amount of data arriving through an array of screens at work, home, and in our hands or on our wrists. The constant flow of information in e-mails, texts, social media platforms, introjected advertisements and enticements, and internet searches we initiate as serious forms of inquiry or as casual exercises of curiosity, move at astonishing speeds. Some of this information we are capable of processing consciously, but it would be fair to say that quite a lot is processed subliminally and effectuates a range of unconscious processing modes.

However, Lohmeier et al. suggest that our sense of time is even more powerfully altered by what they call datafication. Datafication refers to the ways in which the information about our lives is processed through an ever-proliferating array of algorithms that automate how we make judgements, how we evaluate things and perhaps most importantly, how we make decisions. The complex array of data processing points that we engage in the course of daily living gives us a powerful stream of constant data that overcodes our phenomenological experience of the life world and colonizes it with increasingly abstract modes of signification. These algorithmic forms of coalescing and processing the data of our lives is extracted from the field of our social relations and fed back to us translated into capitalist sets of value. The way in which data is collected and processed operates outside of lived time.

In the virtual world of post-industrial capitalism, the algorithms deployed, draw from our memories, our contemporary experience, and projections of future desire. The now commonplace ad campaign that states or infers that the future is now is premised the in ways in which data about future probabilities is mediated through vast computer networks running possible scenarios of virtual futures at atomic speeds. In the virtual world, the future is always being produced now and being streamed to us in ways that collapses time into a series of temporal multiplicities that leaves us disoriented and yearning for a way to enter the time of our lives as participants rather than subjects alienated from our own experience.

The quantification and transformation of all the elements of our lives into digital streams that simultaneously weave our nostalgia for a past that no longer exists into a future imploded into a present into which we never arrive.

Of course, this has immense implications for how young people experience time, as each succeeding generation is inducted ever more deeply into the realm of the virtual as a normal part of their lived experience. For those of us living in a world in which we experience time as if it was still working the way it did when we grew up, these shifts are very hard to imagine. But I would argue, that if you are to adequately account for time and development in the 21st century, our models are going to need to shift.

Finally, I would note that the maturation process for bodies as we enter the second decade of the 21st century has undergone a significant change. In a recent article in the New York Times, it was reported that researchers were finding that girls were experiencing the development of secondary sexual characteristics as early as age 6. The trend was noticed first in the 1980s and has been accelerating since that time. The shift in the age of onset seems to be more prevalent among Black girls but is occurring across racial groups. Although the trend is most pronounced in the United States, it has been confirmed in dozens of countries across the world. There is a similar but less pronounced trend among boys as well.

While the causes of this change are not fully known, factors such as obesity, stress, sexual assault, and chemicals in the environment may play a role. That said, the fact that young people’s bodies are changing in term of their biological development has significant implications for the work we do in CYC and the ways in which we frame development. Not the least of these concerns are the possible impacts on the young people themselves. As the Times article notes,

Although it is difficult to tease apart cause and effect, earlier puberty may have harmful impacts, especially for girls. Girls who go through puberty early are at a higher risk of depression, anxiety, substance abuse and other psychological problems, compared with peers who hit puberty later. Girls who get their periods earlier may also be at a higher risk of developing breast or uterine cancer in adulthood.

The question, I would ask here, as I have been throughout, is – are we taking account of this shift in the ways we work with young people? The bodies of the young people we encounter in our work on not the same bodies we encountered in the 20th century when the field of CYC was developing. If that is case, how do we need to update our models? What do we need to do so that we are re-thinking our approaches to development in the context of 21st century bodies? I would argue that this is an area in need of serious attention. I sincerely hope that we can fully enter the 21st century and move beyond trying to manage 21st century bodies with 20th century models. The young people are already living now, we need to join them.  

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App