Sometimes I'm right
and I can be wrong My own beliefs are in my song
The butcher, the
banker, the drummer and then Makes no difference what group I'm in
I
am everyday people, yeah yeah
In August of 1969, Sly and the Family Stone performed at a festival in Harlem. The festival drew 300,00 people and occurred at the same time as Woodstock, which was about a hundred miles away. Both festivals were fully documented, but only Woodstock drew national attention and has been memorialized over the past 50 plus years. The two festivals were both historical mileposts that signaled the height of hope and possibility for the cultural revolution of the 60’s. For Woodstock, that hope and possibility was largely driven by the dreams of personal liberation embodied in the hippie movement comprised of predominately white middle class young people. For the Harlem Cultural Festival, the hope and possibility was rooted in the newly emergent sense of Black power and the cultural capacity of communities of color. Not surprisingly, the dreams of white kids are what we remember about that summer that marked the moment before the revolutionary potential of the 60’s was destroyed, coopted or at best deferred. The aspirations of the communities of color embodied in the Harlem Cultural Festival faded into history. While Woodstock produced a full media spectrum of documentation, the Harlem festival couldn’t attract any interest for the film and audio shot at the event. In fact, the tapes of festival were utterly ignored. It was the kind of erasure of history so common in the cultural memory of the United States.
Recently, however, the film record of the Harlem festival has been made into a documentary film called The Summer of Soul. I went to see it the other day and it is a remarkable snapshot of a powerful moment of revolt and resistance through affirmation following a series of brutal assassinations of Black leaders (Malcom X, Martin Luther King, Bobby Hutton) and allies (John F. Kennedy, Bobby Kennedy). The summer before the festival, Black communities across the U.S. had erupted into flames over the assassination of Martin Luther King. But, in the summer of 1969, the message at the Harlem festival given by performers such as Sly Stone, the Staples Singers, Stevie Wonder, the Fifth Dimension, and notably Nina Simone was an unbridled assertion of Black identity and the power of communities of color. There is great deal to be said here about the sense of grief and loss the film evokes, knowing what will come in form of backlash and the destruction of the movement, not to mention the careers and lives of performer/activists like Ms. Simone. It is a bittersweet moment full of heartbreaking hope and exuberance both on the stage and in the crowd.
However, it is a much smaller and perhaps less momentous moment in the film that I would like to take up here. There is an interview with someone close to the Harlem community who remarks on the media coverage of the riots the previous year and the introduction of crack cocaine into the community, which at the time of the festival was approaching epidemic proportions. Their comment was, that the media coverage of Harlem had very little to do with the actuality of life in Harlem.
Yes, there had been riots and yes there was a drug crisis. But, mostly the majority of people in Harlem lived incredibly mundane lives centered around their family and community. They shopped, got their hair attended to, cooked meals, went to work, had gatherings with neighbors and friends, paid bills, cared for their children and elders and so on.
It was interesting to see the crowd shots at the festival, which reflected this very sense of everyday people gathered to hear music and celebrate their culture and community. As opposed to Woodstock, there were people of all ages, families with children, people with picnics, all very joyful, but in an odd way orderly. There was no excessive obvious drug use, no announcements about bad acid, no nudity, nothing spectacular at all. Just people from the Harlem community having a very big block party with internationally known acts who spoke to their aching desires for pride and recognition in an America seemingly determined to erase their existence.
In a word, the Harlem festival was simply not the kind of spectacle that Woodstock was. It affirmed culture rather than countering it, because the culture of the people in attendance was already counter to the mainstream by definition. While middle class white young hippies were in the business of rebellion and resistance to their parents and all they stood for, the Harlem festival attendees and performers were simply expressing the power of a culture hundreds of years old. It was and is a culture steeped in hundreds of years of resistance and rebellion that had shaped a people and defined them through the daily affirmations of collective assertions of life over death, freedom over slavery, and survival over genocide. As such, while there have been spectacular moments, like the civil rights movement, or the riots of 1968, the real heart of the matter is found in the far less obvious patterns of daily life as a persistent refusal to be undone as a people or a culture.
A number of year ago, Chris Richardson and I edited a volume of essays called Habitus of the Hood. In the introduction to the book, we made an argument that within every neighborhood characterized as a “hood” by popular culture was a community of complex living relations that exceeded any capacity of social media to represent its material actuality. We cited Cornel West who argues for a,
differentiation between a “hood” and a “neighborhood.” The former, he argues, is filled with gangsters while the latter is filled with friends. “I grew up in a neighborhood, not a hood ... Our neighborhood was a place where there were wonderful ties of sympathy and bonds of empathy. The folk who lived there kept track of you.” In contrast, he writes that a “hood is survival of the slickest. They’re obsessed with their 11th commandment, “Thou shalt not get caught”.
