Seymour Sarason (1985) said that the practices of clinicians - psychiatrists, lawyers, educators, and clinical psychologists are often missing caring and compassion, which he argued was central to "clinical practice", and he tagged higher education as the primary culprit. It may surprise you that he considers all of these "clinical practices"; the reason is that all of these occupations involve practices in relationships, and when it works correctly the relationship makes possible healing and learning.
Seymour is describing child and youth care, without ever using the phrase. In his discussion of teachers, he borrows John Dewey's phrase, that teachers ought to teach children, not subject matter. He says, "When we say that the teacher starts with where the child is, we mean that the teacher... differentiates between the nature of the child's experience and that of the teacher, a differentiation as crucial as it is difficult in practice to make and sustain" (p. 68). Sound familiar? His idea about clinical practice is CYC in another name, and he is talking about occupations both similar and also very different than ours.
His history of psychiatry and clinical psychology is the explanation for the founding of CYC/Youthwork higher education programs in the United States – and probably Canada. Because the professions were abandoning the focus on the child, CYC/Youthwork was proposed as a professional commitment to recover and meet the child in the context of the family, the family's culture and ethnicity, and social class as foreground – all of the features that today some call "intersectionality."
We are still faced with pressures to focus on diagnostic categories and problems rather than on persons. We are pressured to focus on social class and ethnicity rather than persons in the context of social class and ethnicity. We are working in systems that expect us to intervene with and target individuals rather than with individuals in networks of relationships. We are in positions in which time with children, youth, and families, is always experienced as limited.
Sarason says that what is lost is the pedagogy of caring and compassion. We assume it is present and we assume that those who come to the field have it, but we do not study it enough. We do not yet know enough about how to identify it, how to nurture it, and what it looks like in different contexts with diverse types of persons.
Further, "The clinical role is aimed at changing something about the individual, but it is preceded by a process of change in the clinician's understanding" (p. 70) [and] ... if we have learned anything about the clinical role, it is the importance of exercising control over the unreflective tendency to assume an identity between the world of the clinician and that of the troubled individual. To seek to understand requires the clinician to confront obstacles within him- or herself ... From the standpoint of teachers, these 'problems' were in the children. What teachers did not grasp, what their training did not prepare them to understand, was that the problem was in them as much as it was in students." (Sarason, 1985, p. 71)
There are many practitioners who know what this means and who know how to put themselves and other practitioners in situations where this occurs. What we have not yet done is generalized our knowledge of these encounters so that we can teach them, and we have not developed evaluation tools to document and study them.
Sarason says that most higher education programs assume that those who enter the field have these qualities, and so faculty do not bother to teach them. Further, "... the time pressures that characterize their training experiences subtly and inexorably alter their personality in regard to caring and compassionate behavior ... and one of those changes has to do with the perceived need to limit the expressions of caring and compassion" (p. 35.)
Student practica in education are taken up with everything but caring and compassion. Sarason says that "... there is nothing in the selection and preparation of teachers that sensitizes them to and refines their grasp of the obligations and dilemmas of the clinical role." (p. 72)
In CYC, what would it look like – in practice and in education – if we put caring and compassionate relationships front and center? Maybe preservice training or higher education classes for course credit are not the best way to learn these qualities. He believed that clinical supervision is one answer, over an extended period, with a focus on the art of building relationships and on the creation of caring and compassion. It is not a character trait--it is something developed with situational specificity.
Practices could be reorganized. Higher education could reduce our focus on theoretical courses (as useful as some are) and foreground supervision and practica with much more study of how to validly recognize these qualities. We will have to include the participant/patient/client in the experience and in the evaluation process, and we will have to make the education of front-line practitioners a priority.
Why should I have to say this? One reason is suggested by Sarason: "It sounds strange, and I realize that it is not consciously intended, that [higher education] programs whose goal it is to train clinicians tend to devalue those who will spend their lives in the clinical endeavor." (p. 167). It has happened in education, social work, and psychiatry, and it has always been a problem in practice where the front-line work still has low status. It is here in CYC, and something will have to be done.