CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 270 AUGUST 2021

Re-Naming the Profession Revisited – An Epilogue

Kiaras Gharabaghi

Editor’s Note 

This piece by Kiaras Gharabaghi follows his related article (Re-naming Child and Youth Care Practice) in the July 2021 edition of CYC-Online. A response to the original article from Jim Anglin appears in this issue. Kiaras did not have sight of Jim’s response prior to writing his epilogue below and his contribution to this edition should therefore not be viewed as a response to Jim’s article.

As a child and youth care practitioner, I learned the difference between engagement and dismissal fairly early, but not until I had dismissed quite a few young people, their thoughts, experiences, ideas and aspirations. Basically, some of my earliest exchanges with young people went like this:

Young Person: I will worry about my future later; I want to have fun now, do drugs, join a gang and party.

Me: That’s a bad idea. You should avoid things now that will impact you negatively for the rest of your life.

These were not, of course, the actual words exchanged, but these do reflect the spirit of the exchanges that I had quite often with young people. They had ideas, and I didn’t like those ideas. When I reflect on my responses today, I still think that in principle, I am not wrong. It probably is not a great idea to do drugs and join gangs (having fun and partying is probably okay). The problem is that my response is not actually a response to what the young person said. It is instead a dismissal of what that person said and an imposition of what I wanted to say based on where I was at. No matter how my response was intended, I now believe that the only thing the young person heard was “shut up and don’t be stupid”. That’s not really much to work with; in retrospect, I am not surprised that many young people did do drugs and join gangs.

Engagement in child and youth care practice is an entirely different way of responding to what young people say, do, want or otherwise convey. The starting point of engagement is taking what we get from young people as possibility, and then joining young people in exploring those possibilities.

When we get really good at this, we are able to push our preconceived ideas, or biases, or intuitive responses to the background, and really be with the young person within the possibility that they have generated. Together we construct life as reflected within that possibility, and as we construct that life, we insert stories, experiences and reflections that eventually help us see the good, the bad and the ugly in what we have constructed. This process is much less about the outcome as it is about the meaning we can derive from the exploration itself. We will stumble across themes and issues that might be transferable to other contexts and that may help us develop a theory of life that is meaningful to each of us as we are, based on how we are positioned in life, in society, in the world.

All of this is basic, and usually taught in an introductory course in child and youth care (at least I hope it is). This basic process of engagement as a starting point for exploring possibility has been theorized and talked about in our field pretty much forever; Fewster talked about the Self as an anchor for this engagement; Garfat talks about relational practice to convey this engagement; Charles talks about ‘mattering’ as a way of representing this kind of engagement. We can also see this engagement represented in the perspectives of Stephen and Amponsah when they speak of solidarity; or more broadly, in Afrocentrism, built not on the world as it is but on the construction of a world characterized by social justice and racial equity. In brief, engagement is good; dismissal not so much.

I bring this up in relation to my article last month about renaming the field of child and youth care because I was, quite frankly, deeply surprised not at the positions I came across in response to the article (most people who made their positions known were against renaming the profession and seemed quite offended by the idea), but by the level of engagement demonstrated with an idea (never mind what the idea was, just generally the level of engagement with ideas). The responses included such timeless gems as ‘what about social work’ (in case of doubt, bring up social work in response to any question about child and youth care practice), ‘why would we want to give up our identity’ (maybe some hobbies would help to alleviate that anxiety), and my personal favourite, ‘is a rose by another name still a rose’ (I always appreciate a little Nietzsche, but while I am not sure about the right answer, it probably still is a product of the brutal exploitation of child, women’s and Indigenous labour in a South American country so that people in the global north can express their love and care for one another). In short, the responses to my article were not at all about the article or the idea expressed within it; they were instead dismissals of that idea with clarity and indignation.

I understand, and to be honest, I even partially agree, with all the reasons cited for not changing the name. In fact, I am quite capable of producing many more reasons not to change the name, including some that don’t rely on the ‘social work ace’, identity crises or botanical musings. The point of bringing up ideas, admittedly sometimes in provocative manner, is to invite exploration. What might child and youth care practice be like if it were unfolding under a different name? Or even if we never intend to actually change the name, what sorts of words or phrases would capture our aspirations for the field? Or perhaps we might wonder together about whose positionality with respect to our field might be impacted by a different name? Exploring these questions is not about changing the name of the field. It is about starting with new possibilities and creating stories, experiences and meaning as we develop such possibilities together. The more we do this, the less we will have to rely on other professions or other species to understand who we are, how we practice, and where we may want to journey toward in the future.

A mature field derives its maturity from the desire to think. This, in turn, requires that we engage ideas, even those that intuitively we don’t like, or where we can immediately identify some challenges or even costs.

Perhaps our unwillingness to engage, and our enthusiasm for dismissing, or for providing reasons not to do something rather than imagining what doing something could entail, explains why we have been so slow (and sometimes outright resistant) to thinking about the issues of power, racism, and exclusion in our field. Engagement is really the only way to ensure that we don’t reduce ourselves to chronically repeat the same mantras, most of which stem from the previous millennium.

It was fun writing my column last month because it made me think about possibilities. After reading some of the responses, I felt very much like the young people in my early exchanges as a child and youth care practitioner. All I am hearing is ‘shut up already’. Thankfully, I am every young person I have ever worked with – oppositional, defiant, and a bit more of a cactus than a rose.

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App