There has been some recent theorizing about the future direction of CYC practice, describing a split between an individual treatment framework, where the use of life space and relational energy creates the CYC support for people interacting together to ameliorate conditions that are causing unhealthy life situations. This is described as the older, more traditional view of CYC practice, focussing on individual change. This view of CYC practice parameters is criticized as ignoring the larger context of racism, oppression, white privilege, and post-colonial constructs that have kept marginalized communities in powerless situations despite personal agency or effort.
The alternative proposed by this newer thinking is to focus our efforts on pushing back against the oppressive environment, which is generally attributed to white, male, settler, anti-feminine, racist, post-colonial thinkers who practice identity politics and social control strategies to maintain a privileged social position. I believe that these dynamics are a problem that should not be ignored, but I do believe that focussing too exclusively on the fact that the powerful are intent on oppressing the weak is a losing strategy.
Social Work has shifted into this view of their mission for a long time and social work training has stressed changing societal norms for decades. They have moved away from individual change, stressing oppressive dynamics as the issue to be addressed.
My position on this new proposed direction for CYC practice is that I believe it will dilute our effectiveness with individuals and families, with little to be gained on the front of changing societal dynamics. The main issue for me how this newer approach will affect our ability to support the emergence of hope and agency in the youth and families we serve.
Focussing on how the world is unfair to powerless people creates a victim stance that pervades the thinking and performance of practitioners, resulting in resentment and suspicion. CYC practitioners generally try to resist this view of themselves and the young people and families they support, hopefully because they are strength-based, etc.
Mature, skilled CYC practitioners realize that the empathy required by them is more complex than just imagining how they would feel if they were in the same situation as their families, because it would be tainted by all the power imbalance issues listed above as well as imposing their own life logic on people who have quite different lives.
CYC practitioners must be aware of their own prejudices, skewed perceptions of reality, and personal needs to work effectively, and this includes all the sociological dynamics listed in our oppressive world. However, effective attempts at change require the building of hopeful perspectives, because without hope there is no reason to change. We work with people who know much better than the helper that the world is oppressive and prejudiced against them. When the practitioner has a victim stance, building resentment against unfair social norms, how does this create hope?
A recent issue of the Relational Child and Youth Care Practice Journal describes South African CYC practice, stating that the Isibindi projects in that country have indicated a way to blend the two perspectives of our field. The use of local personnel and local facilities keeps everyone fairly focussed on curent realities without compromising the powerful interactions that characterize effective CYC work. One solution is to keep CYC practice as locally based as possible, keeping a focus on personal connections and local identity.
I realize that this issue is bigger than merely discussing hope and agency, but it is one essential ingredient in our practice that cannot be ignored in describing sociological dilemmas.