CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 150 AUGUST 2011

Why Focusing on Control Backfires: A Systems Perspective

Karen VanderVen

A narrow focus on reward and punishment works against creating a rich milieu of activities and relationships. Principles from systems theory show why external controls fail.

On the occasion of John, in residential care, not making his bed, take a look at the following two scenarios:

Scenario I:

“John didn’t make his bed again” laments Jim, a childcare worker, to his colleague Jason, continuing, “Well, that’s 20 points off. I guess that means he can’t go outside to play ball.” Later John is found in the bathroom, throwing soap bars and hurling towels. Jason and Jim need to apply a physical restraint to John, who yells, “I hate it here!”

This scenario is a prototype of what is all too common today: the prevalence of point and level systems used to control children and youth in various settings. Point and level systems are so common that there is barely a need to describe them. In general, points are awarded for behavior that matches pre-set criteria. Their practices are to find infractions, encourage compliance, reward, punish, and take away. Acquisition of points is connected to levels that in turn enable access to greater “privileges,” such as more interesting activities and opportunities to interact with adults; however, all too often the results are that the undesired behavior escalates into a more unmanageable situation.

Scenario II:

“Hey, John! You must have had a restless night. Look at that sheet! More twists than a pretzel. C’mon over, give me a hand, and let’s get it straightened out. Want you to sleep well tonight so you ‘refresh for tomorrow’s game. And let’s get it done now so we can get out to practice. John grumbles and rolls his eyes heavenward but comes over and picks up an end of the sheet.

This response is an attempt to replicate how Fritz Redl and David Wineman might have handled an “unmade bed” situation with the youngsters at Pioneer House, the treatment program in Detroit that was the subject of their classic work, The Aggressive Child (1957) which encompassed two books, Children Who Hate and Controls from Within.

There were no point and level systems at Pioneer House. Nor were there the insights from dynamical systems theory that have provided completely different insights and altered practices in behavioral sciences (e.g., Butz, 1997).

Both the past (the work of Redl and Wineman) and the present (non-linear dynamical systems theory) offer perspectives that show the ineffectiveness of point and level systems and lead towards relational and activity oriented approaches in development of internal controls.

Perspectives on Activities

Promises and Rewards

Redl and Wineman (1957) acknowledge that offering rewards so that children may receive something they find pleasurable is a common practice among educators and parents. They also acknowledge that even for essentially normal children with intact egos, these practices may be only marginal. They continue to indicate that such practices are totally unsuitable for the disturbed youngsters of Pioneer House, whose anti-adult stance is well entrenched. The idea of youngsters “deserving” rewards or positive experiences for which they were not able to make the connection between the reward and their own prior action would only re-affirm their perception of adults as mean and depriving just as they may have actually experienced them in the past.

Yet, today, the promise-reward premise is rife in a wide array of group treatment, residential, and educational programs, especially as wrapped up in the current argot point and level system. Not surprisingly, these systems simply reinforce the youths’ distrust of and disengagement from adults rather than encourage positive change (e.g., VanderVen, 1995, 2000).

Gratification Grants Without Strings Attached

that children and youth in treatment need to feel that the adults want them to have fun, whether or not they deserve it, is one that is extremely hard to convey today. As Redl and Wineman (1957) say of the children:

Satisfaction and gratification are not a bribe or reward thrown at them for the production of good or for the avoidance of bad behavior but are a basic part of their accepted diet which they can expect as securely guaranteed even in times which involve trouble. (p. 297)

Somehow, so many today feel that programmed activities, meager as they may be, must somehow be deserved and so they are attached to the ubiquitous point and level system, to be earned. As one well meaning, but sadly uninformed youth worker said in a workshop on activity programming, “But if I can’t take activities away, then what can I take away?”

In some settings, more complex or challenging activities-and often more attractive ones-are attached to levels that must be earned by acquisition of points. If a child goes down a level for some infraction, then he or she can no longer participate in the higher level activity, thus precluding the opportunity to deepen his or her interest or develop a higher skill level. Furthermore, the allowed activities at the lowest level are usually the least growth producing (e.g., watching television). So a youngster cannot go swimming, play basketball, take a walk, make a birdhouse, paint a picture, or playa musical instrument, but rather must sit passively or act out.

Relationships

Defenses Against Change

It is not easy to form helpful relationships with disturbed children and youth. In their discussions of the disturbed ego, referring to the almost impenetrable methods delinquent and disturbed youngsters use to maintain their delinquent perceptions and actions, Redl and Wineman show how even the most wellmeaning and kind adults are resisted.

When adults impose and implement a point and level system, however, there is no opportunity to view them even as decent, caring, and giving, thus continuing to fuel and justify the youngsters’ perception of adults as exactly the opposite. At least in the point-and-level-free environment, where caring, interesting and engaging activities, and acceptance do not have to be earned as part of a rigid accounting process, there is a chance, difficult as it is, that the delinquent ego may finally be reached.

