by Kiaras Gharabaghi in the July 2021 issue of CYC-Online
Preamble
I want to thank Kiaras for “turning up the volume” on the somewhat “muted” issue of our beloved profession’s name. While the name issue has been the subject of discussion and debate for many decades, it is interesting to note that the term ‘child (and youth) care’ has persisted to this day in much of our literature in North America and in the name of many associations and academic schools across Canada. Further, the term has been, and continues to be used by those in our field in many non-English speaking countries as the English translation of their own professional name.
In this brief perspective piece, I will examine the arguments put forward by Kiaras to determine if he articulates a compelling case for a profession name change.
Background
In the early phases of development in North America, our profession was known simply as ‘child care’, but when the ‘day care’ field adopted the term ‘child care’, we needed to differentiate ourselves from that evolving “sister” profession.
Over the decades since the early 1940s (in the American Journal of Orthopsychiatry), and more recently in such journals as the Child Care Quarterly (now Child and Youth Care Forum) and the Canadian Journal of Child Care (now Relational Child and Youth Care Practice) and others, many articles discussing our name and identity can be found. One of our pioneers in North America, Karen VanderVen, advocated for our profession to move into life-long caregiving, in much the same way that ‘social pedagogy’ in Europe does. This shift would presumably require a name change, moving away from the reference to ‘children and youth’ in our name. Karen felt strongly that we would never become a “true” profession until we embraced life-long carework.
Others, such as Henry Maier and Lorraine E. Fox (and many others) have explored the notion and nature of ‘care’ in child and youth care. Henry traced the evolution from the concept of ‘caretaker’, to ‘caregiver,’ to what he (somewhat awkwardly) termed ‘care-interactor.’ As Child and Youth Care Workers (CYCWs), we don’t take, and we don’t just give – we interact in a reciprocal and (hopefully) respectful manner.
Kiaras briefly acknowledges some discomfort with the notion of ‘care’ in our name and identity, suggesting that understanding care as a ‘practice’ may be problematic. Kiaras also notes that in various jurisdictions and contexts, the word ‘care’ is replaced by such concepts as ‘work’, ‘counsellor’ or (I would add) ‘practitioner.’
Thus, there are two aspects of our name, both of which have long histories of debate. On the one hand, there is our “ageism”, namely the focus on young people, a range that can encompass birth to 30 years depending upon the context. I am aware that there is also an evolving profession of Youth Work that has as its focus the upper portion of the broad ‘child’ spectrum. Youth Work as a profession also tends to embrace a political agenda and has roots in ‘youth movements’ that have evolved over more than a century in Europe, North America, South America, and beyond.
It is perhaps important to recognize that CYC(W) is not the only age-defined profession, and is, in a sense, sandwiched (in an overlapping way) between ‘child care/early childhood education’ and ‘youth work.’
There are many discussions in our literature about the richness and importance of ‘caring’ for the development and well-being of young people. Maier even talked about ‘caring care’ to emphasize the notion that care in CYC needs to be seen as moving beyond simple physical supervision or hygiene assistance (for example). However, we need to realize that holding on to the term ‘care’ in our title risks others perceiving us as the children’s version of ‘elder care’ workers who mainly toilet, brush hair, dress and feed (amongst other things) elderly people not capable of carrying out such basic functions by themselves. I expect most readers of CYC-Online would understand the notion of ‘care’ in our profession as an extensive, complex and vital set of psycho-social-emotional and physical activities.
But I will not explore any further here the ‘carework’ portion of our name. As mentioned, there already are several variations of the practice dimension of our title (e.g., counsellor, practitioner). It seems to me that these variations have not weakened the profession, rather they have allowed our profession to communicate our identity and functions effectively in various contexts. One cannot overstate the strong sense of identity CYCWs have across the world, whatever variation of wording we use to describe our practice. However, I believe the ‘child and youth’ dimension of our name is a key common identifier, therefore I will focus the rest of my comments primarily on this aspect of our name.
Much of what Kiaras says in his article pertains to CYC being/becoming a profession, and the accoutrements that accompany being a profession, such as being embedded in the politics of legislation and organizational life.
