For a number of years, I have been arguing that anytime we see a word or concept proliferate across the landscape of virtual global capitalism, there is a very good chance that whatever material value the word referred to no longer exists. In other words, whenever we see a key social value or structure such as “families” or “children as the future” or “the middle class,” we can be reasonably sure that virtual capital has appropriated it, emptied it of material integrity, and returned it to us as an empty cipher; a ghost of its itself. In that regard, I can’t help but notice the proliferation of the term health and healthy everywhere I look.
In our work in CYC, as in many of the “helping” professions, the term healthy is very pervasive. We often used it as a key indicator of good practice and desirable behaviors. We use healthy to describe relationships, boundaries, bodies, mental and emotional states, communities, environments, and practices to name but a few aspects of our work and lives. Of course, this discourse is well intentioned in its goal to assist young people and their families. Ideally, advancing the health of the young people should assist them in being able to cope effectively with the challenges and struggles that they face. We also use the language of health to assist ourselves as workers to be able take care of ourselves in ways that allow us to do our best work. To be healthy carries with it a sense of resilience and vitality, a promise of capacity and increased life force.
But, exactly does health mean when it gets used in the context of global capitalism and do capitalist frameworks actually advance our material health? Or does the discourse of health under neo-liberal capitalism simply give us the illusion that health is attainable, while infinitely deferring the material lived experience of health through a series of ever proliferating “healthy” pathways and practices that never seem to get us truly healthy?
We know that the conditions for optimal health are founded in an environment that supports the physical, mental, and spiritual aspects that make us what we are. All that we are needs sustenance to thrive and persist. Of course, there are limits to each individual body. After all, we all die at some point. But to live as long and comfortably as possible requires that the world in which the body is embedded works to our advantage at all levels of our being. This would imply an ecology rich in all of the nutrients we need to survive and thrive. Such an ecology would need to encompass a wide variety of elements compatible with the fairly wide-ranging variations of human physiognomy that give rise to our capacity for thought, expression, affect, and action. The problem is that in our contemporary society, our sense of ecology may well be seriously compromised. Our connection to anything outside our self can sometimes be pretty tenuous. We know the world is out there, but sometimes we are not sure that it connects to us in any real way.
Of course, the fact that we have managed to imagine ourselves as somehow separate from the ecology in which we are entangled is one of the great superstitions and nasty illusions of our age. Contemporary humans, or at least a great many of us, have fooled ourselves into thinking we can somehow step aside from the world that surrounds us and encase ourselves in this bag of skin we call “our body.” In a kind of magical thinking, we even go a step further and imagine that our self is somehow beyond the body. That who we are is founded in thoughts or some kind of abstract spiritual form that transcends the messy details of the material world. In this kind of fantasy, we can act in any way we like with minimal or no real consequence. We fantasize that we have an escape route that will allow us to flee any material ecological crisis through technological innovation, spiritual transcendence, or the exercise of free will. At a minimum, we can limit the damage to our “own” body through carefully managing the effects a degraded environment might have on it. We can use modern science and ancient spiritual practices to ward off any devastating effects of the increasingly corrupted world out there by paying ever closer attention to what’s in here.
In this truly dystopian set of hallucinations, we will do or believe almost anything as long as it promises that we will be healthier. We will follow all sorts of diets, exercise regimes, mindful practices, drink all manner of concoctions, even ingest micro amounts of psychedelics in the pursuit of health. Each of these, in its turn, fades and fails to satisfy our need to feel better and better, to look fitter and fitter, to think faster and faster, to beat the clock of age, and to be resist the inevitable.
And as the reality of our bodies in their full materiality threatens to become ever more real, we often engage in a devil’s bargain with money, in which we begin to believe that we can buy our way to health. We just need the right gym, the right food, the right water, the right set of spiritual practices; all of which seem to cost an ever-escalating amount of money. And so, we spend and spend under the illusion that disposable income will make it possible for us to feel better and better every day in every way. But somehow, it never really does. There is always a little bit more health around the corner. We just need another sleep app, a way to track our biorhythms, a way to check our caloric intake and on and on.
Of course, there is even a deeper devil’s bargain with our health. Sometimes, it is not physical health we seek so much as fiscal health. We play games with the trade-offs we make with our environment to make money. Instead of looking to the world as that which nurtures us, we look to the world as something to be used, exploited, and consumed. At some level we know this an oxymoronic endeavor. That to seek to feel better and more healthy though creating a consumer universe of goods and services which savage the earth and all its inhabitants, doesn’t really make any sense. To extract toxic minerals, destroy forest habitats, pave over watersheds just so we can build a gym, the perfect home, the big box organic food store, a luxury spiritual retreat is a kind of madness. After all, we are quite literally fouling our own nest in pursuit of feeling healthy. It is a kind of suicidal madness, but one we as a society seem hell bent on pursuing.
