I met Connor when he was 14 years old and placed in an Individualized Living Arrangement I was supervising. Connor was the only young person in this arrangement with a core staff team. This was placement 19 for him. Connor was 18 months old when he and his four brothers were removed from an environment that was reported to be one of extreme neglect and exposure to domestic violence. Reports describe Connor and his siblings being removed from a filthy, locked room, deprived of food and nurturance. Both his mother and father struggled with addictions and the domestic violence inflicted on Connor’s mother by his father was described as brutally violent.
Many children who are removed from their families and in child protection systems often have many placement disruptions interrupting continuity of relationships. Each disruption, including separation from parents, can negatively impact healthy development increasing the inability or unwillingness to form new relationships. Trauma, grief and loss are most often attached to these multiple moves (Fahlberg, 1994). Connor’s early experiences of terror and chaos deprived him of an adult to keep him safe and secure. Due to his adverse experiences up to 18 months old, many moves and maltreatment in several foster homes, it is likely Connor’s childhood was one of chronic fear and unmet needs.
When Connor was first placed in our program, for a period of almost two months he refused to step inside the door. He didn’t enter the house to shower, to get a change of clothes or to have a meal. During this time Connor was couch surfing and staying at various friend’s homes in the city, most of them youth living independently who likely had experiences of trauma and hurt in common with one another. Except for a visual check-in once every 24 hours, we didn’t see Connor. The only reason he agreed to meet for a visual and to answer some phone calls was because he wanted to avoid a missing person’s report being filed with police. He certainly did not want the police knocking on doors looking for him. Forming relationships with wounded young people is not an easy task, forming a relationship with a wounded young person we saw for five minutes in 24 hours proved to be even harder. There needed to be creativity and intentionality in finding ways to show this boy he was cared for and worthy of this caring. At that time our moments with him were brief and few and we had to be purposeful in every single moment of interaction no matter how brief.
Connor didn’t trust us and considering the hurt and loss that had been his lived experience for most of his life, who could blame him? As it became very clear that Connor had little desire to join us, we realized we had to amp up our acts of caring while approaching our interactions carefully so we would not scare him away. We began taking him meals when we would see him. While there was a risk that bringing him things would take away any reason for him to come to the home, the risk of solidifying his feelings of being unworthy of caring, if we did not find a way to connect, was greater. When we first started doing this we often added a little extra; we would bake him cookies, we would add a toothbrush and some toothpaste or new socks and underwear. At first, he would come to our car window, take his care package and leave. After a while he would stay at the window for a brief interaction. We were all surprised when he began to sit in our vehicles to talk for a few minutes. These moments gradually lead to him eating in our vehicles while we would go for a drive, providing us with moments we would maximize towards building a relationship. While Connor had yet to come to the home, the time spent with him started to increase. Often this time was spent driving around talking about rap music, then we would part ways and the team would research the rappers he was talking about to engage in conversation for the next interaction. One evening while going through a drive-thru with Conner, I spotted a robot claw hand-grabbing stick toy in the back of my car that belonged to one of my children. I looked at Connor and asked if I should pay with the robot hand and take the order out of the window with it. To my surprise Connor said, “Yes, do it!” followed by mischievous laughter. What followed was him putting my purse on this robot hand while we were both in a shared moment of laughter as I was completing this drive-thru exchange making a complete fool of myself. We were both laughing so hard I had to park in the parking lot for a while before driving.
Another evening Connor was eating in my car at around midnight. As always, I told him that if he needed anything and if he would like breakfast brought to him in the morning to call and I would bring it. Just before 6:00 am Connor called and asked if I could bring him breakfast. It would have been easy to dismiss this request or tell him he needed to wait as it was too early, but this was the beginning of many tests Connor would put us through to see if we would follow through with our words and we needed to pass them. I often thought of Connor calling and asking for food like a baby who cries to be held or fed, except this was a hurt teenager crying out for caring.
After a couple of months Connor eventually came to the home (mostly to sleep). While he still chose to spend most of his waking hours away from the program, he was not couch surfing any more. While in the house, Connor consistently made efforts to push us away. Likely this was to prevent the eventual hurt that he most often experienced when he let others close. While this testing decreased in duration and intensity it remained something that was consistent throughout his three years in the program. Often staff were spit on, yelled at and called obscenities. Often this behaviour would peak after periods of seemingly connected times, times in which he would open up and talk about his hurts, letting his guard down. Connor needed to have experiences of people who were committed to him enough to not give up when things got tough. The pattern of people leaving him when things became difficult needed to be broken to help him learn that he would not always be abandoned by those who were supposed to care.
In the first year of working with Connor there was a phase when he would tear the doors off rooms in the home. It is plausible this behaviour could be linked to his early childhood experience of being confined in a room with his siblings. When Connor would remove these doors he would prop them up against the walls in such a way that he would block staff from entering spaces in the home where he was. Connor had many metaphorical walls built up around him and now he was putting up physical barriers to keep us away. Interestingly, in the evenings when he would create these barricades he would take his mattress from his room to the living room which was closer to the office and this is where he would sleep. The makeshift wall remained but he was closer in proximity to us. It seemed as if Connor didn’t want us to be close to him but he also didn’t want to be far from us which resembled characteristics of disorganized attachment. It is possible that on some level he feared we would cause him harm but understood at some level that he may have needed us, thus causing him internal confusion. Children with disorganized attachment try to escape the source of fear at the same time the attachment system triggers an approach response.