I, and I expect many readers, share some ambivalence about how professionalization has been approached in other disciplines, and I believe there is widespread desire across our field to avoid (as far as possible) the dehumanizing and exclusionary aspects of professionalization. At the same time, professionalization can assist us in being well-recognized and respected in society for our knowledge, skills and commitments, and thus can help us to be more effective in supporting children and youth who can benefit from our work. I will not address these issues further here as I want to focus on the issue of naming our profession.
Kiaras makes many points in his brief article, many of which are not specifically about the name of Child and Youth Care, so I will briefly re-state some of his key points on naming, and address each in turn. (My apologies, Kiaras, if I unintentionally distort or misstate aspects of your article and argument.)
1. Child and Youth Care is not a term used everywhere
Does it need to be? Europeans, for example, have different terms (e.g. Educateur Specialisee in France, Erzieher in Germany, Barnevernpedagog in Norway, and Social Pedagogue in various other countries) that they generally translate as child and youth care worker. The same is true of other professions. Nurse in German is Krankenschwester, in French it‘s Infirmiere, in Spansh it’s Enfermera.
2. The term CYC doesn’t entirely capture what the field is actually about
What profession’s name does entirely capture what the field is actually about? Doctor or Physician do not. Nurse, Social Worker and Psychologist do not either. No term of one or a few words can adequately capture what a complex professional field is actually about. All professions need to find ways beyond their name to explain themselves and their work to those outside the profession. I would agree with many others that we need to up our game in this area.
3. Many minorities do not see themselves reflected in the phrase or title. Newcomers may be puzzled by CYC
Who isn’t puzzled by a professional term that is new to them? I had to figure out what a ‘child care counsellor’ was after I was hired to be one. At first, probably none of us see ourselves reflected in the phrase or title. Is it really any different from seeing oneself as a psychologist or physician, or understanding what a profession actually does, simply from its name?
4. The name excludes work with adults, or can be problematic when we work with adults (e.g., the term may insult adults with developmental challenges with whom some CYCs work)
Actually, our name does not exclude us working with adults – we do it all the time. We work with parents frequently, and with youth who are of adult age. As to our name as a profession insulting adult clients, having CYC education and training does not preclude us using other job titles, such as Family Support Worker, Developmental Specialist etc. that would be more suited to such contexts.
Frequently, the life span education and perspective CYCWs bring is very well suited to working with adults with cognitive or emotional challenges, as well as with parents (for example).
5. The title may bring some inherent compromises that are ethically unacceptable
Without an example, I don’t know what would be ethically unacceptable about our name, or what compromises inherent in the name are being suggested. I would welcome clarification of this point, Kiaras.
6. We have largely failed in our quest for regulation and governmental mandate
As Kiaras notes, South Africa offers an example of how our name has been recognized in legislation and government regulations. As well, this has happened in a society of diverse, non-white traditions, that has embraced the name and practice of child and youth care and merged its own knowledges and traditions into the profession. The province of Alberta in Canada is in the process of legislating and regulating ‘child and youth care counselling’ as a profession. The profession has been making progress in this area, but the profession itself has not, in general, made sufficient concerted efforts on its own behalf. Perhaps now is the time.
7. Will the name keep us from incorporating other knowledge traditions? With this title, how can the field evolve beyond its white foundations?
I think this is answered in the previous point in relation to the impressive progress of the profession in South Africa. The concept of Ubuntu, for example, has not only made its way into CYC in South Africa (Allsopp, 2020; Thumbadoo, 2020), but also into the vocabulary of CYCWs in other continents (e.g., Grupper, Anglin and Schmid, 2015).
8. Does tradition matter? Or does tradition hold us back?
I guess that is up to all of us, and how we honour the wisdom of our elders and our profession’s traditions, and, at the same time, the degree to which we are open to change when it is needed. I don’t think our name, in itself, either holds us back or pulls us forward.
9. Do we hang onto the name a) out of fear of losing relevance? b) through emotional attachment? or c) protecting our investments?
Many of us who have been working for many decades to establish and build the profession of child and youth care (myself included) do feel an emotional attachment to our name and identity. I think we also want to protect many of the investments and advances that have been made, in creating professional associations, academic programs, professional journals, international networks and the like. My fear would be that if we were to change our name, we may be in danger of losing not only our identity, but also the very foundations of our work that is so important for literally millions of children and youth around the world.