With all due respect to Dr. West (for whom I have the deepest admiration), we felt as though his nostalgia for the neighborhood was misplaced and premature. Without a doubt, there has been a fracturing and dissembling of community ties across the United States, but community has not been entirely given up or situated only in the past. We responded to Dr West’s nostalgic reading by acknowledging that while he is making,
a provocative distinction, we feel that defining the hood as a completely negative, selfish, and destructive place may be too simplistic. If the hood were truly devoid of strong bonds and close-knit social relationships, there would not likely be so many nostalgic references to it in popular culture . . . This is not to say that the hood is an easy or ideal place to live. Often times, it is the enduring struggles of the residents that unite them. It is not a sense of love or joy but a shared understanding of the injustice imposed on residents from outside the hood that creates a bond. This formation of a group habitus, based on specific geographical spaces, should not be underestimated both for its power to shape ideas and its power to unite a community – even if members are only united in their anger and distrust of outsiders.
In short, we were arguing that under the media spectacle of violence and crime, there is the lived reality of everyday people. I was reminded of this when speaking to an old friend who lives in the neighborhood in Minneapolis where George Floyd was murdered. Just around the corner from his house is where the police station was burned down, and block after block looks like it had been bombed as a result of the burning that followed Floyd’s death. Recent media accounts, such a recent article in the New York Times have portrayed this area of the city as lawless, chaotic, and violent. My friend said that this couldn’t be further from the truth of living in that neighborhood. He said that the reality of living there was extremely mundane. People are rebuilding and living their lives, going to work etc.
Are there incidents of violence? Of course, but no more than there have always been in an impoverished community. The difference is that there is little or no police response and that is causing some to panic and overrepresent the situation as anarchic or out of control. One might argue that the media representation has deep structural implications for the utilization of police presence at all. This is an area of the city where the defund the police movement is very strong, But to hear the media portrayal, the citizens of this community desperately need the police to bring order and control.
As I reflect on the erasure of everyday people from our view as they are overshadowed by spectacular accounts of violence and crime, I can’t help but wonder if we as CYC workers don’t also spectacularize the young people we encounter in our work. Of course, so much of what we do is profoundly mundane. We cook, clean, chat, play games, go for walks, make beds and so on with the young people in our care. For most of the time in our work, we are all everyday people. Indeed, this has been the hallmark of our field as relational rather than clinical. And yet, how much of how we see young people is now marked by spectacular images of trauma, violence, diagnoses, and troublesome behavior? How much of our sense of everyday community is deeply influenced by our view of young people as out of the ordinary, often in a very negative way? How much of our conversations are about the spectacular aspects of our work rather than the everydayness?
When I worked in the field as a supervisor, I often found myself, advising CYC workers to avoid being “drug off” by symptoms. It is so seductive to see a symptom manifesting itself and to be a clever detective and find the just the right name, just the right etiology, and just the right intervention. Symptoms are ways we can tag a young person and explain them in neat and concise explanations that make us feel reassured that we understand things now. And yet, if we go down that rabbit hole, we very soon fail to see the young person at all. Instead, we see a constellation of symptoms to be managed or resolved. The rich complexity of the living material human being in front of us becomes a problem to be named and solved. And of course, the more spectacular the symptom, the less we see the young person at all. In fact, if the symptom is spectacular enough, it can intimidate us into abandoning the young person into the care of a medical expert who has the “expertise” to manage such dramatic and powerful symptoms. Indeed, symptoms can scare us off and give us the impression that this young person cannot ever be engaged by us as everyday people.
And yet, we are learning that even psychotic symptoms do respond to the relational engagement of everyday people. The Hearing Voices Network provides a community of voice hearers who work together to see the symptom of auditory hallucinations as just another thing to be managed collectively through mutual support and creative problem solving. Or the Open Dialogue approach to schizophrenia in Finland that uses networks of families and friends to learn to listen in deep ways as a mediation of psychosis with remarkable results that far exceed traditional forms of psychiatric intervention. And of course, there is always AA, NA and all the other gatherings of everyday people struggling with addiction.
The point is that we needn’t be spectacular in how we deal with people, nor do we need to create their lives as anything other than ordinary.
Everyday lives are filled with a rich mélange of pain, suffering, joy, indifference, boredom, excitement, love hate, and everything in between. We all live our lives as everyday people and that is a very powerful base from which to change the world, however big or small that world may be.