CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 278 APRIL 2022

Self-Development for CYC Staff, a Supervisory Focus

Jack Phelan

Our treatment efforts emphasize changing the young people and families in our programs almost exclusively, while ignoring the need to change the attitudes and thinking processes of the CYC staff members. Effective CYC supervision should include deliberate attempts to change the way that CYC staff think about the intention of their efforts with young people and families. I have based some of my understanding of intentional interventions on the work of Laura Steckley (2021) in Scotland concerning Threshold Concepts and the research of Heather Modlin (2013) in Newfoundland on adult thinking stages.

As CYC practitioners mature and develop increasingly complex ideas about effective life space treatment, their conceptualization of “self” in this relational dynamic changes dramatically. My premise is that how a practitioner thinks about what they are doing in the helping process is a result of how they think about the “self” that they bring forward in the interactions which are created in life space work. It is important for CYC supervisors to both understand how the “self” understood by each practitioner influences his/her ability to think about what is happening and also how to support a continual increase in complex thinking about “self”.

These conceptualizations of “self” mirror the developmental stages described as Level 1 Competent Care Giver, Level 2 Treatment Planner and Change Agent and Level 3 The Creative, Free-Thinking Professional, Phelan (2017). I will describe the “self” issues for Level 1 practitioners this month and the later stages in the next months.

Level 1 practitioners usually develop quickly over the first year of CYC experience, beginning with an awkward period of nervous anxiety about competence and personal safety during the initial three months of practice, followed by increasing self-confidence and skill building resulting in a practitioner who can competently organize and implement the existing daily program or home visit protocols, generally by the end of 9-12 months of experience.

The thinking of new practitioners is very focussed on personal feelings, generally concerned about safety and control. The anxiety about loss of control which is typical of new practitioners causes young people and families to act badly around them because this atmosphere of anxiety affects them too. As the practitioner acquires more experience, he/she settles down and things become more manageable. The practitioner often believes that the young person or family has changed, but he/she is the one who has changed, having built a safer belief about “self”.  Foster parents often go through this process with new youth or if they are new to fostering and once a safe personal attitude has been established, no longer need to be reassured that a youth will be removed from their home if the poor behavior continues. As they become safer in their own sense of self, the issue goes away.

After this difficult early experience of self fades, the new practitioner is ready to think more clearly about the person being helped, and less about their own discomfort. When challenging behavior occurs and the practitioner shifts from thinking “or no, what am I going to do now?” to “I wonder what is bothering the youth or family?”, the “self” of the practitioner has become able to focus on treatment needs. Level 1 practitioners still think about their own needs and generally see success linked to being liked by the person being helped. Personal attractiveness is an ongoing issue and Level 1 practitioners strive to be a role model and hope that they are missed when absent. This conceptualization of “self” is useful in many ways but has serious limitations. The intentional behavior of the helper includes thinking about their own image being projected, which limits their ability to fully appreciate the other person’s reality.

The Competent Care Giver is a valuable asset to the treatment program because he/she can competently run the requirements of the pre-determined set of routines and expectations, as well as creating experiences of being cared about for young people and families who often feel neglected and unimportant. The ability to create these moments result from supervision that emphasizes the need to go beyond the minimum requirements of job descriptions.

Themes arising in the first year of practice that supervisors will address include focussing on reducing anxiety in very recent staff, avoiding the agenda of the poor behavior of young people and family members. By supporting staff to reduce anxiety, they will more smoothly develop better thinking skills and strategies for helping, rather than getting stuck in the cycle of anxiousness that increases conflict. Newer staff also think of themselves as deserving of gratitude for being so willing to help, which only invites the distrust of young people and families. Supervisors can focus staff on the professional nature of the role and the issues that arise when staff feel unappreciated. The personal “self” focus of newer staff can also result in them wanting to be seen as a trusted friend, when they should be trying to create a more impersonal safer boundary for themselves. When supervisors can support Level 1 staff to think about the needs of the other person first, reducing the tendency to look for gratitude, trying to create moments of caring that exceed basic job expectations, and looking inside themselves to evaluate quality of performance rather than external approval, they will be building the foundation for shifting into a conceptualization of “self” which will be further developed at Level 2 practice.

We will look at Level 2 issues next month.

References

Phelan, J. (2017). Intentional CYC supervision a developmental approach, Cape Town, SA: CYC-Net Press.

Steckley, L. (2020). Threshold concepts in residential child care: Part 2, relational practice as threshold. Child and Youth Services Review, 112 (2020).

Modlin, H. (2013). Meaning making: Another perspective. Relational CYC Practice, 26 (3), Fall 2013.  

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App