The Pathway to Hell
If you’re like most of us, you came into this profession with the best of intentions. You cast aside the lure of fame and fortune because you were looking for something with ‘meaning’. You ‘cared’. You wanted to ‘make a difference’ to help kids overcome their troubles and live their lives to the full in a just and humane society.
It’s possible that none of these reasons fit for you, but having interviewed hundreds of Child and Youth Care applicants, I can attest to their commonality. As a rule, they are all acceptable motives for employment in the field, but left without further examination and qualification, they only serve to assure us that the pathway to Hell can, indeed, be paved with good intentions.
It’s not that people entering this profession are hiding anything about their motives at least not consciously. For the most part, they simply accept their own explanations and remain unaware of what stirs them on the inside. With no inner sense of direction, they become fodder for whatever economic, political and professional agendas are floating around ‘out there’. Once inducted into some system of beliefs and practices, they are quickly dispatched to the front-line where survival depends upon their willingness and ability to match the expectations of those with the knowledge and the power. The successful ones may eventually become ‘experts’ themselves, regurgitating the handed-down ‘truths’ designed to perpetuate whatever system they represent.
In many ways, they are like kids who blindly follow the religious beliefs and practices of their parents. They may act from a solid sense of commitment, but not from a place of awareness. Their befuddled belief is that if they can make things right for others so they can be right for themselves. It’s a lost cause and the most predictable outcome is ‘burn-out’.
Then there are the rebels, the self-appointed advocates who enter the field bent on representing kids against the forces of oppression. Even within their places of employment, they will oppose anything they consider to be the imposition of authority. While their reasons may appear to be more apparent, they are no closer to the truth of their own intentions and actions than those who faithfully toe the party line. What they fail to see is that the roots of their rebellion have nothing to do with the plight of the kids they set out to protect and liberate. Beneath their self-righteous hostility lie feelings of repression and resentment that came about long before the entered the ranks of Child and Youth Care. What they really need is the courage to confront their own discontent and take action on their own behalf rather than use the kids as convenient foils.
If you find all this to be an unwarranted cynical attack on the well-meaning folks who come into our profession to help kids, I can only assume the cap fits and I fully understand. But if we are to assist kids in resolving their developmental injuries, the onus is upon us to deal with our own stuff along the way. There’s no way of saying this nicely and tactfully. On the other hand, those of us who deal with angry kids on a daily basis shouldn’t need to be protected from such allegations. As guides, we must understand our own developmental interruptions and discover the internal resources we need to create the lives we want. Self-awareness isn’t an adjunct to Child and Youth Care practice, it’s the very heart of the enterprise. If we unwittingly impose our own issues onto our young ‘clients’ we simply stir more confusion into the relational casserole. Unaware of the motives behind our actions we treat others as objects to be manipulated in our unconscious schemes.
Only by coming to know our Selves can we come to know others as separate and unique beings. And only by understanding why we make the choices we make, can we take responsibility to act in the best interests of the kids in our care. While we may follow pre-designed intervention prescriptions and strategies, the nature of our work takes us directly into the everyday world of our clients where we are constantly making decisions in response to that, frequently chaotic, arena. Here our primary guiding instrument is our own authentic sense of Self and this we must nurture, develop and fine-tune with the tenacity and precision of a skilled surgeon. If “heal thyself” is a precondition for medical practice, then “know thy Self” is an equally essential quality for effective Child and Youth Care.
Loitering With Intent
I’m not debunking those nice little clichés we use when asked about our reasons for being in this profession. The search for ‘meaning’ is generally considered to be a basic human pursuit (see Viktor Frankl) and is firmly embedded in effective Child and Youth Care (see Thom Garfat). The verb ‘to care’ transforms meaning into feelings that can be expressed in action. And wanting to ‘make a difference’ is a very laudable quest that incorporates both meaning and caring.
But, to return to my original stance, these are unsatisfying explanations that fail to offer what Child and Youth Care practitioners most need – Self-awareness. On the other hand, they can be used as points of departure for those who set off in search of the Grail.
