Relational approaches to CYC sound great, though I have some reservations. The primary reservation has to do with some claims about the “use of self.” It is important to know oneself, but the descriptions of “using oneself” leave me a little cold.
I’ve written before about the problems with practitioners’ assumptions in relationships with youth. In short, there is considerable evidence from related fields that the person who is closest to a client might be the wrong person to have a clear view of what is happening. Many studies of therapists find that therapists a) are overly optimistic about their own effectiveness, b) terrible at predicting how well their clients are doing, and c) terrible at predicting outcomes. Also, brief therapy studies have shown that many problems can be addressed relatively quickly, if done well.
Further, therapists who have some way of independently measuring their client’s well-being and progress are more effective than those who don’t. It corrects their vision. Surprisingly, quantitative measures work well for this. There is no reason to believe that these things are not true of CYC practitioners.
Now there is an accumulation of work in education that suggests teachers too have blind spots and need an independent source of information to inform their work. The current phrase is “data-based individualization (DBI),” along with “curriculum-based measurement (CBM).” The use of these phrases do not mean that the relationship is unimportant. It does mean that if a child has an educational problem without measurement, the teacher may know that there is a problem but may not know how to focus help or where in the child’s experience the problem is located, and if the teacher is implicated in the problem there may be a blind spot.
The DBI idea is that the child’s educational progress is measured using an independent source, such as a simple survey or educational challenge, and it is measured often, even weekly. When a problem emerges, the educator will have information that alerts them, and there is a structure for getting a grasp on the problem. The educator can respond by modifying the instructional and learning strategies. Among the changes that can be made are the intervention length, intensity, duration, delivery method, intervention setting, personnel, and how the instruction is delivered.
These developments are good news, because these help educators take responsibility for the achievement of students and makes it less likely that students (or parents) will be blamed for not learning. Even better, there is some recognition that academic and behavioral problems go hand-in-hand. Kuechle, et al (2015) says,
A trip to any middle school will show the error in this approach as children who have academic difficulty misbehave, and children who have significant behavioral issues fall further and further behind academically. It is doubtful that one can truly separate academic and behavioral outcomes at any level, but as a child’s issues become more intense, the likelihood of concurrent academic and behavior problems rises. And, despite the history of poor outcomes, intervention research suggests that the right supports can significantly improve both academic and behavioral outcome (p. 152).
CYC practitioners in the schools have been saying this for decades.
Trauma is all the rage in CYC now, but most problems are not trauma. Some are more pedestrian, such as a result of daily failure in school, and some trauma can be addressed by helping youth find some success and pleasure in accomplishment, i.e., in school. Teachers are learning to break large problems into smaller pieces to help youth, and this is something CYC practitioners know something about.
Educators are increasingly also measuring behavioral issues and modifying their approaches. We should jump onto this train, learning to obtain data independent of the judgment of the practitioner closest to the child so that we are more immediately responsive. We can teach educators the importance of starting with the child’s goals, not ours, and measuring them. We can also teach them, if they need it, the importance of love and care, even amid careful attention to checking our work.
Reference
Kuechle, L. B., Edmonds, R. Z., Danielson, L. S., & Peterson, A. (2015). The next big idea: A framework for integrated academic and behavioral intensive intervention. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice, 30(4), pp 150-158.