CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 282 August 2022

Goal Setting and Plans of Care

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Over the past few months, I have had repeated occasion to review plans of care developed for (rarely with) young people involved in child welfare. I remember being confused by plans of care many

years ago, when I encountered these regularly either as part of my own work in child welfare or as part of my research. Turns out, not much has changed, and planning care seems to have remained quite static even though the context in which care is being planned has changed quite significantly. Of particular interest to me is the way we think about goal setting as part of the plan of care process. This month, I want to offer some thoughts on why we may want to re-think this.

The first observation about goal setting is that the extent to which the process itself reflects the participation of young people is rather limited. Common goals one encounters are clearly not articulated by the young people. They include such things as ‘learning to abide by the rules of the setting’, ‘doing well in school’, and ‘developing positive peer relationships’. Sometimes, goals are very specific to the circumstances of a young person, and may include such things as ‘abstaining from drug use’, ‘eating healthy’, or ‘finding a part-time job’. At other times, goals are less specific and include seemingly positive aspects, such as ‘improving family relationships’ or ‘improving self-esteem and reducing self-harm’. These goals strike me as profoundly uninspiring, particularly when seen through the lens of a teenager. That doesn’t mean that there is anything wrong with having positive peer relationships, or eating healthy, or getting a part-time job. Quite to the contrary, these are all good things, and one would hope that we aspire to enable these things for all children and youth all the time. It strikes me as explicitly discriminatory to set these things as ‘goals’ for young people in care while working to enable these things for children and youth with stable and loving families as a matter of course. It implies that for young people in care, the responsibility of achieving access to routine benefits lies with the individual young person (set a goal and then work to achieve it), whereas for everyone else, that responsibility is a social responsibility that is embedded in the parent-child, community-family relationships. Most young people receive the benefits associated with these goals; young people in care have to work to achieve these benefits (often in the face of institutionally generated barriers).

Perhaps more importantly, I often wonder whether these are the kinds of things that are relevant in the 21st century world. In the 20th century, groups homes and foster care were places of coercion, designed to enforce conformity and compliance. I know that this was not the prevailing view at the time, but there is little point in arguing about the enormous coercive content of care twenty plus years ago. Then again, for much of the 20th century, particularly from the 1950s to the 1980s in North America, the nature of the world in the context of which we were providing that care was clear. It was a white world, where power flowed from the top and the masses were asked to (coerced to) comply. Treatment was chemical, identity was binary, relationships were instrumental, and value was material. Both in the societal and the global context, we operated based on the balance of power, in which resistance and change were mediated through the generosity of those holding the most power. Patriarchy, ableism, white supremacy, and highly gendered social relations reflected the everyday reality for almost everyone. We paid the price for the protection of our existence by allowing the concentration of power within the military-industrial complex that kept us safe from nuclear annihilation.

Within that kind of system, it certainly made sense to reduce the concept of care to one of conformity and compliance. Care meant that young people in care learned their place within the power structures of society and the global world. In fact, we could just as well have used the phrase ‘young people in training’ as opposed to young people in care (and indeed, congregate care, especially in the disability sector, was often called ‘training schools’), since the goal of much of child welfare was training young people to become complacent, rule-abiding, but largely invisible citizens of the white state. Doing this served to maintain the balance of power, which served as the ultimate good.

The world we live in today has changed quite dramatically. Some might call it the postmodern world, or a collection of societies governed by fluidity rather than balance. Today, binaries clearly are in retreat, whether we are talking about gender binaries, ability and disability, or racial contexts where it is no longer just about identifying this race or that, but also recognizing that white supremacy has given us concepts such as shadism, white- passing, intersectionality, and mental health as a complex interface of many states of being. Even in the material context, things have changed; today, you can accumulate absurd wealth doing absolutely nothing, but you can also condemn yourself to chronic poverty working 70 hours per week. Globally, we have accepted contradictions and tensions that run counter to the purity and sterility agenda of the previous century. We allow migrants to drown in the Mediterranean Sea by the thousands and call this unfortunate; wars are erupting in which one side claims moral superiority over the other despite both sides enabling bloodshed with their high-profit weapon production sectors. We can accept the sale of highly destructive weapons to Ukraine, designed to kill 19-year-old Russians on the battlefield, but we are deeply offended by a Russian oligarch owning a British soccer team. And our relative safety from nuclear annihilation has given way to our assured extinction (at some point) resulting from our refusal to accept the ecological limits of the planet.

This begs the question: Does training for conformity, for fitting in, and for compliance with existing power structures, really make for relevant goals? I think not, and I worry a great deal about young people who submit to this new coercive practice. Their ‘treatment’ is very much like a root canal; it extracts the roots of capacity to navigate a world filled with contradictions, and it aims explicitly to diminish the courage necessary to move around and to reinvent oneself within this world. It is of course true that many young people in care systems engage in behaviours that will for many years strengthen the barriers they will face for self-determination and for acting on opportunities that may meet their interests and aspirations. Dropping out of school, addictions, incarceration, and self- harm are not helpful. The idea of working with young people to mitigate long term damage is a good one, and relational practices in child and youth care are well suited to do exactly that. At the same time, however, setting goals that are assessed and measured based on behavioural responses of young people to imposed structures and rules are probably not meaningful ways of ensuring that young people can see themselves as autonomous subjects in the world. For this reason, I think goal setting and planning care needs to adjust to reflect much deeper engagements with young people than current processes allow for. For one thing, I think a sense of Self, coupled with a strong sense of personal autonomy, is an essential goal for young people who by virtue of being in care, have had their sense of Self as subject replaced by their objectification/commodification through case management. But beyond personal autonomy, the goal for young people ought to always be about finding much more fluid systems of belonging, which inherently means working to develop social networks that are diverse, reflect multiple capacities and ways of being in the world, and that can greet the contradictions young people encounter along the way through creativity, courage, and connection.

In many ways, I think ‘planning care’ ought to reflect the organic forms of care that are ever present for young people who are not absorbed into formal care systems. This means that the goals set as part of care planning cannot be linear goals in which behaviour is modified to greater levels of conformity. Instead, much more multidimensional and intersectional goals, that extend beyond the individualistic and performance-based construction of young people, are necessary that focus first and foremost on helping young people develop responses to these questions:

When young people engage these kinds of questions, we no longer need to set goals related to conformity and compliance. Young people will choose the context in which conformity is important to support their emerging sense of Self and their aspirations for connection. Their decisions will matter, which means they will matter. How they are, and how they become, in the world will reflect the world they are actually experiencing, rather than the constructed world in which we have been trying to render them irrelevant. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App