When people with disorganized attachment begin to form a coherent narrative of their lives, they can be helped to understand how their past experiences are affecting their lives (Firestone, n.d.). Connor recognized that he struggled emotionally and was quick to react. He had a desire to change and develop an understanding as to why he had the intense reactions that he did. In the last year of his time in the program and after a lot of hanging in, it seemed we had earned some of Connor’s trust. He became open to speaking about his early childhood traumas and how they were impacting him presently. Connor would seek out information on attachment and early trauma. He would ask for information to be printed and he would take it to his brother who had recently moved back in the city. Not only was Connor seeking insight for himself, but he was also looking for this insight to share with his brothers who had similar experiences. While Connor’s reactionary behaviours didn’t disappear, they did decrease significantly the more he learned.
According to preplacement reports, Connor had struggled through most of his school years. His teachers described him as an intelligent child, but a child who struggled to pay attention and was resistant to following the rules of the classroom. As we slowly got to know Connor, he spoke often of wanting to get his education, and while there were several times that this was set up for him he never seemed able to follow through for any length of time, despite the supports and encouragement that were given. The last time Connor attended school a boy accidently bumped into him in a crowded hallway. Connor reacted almost reflexively and punched the boy, breaking his jaw. This experience not only resulted in him being expelled from school but also in receiving his first criminal charge. It is likely that Connor’s experiences of trauma had resulted in him having a highly sensitized alarm response and because of this he reacted quickly to things without thought. Perry (2005) states that a child who has a persistently activated stress response, extreme hypervigilance and anxiety will struggle with academic, therapeutic and socio emotional learning opportunities. It is reasonable to say that school likely was a quite a stressful place for Connor. School environments are often places with a great deal of sensory input that can be overwhelming. Also, school may have been triggering for him as he had to start over in new schools so often in his childhood. Knowledge of Connor’s background combined with an understanding of attachment and neurodevelopmental theories may have assisted educators in Connor’s previous school settings in ensuring suitable accommodations were made for him to best support his learning.
Connor would often be triggered into explosive rage that often happened unexpectedly and seemingly out of nowhere, particularly in the mornings. Staff entering the home at shift change and even the faintest sound of footsteps often resulted in Connor yelling, growling, shouting profanities, throwing objects and putting his fists through walls. It appeared Connor had extraordinarily little control of these responses. Staff who experienced these intense reactions to noise in the mornings often described them as feral in nature. It is reasonable to consider that Connor’s strong reaction to noise in the morning was possibly being triggered by memories of experiences that he could not cognitively explain or understand. For practitioners to engage in therapeutic practice it is essential they understand the young people we work with often have had repeated experiences of threat and fear. They may be hypersensitive and easily distressed by daily events that would not be distressing or even noticed by others who have not had these adverse experiences. These children may quickly react in ways that may have prevented harm from happening to them in the past. Behaviours, such as yelling and aggression may have been survival strategies that at one time deflected real or perceived danger (Baker & White-McMahon, 2021).
It is through healthy attachments that a child begins to develop an internal working model of how they see and view the world. Connor’s lived experience in his 14 years of life was one of tremendous unpredictability and loss. While most of his 19 living arrangements were separate from his siblings, at approximately four years of age Connor and his younger brother were placed together in a foster home for potential adoption. Within less than a year of living in this placement the foster family made the decision that they could not provide the degree of care that Connor needed and stated that his behaviours went beyond their capabilities. They proceeded in adopting his younger brother and Connor was moved. At 12 years of age Connor’s mother was in a healthy marriage, it appeared her addictions were under control and she had another child whom she was caring for.
Connor’s brothers who were previously in the protection system had also returned to living with her. She had made an application to the court for Connor to return as well and this request was in the process of being granted. Shortly before the order was finalized, on the day before his 13th birthday, his mother told Connor she was leaving the province with his siblings. She rescinded her application for reunification stating that Connor needed treatment for his behaviours before he could live with her. These experiences along with his many other disrupted placements likely would have reinforced for him an internal working model of being unworthy and unwanted. Tomlinson (2000) states that intervention with youth who have insecure attachments needs to begin with practitioners being aware of the child’s internal working model and providing experiences to the child that does not confirm their theories of the world and other people. Connor needed lived experiences of adults who cared about him, who nurtured his many talents and strengths and who would hang in through those times he would act in ways that would push others away.
Connor made the decision to leave care a few months before his 18th birthday despite our pleas for him to stay. The irony is not lost on me that this might have been one of the few, if any, times efforts were made to convince him to stay in any place he was living. We did not want him to go and would miss the talented, insightful, funny, intelligent individual we discovered underneath layers of protective armour. I pointed this irony out to Connor one evening before he left and he responded somewhat emphatically, “But now it’s my choice.”
References
Baker, P.W. & White-McMahon, M. (2021). The brain and life experiences: A neurotransactional approach to child and youth care. In H. Modlin, J. Freeman, C. Gaitens, T. Garfat (Eds.), Relational child and youth care in action. (pp. 101-115). The CYC-Net Press.
Fahlberg, V.I. (1994). A child’s journey through placement (UK ed.) British Association for Adoption Fostering.
Firestone, L. (n.d). Disorganized attachment: how disorganized attachments form & how they can be healed. PsychAlive. Retrieved February 23, 2021 from https://www.psychalive.org/disorganized-attachment/
Perry, B. D. (2005). Applying principles of neurodevelopment to clinical work with maltreated and traumatized children. In N. Boyd Webb (Eds.), Working with traumatized youth in child welfare (pp. 27-52). Guilford Publications.
Tomlinson, M. (2000). Attachment and youth at risk. CYC-Online. https://cyc-net.org/cyc-online/cycol-0400-attachment.html
Originally published in Relational Child and Youth Care Practice, 34, No.1, pp13-20.