If the youngsters come to like the adult, that is the first step in change. Such change is not complete, however, unless the youngster internalizes the positive characteristics of the adult. If the adult is seen as an arbitrary dispenser of privileges and favors, especially that of his or her own attention and caring without the barrier of an external construct, then even this first ingredient of the potential for change is lost. Certainly the possibility of positive identification is negated. So should we then be working for development of a negative identification in which the image of a punitive, rejecting, and withholding adult is incorporated? Point and level systems may control at the moment, but they do little to ensure real change.

Escape Into Virtue

Another way delinquents resist the influence of adults is by “escape into virtue,” literally behaving well (Redl and Wineman, 1957, p. 167). However, this easier to manage behavior may be meaningless because it is superficial compliance. Fox (1994) has suggested that point and level systems encourage superficial compliance and trick adults into thinking that their control efforts are really working. What they actually do is drive the aberrant behavior deeper, so that the youngsters can keep it out of sight of the adults. Even the so-called rewards given for earning points may work for a while until the youngsters realize it is not worth the effort, happily reverting to their previous resistance behaviors, both overt and covert. This dynamic, of course, drives the youth even further beyond the reach of the adults.

Relationships and Activities

Strangulation Of Love, Activity and Dependency Needs

Control methods such as point and level systems thus fly directly in the face of meeting basic needs for being loved and for engaging in interesting activities-both of which are crucial for healthy development (e.g., VanderVen, 1999). Redl and Wineman (1957) consider this theme by quoting Diogenes as saying, “The safest way of not getting involved ... is to stop wanting anything” (p. 173). They continue to indicate that under continued punishment, many children “actually develop, as a counter technique, a real withdrawal from activity need, a taste for passive daydreaming which, once developed, makes them safe. They don’t have to change; they just don’t mind this form of punishment any more” (p. 173).

This is just like the reports of those finally acknowledging that point and level systems do not work. The youngsters just stop wanting whatever the rewards are, even the activities that have to be earned. And, what do they do instead? Just as Redl and Wineman (1957) point out, they learn how to “be happy by newly discovered pleasures of daydreaming, dozing, or the proud planning of future revenge” (p. 173). This certainly is not treatment.

Redl and Wineman knew it back in the 50S: The core elements of treatment and positive child and youth development are relationships and activities and the interaction between the two. Activities situate and mediate relationships. Relationships support new interests and skill development. Together these comprise programming. Redl and Wineman (1957) put it so beautifully: “Programming as a Full Fledged Therapeutic Tool” (p. 318). Children and youth should not have to earn their treatment.

Non-Linear Dynamical Systems

If Redl and Wineman did not have the language of “point and level systems,” they also did not have that of “non-linear dynamical systems theory,” also known as “chaos theory.” Had they known about this new worldview, however, they would have seen it as a rationale that supported their thinking and actions such as those described above.

The following discussion, albeit brief and simplified, will focus on some of the concepts of dynamical systems theory that are particularly applicable to understanding the dynamics of control approaches such as point and level systems in child and youth work and will provide still another rationale for their ineffectiveness.

Recursion

For insights concerning the powerful concept of recursion, thanks go to the famous anthropologist Gregory Bateson (e.g., Bateson, 1972; Bateson & Bateson, 1987; Harries-Jones, 1995). Recursion is a concept in the subfield of cybernetics which is “a branch of mathematics concerned with problems of control” (Bateson & Bateson, 1987, p. 207) and the relationship between inputs and outputs in a system. Attempts to control a complex system-for example, a classroom, a group or a residential program-can lead to recursion effects. These usually are increased misbehaviors leading to stronger control methods, with a continuing cycle of escalation. Helpful in understanding recursion is the concept of feedback, a word more common in usage. In this context it means essentially that new information is being fed into a system which then changes the nature of the system. In “negative feedback,” a characteristic of a recursive system, information about the outcome of a previous input is used to “adjust the mechanism governing future functioning” (p. 208).

Thus in recursion, information from a system is fed back on itself, thereby changing the nature of the system and affecting the initial input. Often recursion effects are responsible for unanticipated or paradoxical outcomes (VanderVen, 1994). This is often why people are so surprised when their “logical” approaches do not give the expected result. For example, consider the example of pest control by pesticides. While the immediate outcome was fewer pests, the continued recursive cycle led to the ability of pests to withstand the pesticides as well as the increase in the number of pests and their ability to resist pesticides. Stronger pesticides are then needed in the hope of controlling the ever more resistant strains. Another example is the attempt to control child abuse. Certain practices, such as forbidding touch where it is really not necessary to do so, have created new forms of “secondary child abuse,” depriving youngsters of developmentally necessary caring from adults (VanderVen, 1994).

In these recursive phenomena, then, attempts at control actually create more out of control situations which require stronger control measures and lead to the continued creation of uncontrolled behaviors.

