Recently I was reading about the cultural center Albert Camus created with his colleagues in Algiers in the 1930s. It was a place where Arab, Italian, Spanish, and French could gather to learn from literature, music, and theatre. During a period of political and social strife, they believed this would advance society and serve as powerful source for political discourse, and activism. By watching and discussing a Chekhov play, for instance, not only would their lives be enriched, they would also gain insight for relating and acting together to improve social conditions.
I often go to an independent book store and art center in our community. It serves as a gathering place for people of all classes and backgrounds in a relatively poor section of town. On visits one is surrounded by evocative sounds, words, and pictures of culture. On Saturday evenings they hold poetry readings. Many of the presentations are followed by discussions with the performers. Sometimes people provide food, wine, and other goodies. On Sundays they have folk, rock, rap, and classical music concerts. The room where performances are held is also an art gallery.
Reading Camus reminded me that these centers are in and of themselves places and sources of social and political change. In our community if the center were to disappear, the neighborhood would truly be a different place. Something very important would be lost. While the impact cannot be easily measured, almost every one of the regular supporters agrees, it pulls us together in way that cannot be found anywhere else. The connections and discourse inspired in our gatherings can’t be found elsewhere. So, we fight to preserve it; we give both our time and our money to a place that presents many sides to issues and life in multiple forms. It is a place that helps bind together the community. This makes me wonder, where is the cultural center for our field? Is it here on cyc-net.org? Probably more than anywhere else, yes it is. There is a wealth of material to be accessed and read here. Our field can be seen evolving without borders. Common problems and solutions are shared. Issues are addressed. Some issues are left unaddressed, but at least they have been raised. People are telling their stories and writing their opinions. How to (s) are presented. New approaches and ways of thinking are introduced. Photos and art represent our work in action.
Is this enough however? Is our cultural center being sufficiently developed with philosophy, history, music, theatre, art, and literature? Have we invited in outside voices, or are we still rather insular? Are the discussions enriched by the insights of people in other fields who have looked at similar issues from different perspectives? Can we see, hear, feel, debate Child and Youth Care in its multiple forms, places, contexts, and cultures? Are we open to outside criticism and discourse?
My answer to all these questions is probably not enough. More pictures, songs, dances, plays, novels, stories, rituals, critical thinking, and collective action grounded in the real, often open-ended, mixed genre, rich accounts of our challenging work are needed. We can be more informed by music, art, philosophy, film, and literature in our work.
This will help us show the dualities and moral dilemmas that are often left unsaid or not shown in approaches and models not suited for our non linear, outside the box work. A good book, movie, theory, painting, or way of thinking is often open ended. The authors, writers, filmmakers raise questions knowing there are many more to be asked. These are not just good tunes or stories, rather thoughtful pieces that show rather than tell. We see their pictures and images as real at a point in time, knowing the rest is left to us to make better choices for ourselves and others. Or we just see something in a different light.
As we grow into the future, our cultural center will need more of all this to give us the legitimacy of a profession that is serious about trying to know and define itself as a human endeavor full of struggles, challenges, and differences that are part of being human. A field in which a play, film, painting, critical discourse, narrative and story is not just a metaphor for the work, but our very work with youth, and the way we show and discuss it in its multiple new forms along with what we have already learned.