It is of course, a kind of narcissism. The society we produce and which produces us is profoundly fixated on the self or the individual. When we think of being healthy, we tend to think of my body, my emotions, my mental health. When we seek to pursue health, we tend to think of what we can do with my body, mind, spirit, and so on. Our health is a personal concern that we often think of as private.
We go to great lengths to preserve the right to confidentiality in terms of our medical records. The right to keep our maladies between us and our physician can be quite important. What treatments we get, what pills we take, what surgeries, what mental health therapies is information many of us treat as proprietary. Our body and mind belong to us and what we share and with whom is a private matter. Of course, in a virtual world, this is something of an illusion with our medical records online, we are all a short hack away from unwitting transparency. And yet we sign forms and withhold information, sometimes even from those closest to us.
It should be said, that there is something to the idea of having some modicum of control over what we get to do with and for our bodies. After all, there are just to many examples of what happens when the government begins to tell us what we can and cannot do, from reproductive freedom to who can have sex with who, to what gender we must be or not be.
That said, I would argue that this faux control that we imagine we exercise over our body comes at a price. When we individualize bodies as biologically separable entities, we lose much of the capacity to think in deep and important ways about how dependent our body is on all other bodies. We lose the understanding that health is never an individual issue. Health is always collective.
Our health is an ecological matter. If we are embedded in a toxic and degraded environment, then the interactions we have with that environment will degrade our own bodily capacities. This may seem simplistic and yet, when we act in terms of our health as an individual matter that we can control outside of environmental factors, we are putting ourselves and everyone else at risk. All living things thrive in a rich and diverse ecology, including humans. When we have massive die offs of other species as we do now, it is both a warning that the system we live in is degrading significantly, but it also has immense implications for the kinds of nutrients our body needs to exist.
Our bodies are not homogenous. As I mentioned earlier, our physiognomy is idiosyncratic. Without a doubt, we share some things in common, but in other ways we all need different and nuanced nutrients to have the best life possible. When the ecological components of our existence are diminished, there is less variation in what we can access for the optimal function of the body. On the whole this may seem a bit abstract, but concretely it means that fewer bodies are able to adapt to an increasingly toxic and ever more homogenous environment. Our ability to effectively compose the biological and chemical relations we engage in each moment becomes compromised. We are more susceptible to environmental toxins viruses, harmful bacteria, cancers, and so on.
In a complex ecology, such threats are mitigated by a myriad of other bacteria, fungi, animals, plants, complex chemical interchanges of water and air that increase our immune capacity idiosyncratically in each body. When that is not available, because we are losing species, air and water quality, diversified plants and fungi, then our capacity to compose a complex and rich immune response to the world is compromised. We become reliant on narrow immune responses. Some of these we are able to generate in exchange with the living ecology in which we live, but increasingly our immunities are calibrated by pharmaceutical products with a very targeted and limited range. Given all of this, it is not particularly surprising that we have a drop in life expectancy, lower birth rates, increases in worldwide viral and bacterial outbreaks, and endemic rates of an ever-proliferating array of cancers.
Of course, I haven’t even begun to address the psychological and emotional desert of our social ecology. We have experienced significant losses of sociality, kinship, mutual care, and the richness of affective lived experience. While it’s clear that we are in trouble in the biosphere, we are in at least as much trouble in our social and psychological ecologies. We are starving ourselves through isolation and alienation. We are an society of profoundly lonely people, increasingly distant from one another and subject to processes of psychological and emotional homogenization that is robbing us of the richness of exchange with others that might well provide the collective answers we need to remedy the biosphere.
Here, we arrive in the world of CYC where I would argue our increasingly facile descriptions of healthy young people, workers, families, and communities are nowhere near sufficient to the crisis we face as a species. This may seem a bit beyond the scope of day-to-day practice. But if we took seriously the question of health as a collective concern, we could address in the minor collectives of our programs. What if we pushed back against homogenous descriptions of individual young people as disturbed, troubled, psychologically damaged, or psychiatrically impaired? What if we wondered about whether such young people were simply starving emotionally, socially, and psychologically? What if we asked the same questions of ourselves-are we also starving? What would happen if we quit treating young people and ourselves as individually unhealthy and began to see health ecologically? Perhaps, we could begin to feed each other and to value the rich diversity of bodies and minds that populate our daily lives at work and at home. That might be a small beginning towards actual health as something we all share and to which we are all accountable.