With reference to point and level systems, an example of the recursion phenomenon can be found in the observation by many that youngsters found ever more adult-resistant and creative and unconstructive ways of evading the system. Some examples have already been mentioned, including when the rewards offered no longer are attractive to the youngsters. Others include such covert activities as trying to get others in trouble so that they, rather than the instigators, are penalized. Even some staff, reveling in the power awarding points can give them, come to pleasure in seeing how many points they can levy in a culture that nurtures such actions.

Attractors

In addition to recursion dynamics, another dynamical systems concept is that of the attractor. An attractor in a system is the source of energy that drives the system and to which its development constantly reverts. When a point and level system is in place, it becomes the attractor in the setting’s system, drawing focus and energy towards it and ultimately becoming the shaper or frame of the culture and practices. Everything-contact with adults, permitted activities, peer interactions, even assessment for discharge-is oriented towards how many points a child or youth has. Like bad money driving out the good, the point and level system takes over and becomes a culture of its own (e.g., VanderVen, 2000).

Language reflects culture. When a point and level system is the attractor, even the language reflects its pervasiveness. In “pointese,” the conversation revolves around “consequences,” “privileges,” and the like. As this language becomes entrenched, it serves further to establish the point and level system attractor, and contributes to the ever escalating strength of the points and levels to drive the system.

Disequilibrium

In human services, control efforts are often used to bring things into stability or equilibrium as a desired target of change. If only things were better organized. If only there were no misbehavior. In fact, disequilibrium is the condition under which change occurs. Disequilibrium does not mean lack of structure or focus, but rather, applied to a child and youth program, a setting that is dynamic where there is both an inherent structure and an open-endedness allowing emergence to take place. In other words, practices take individuality and context into consideration, rather than using a “one size fits all” approach.

This phenomenon is also relevant to many other instances in human services where even well meaning attempts to control, manage, or intervene in an undesirable situation or event have led to unanticipated results that can be damaging in new ways. The example mentioned before is child sexual abuse, in which “no touch” policies came into being as well as over-scrutiny in which even the most well-meaning adults could become suspect if they so much as put an arm around a shoulder or a pat on the back (e.g., VanderVen, 1994).

For disequilibrium to be a favored condition in a group setting, there needs to be the ability to tolerate ambiguity, to accept misbehavior (as was done at Pioneer House), and especially to have time on one’s side. True change in both a program and a personality takes, as Redl and Wineman point out, a considerable amount of time. Where there are short-term and short-lived efforts, a control-oriented culture thrives and does not take advantage of the dynamics of disequilibrium in which over time new, exciting, and often productive, occurrences evolve.

Towards the Future

Taking the clinical and developmental wisdom of Redl and Wineman into account, along with a dynamical systems perspective, one can consider their implications for practice.

he arguments advanced both in this article and the others to follow are compelling. Punishment and deprivation of activities and relationships by their having to be earned do not work and create a similarly negative culture that shapes a very unproductive and unpleasant environment. When challenged to replace their point and level systems with more constructive approaches, people often lament, “But then what can we do?” Controls from Within offers a response to this question.

We can offer so much of ourselves and our interests our favorite activities-to help children and youth build strengths and develop into healthy and well functioning adults. We can offer the potential of relationships even though they may at times, especially in the earlier stages, be fraught with conflict. We can learn through proper professional preparation and on-going learning to better understand the dynamics of troubled and neglected youngsters and know how best to meet their needs. We should not take from them something they never had. We should not punish them for doing things we have never taught them not to do. By doing these things we take away from ourselves as well.

References

Bateson, G .(1972). Steps to an ecology of mind. New York: Ballantine Books.

Bateson, G., & Bateson, M. (1987). Angels fear: Towards an epistemology of the sacred. New York: MacMillan.

Butz, M. (1997) Chaos and complexity: Implications for psychological theory and practice. Washington, DC: Taylor and Francis.

Fox, L. (1994). The catastrophe of compliance. Journal of Child and Youth Care, 9(1),13-22.

Harries-Jones, P. (1995). A recursive vision: Ecological understanding and Gregory Bateson. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Redl, F. & Wineman, D. (1957). The aggressive child. Glencoe, IL: The Free Press.

VanderVen, K. (1994). Preventing second-generation child abuse: Applying chaos theory to reframe interventions. Journal of Child and Youth Care Administration, 6(1),27-34

VanderVen, K. (1995). Point and level systems: Another way to fail children and youth. Child and Youth Care Forum, 24(6), 345-367.

VanderVen, K. (1999). You are what you do and become what you’ve done: The role of activity in development of self. Journal of Child and Youth Care, 13(2), 133-147.

VanderVen, K. (2000). Cultural aspects of point and level systems. Reclaiming Children and Youth, 9(1), 53-59.

From: Reclaiming Children and Youth, Volume 17 No.4, pp 8-12

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App