10. The name centers children and youth
Kiaras makes an important assertion relating to centering the child in our practice. He says:
In another scenario, we can focus on how child and youth care centers children and youth in describing or naming our practice. The idea of centering on children and youth may sound innocuous enough, but in fact, this too is already a political statement that runs counter to many community traditions and ways of being. Furthermore, the name child and youth care suggests that the care of children and youth can be constructed separately from care for the community, care for other generations, and care as a spiritual good rather than pragmatic practice. Once again, we can see how the name itself creates boundaries for truth in our practice. (p.11)
The notion of ‘centering’ is an interesting one. Being child-centered is espoused across many social care professions, including education, social work, health care and counselling. It is usually intended to mean keeping the child in focus when making decisions about their lives and working in partnership with them and their families. I believe that centering the child is at the very heart of good relational practice in our profession.
An actual case from Canada may help illustrate this point. Some years ago, a child who was living with a parent starved to death. The most shocking aspect was that there were five professionals working with the parent/family at the time, purportedly to ensure the protection of the child. How could this happen? Well, whenever a professional would come to the house, the parent would make some excuse for not having the professional see the child. The parent would say that the child was sleeping, or sick, or out with someone. No one insisted on actually seeing the child and took the parent’s assurances at face value. All the professionals involved took their eyes off the child and thus the child was able to starve to death under their watch.
There was no trained child and youth care worker involved. I cannot imagine a professional child and youth care worker would have visited the home without insisting on seeing the child. At the core of child and youth care is the child/youth, and I maintain that centering the child/youth should always be our fundamental function and responsibility. Yes, certainly all children need to be understood and related to in the context of their families and communities, but if we ever de-center the child/youth in our practice, there is no assurance that any other professional will keep their eyes and attention focussed on the child/youth. While this case may sound extreme, regrettably this is not the only time a child has died from neglect or starvation while supposedly being protected by professionals.
I have written elsewhere:
Throughout the long history of societies internationally, the realities and voices of children have not traditionally been seen or heard. We have learned that where the needs of children are not considered first, they tend to be addressed last … which often means not at all.
In order to ensure a sustained focus on the day-to-day, living realities of "the whole child," the development of child and youth care education, training programs and professional associations needs to be vigorously supported. Because at the very heart of child and youth care work is the willingness born of struggle, knowledge born of experience, sensitivity born of vulnerability, and skill born of necessity, not just to act or advocate on behalf of children, but to truly live with young people as a profession. (Anglin, 1999. p.149).
I suggest that keeping the words “child and youth” in the name of our profession serves to remind everyone, including ourselves, what (and who) lies at the center of our concern, our practice and our responsibility, at all times.
Our name does not actually create boundaries, as everything in society in some way impacts on the well-being of children and youth, and thus can be of concern for us. CYCWs do relate to families and communities, however they do so primarily as contexts for the development of children and youth. For a CYCW, families and communities are not ends in themselves, but rather are contexts for the upbringing of children and youth. While other professions may focus on family well-being, parental needs or community development per se, they all too frequently overlook the voices, experiences and capacities of children and youth. Regrettably, all too often they seem not to understand children and youth as being fully human and key agents in their own right.
Conclusion
If child and youth care workers do not center the needs and well-being of children and youth, who will? If they do not center the needs and well-being of children and youth, what then will guide their work, and what will be their unique function in the social care system? If child and youth care does not center the child/youth, we may undermine the very foundations and reasons for our existence as a profession.
At this point, I am aware of no compelling reason to change the name of the child and youth care profession, and I see many compelling reasons to retain our name. At the same time, I want to express my appreciation for Kiaras’ provocative perspectives on this issue, and for bringing me out of my Covid 19 semi-hibernation to respond to his “what’s in a name?” challenge in CYC-Online.
References
Allsopp, J.M. (2020). Child and Youth Care Work in the South African context: Towards a model for education and practice, 176-177 (Doctoral thesis, Durban University of Technology, South Africa).
Anglin, J.P. (1999). The uniqueness of Child and Youth Care: A personal perspective. In Child and Youth Care Forum, 28(2), 143-150.
Thumbadoo, Z. S. (2020). Towards the development of a theoretical framework to guide child and youth care practice in South Africa, 78-81 (Doctoral thesis, Durban University of Technology, South Africa).
Grupper, E., Anglin, J.P. & Schmid, A.K. (Guest eds.) (2015). Introduction to the special issue on inclusion. In International Journal of Child, Youth and Family Studies, 6(3), 347.