If you tell me you’re searching for “meaning” in your life, the implication is that something is missing –something that might give you satisfaction and fulfillment. So what is it? What do you need to fill the void? And why would you expect to find it in the conflicts and confusions of kid’s lives rather than in a museum, airport traffic control tower or fashion design center? Then comes the question of where the ‘meaning’ might be found in this congested space? If you’re looking to the kids to provide the missing piece you’re heading into a black hole. What they need most is to be seen and heard by someone who is at one with his or her sense of Self – not folks who are scrabbling around looking for their own bits and pieces. So I have a few suggestions to make. Begin by going back into your childhood and search for the missing pieces (see the previous articles in this series). You’ll know when you find them. Develop a personal plan to give yourself what you didn’t get. Remember it can only come from you.Consider the proposition that ‘meaning’
isn’t something to be discovered but something to be created; it’s a sense of purpose that can only be ground from direct engagement in life and the only possible creator is you. Now you can move in Child and Youth Care, or any other interactive arena, as the author of your own life while supporting others in doing likewise.
If you tell me you “care” about kids, without being able to identify what it is about them that warrants your caring, the implication is your concern is about some ideal that, if explored, would say more about you than the kids you purport to care about. Taking a close look at this ideal might be the first step toward transforming ‘caring’ from an impersonal abstraction to an interpersonal experience. You may discover that it’s not about kids at all but some moral notion of how the world ‘should’ be. If children are indeed the focus, is your concern about kids in general or about Robbie Fowler who just robbed the grocery store? If it’s about Robbie, then you have identified a human object for your caring and, if you have a solid sense of Self, your actions are likely to be relational. I may also care about Robbie, but for very different reasons. On the other hand, I may regard him as a wretched little plonker who steals the purses of old ladies. In other words, the reasons we care about another human being are to be found in ourselves. Only when we know what belongs to us can we begin to know where we end and the other begins. This is the boundary that enables us to care about children as fellow travelers on their own unique developmental pathway.
If you tell me you want to “make a difference” you’re playing with a Pandora’s Box crammed with hidden an disguised intentions. So where do you go from here, given that pretty well every Tyrant who has ever declared war on humanity has carried some version of this banner into battle? Well, you might want to begin by bracketing off your ideas about ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ or ‘good’ and ‘bad.’ Get down to the nitty-gritty. What do you want to change? If you want to change the quality of life on the planet, go out into the desert and ponder on your delusions of grandeur. If you want to make a change in your community, you may wish to consider running for Mayor or joining the Rotarians. If you want to make a difference in other people’s lives, forget it. This isn’t only a lost cause it’s a gesture of unadulterated arrogance.
Now comes an even more critical question – why do you want to make this difference rather than that difference? Specifically, what’s the agenda and what’s the anticipated payoff? Are you still trying to please Mommy or are you now scrambling to reserve a bed for yourself in that group home in the sky? If you examine your motives to their roots, you’ll probably discover you’re actually reacting to the most powerful infantile malady of all – the universal fear of abandonment. This isn’t a rational fear created by the mind, it’s a survival issue held in the body that dates back to the very first time Mommy was not there for you – often during the first trimester of pregnancy. The unspoken primal motive is – If only I can please or fix Mommy, she will be there for me and I won’t die.
For those of us in the helping professions, this awareness is critical. The compelling urge to ‘make a difference’ by pleasing or fixing others inevitably involves giving up the Self – the most essential element in Child and Youth Care practice. And, because the fear of abandonment is so deeply rooted and established pre-verbally, it can never be fully eradicated. The best we can do is to recognize this enduring formula for frustration, resentment and burnout before too much damage is done. The trouble is that even acknowledging our ‘addiction’ can be a challenge because there are so many seductive rationalizations to disguise the dis-ease and justify the behaviors, e.g.: “It’s better to give than to receive” (a pretentious violation of relational reciprocity); “I like to help others less fortunate than myself” (So, what makes you so fortunate?); “He’s being recognized for giving his life to others” (usually posthumous); “I’m happy when I can make you happy” (good luck, sucker); “She’s such a self-less person” (probably untreatable), “I help other’s because that’s who I am” (Come off it – who are you really?) etc. etc.
If you can’t relate to this common strategy for ‘making a difference’ please think again. If, after close examination, you remain convinced that it doesn’t apply to you, there are three possible reasons:
Traveling Together
Having said all this, I want to stress my belief that there are acts of helping, caring and loving that are not driven by unconscious motives – and this is the quality of interaction we should be working toward. This doesn’t mean we should have all our subconscious stuff sorted out before we enter the world of human relationships or join the ranks of Child and Youth Care. On the contrary, these matters only come to light in the cut and thrust of daily life and I know of no better context for addressing our early childhood interruptions than a residential program for delightfully disturbed kids. If we remain aware, we will enter that world, not as experts or fixers, but as fellow human beings with all our own doubts, fears and confusion. The key is to remain curious and know that every moment is saturated in opportunities for learning. How lucky we are!