Imagine if a philosophy professor taught her own theories as if they were the "right" answer to historical questions rather than teaching about the variety of theories, current and historical, that have been developed to respond to those questions. Students would likely be graded on their agreement with the instructor, not on the quality of their thought, the quality of their writing, or the creativity of their engagement with diverse ideas. They would not learn to have a disciplined mind, only an obedient one.
Philosophical theories begin as hunches, and then they are tested against the thought of thousands of people, and sometimes tested against empirical data. Even then, they are taught as theories, with room for disagreement and arguments pro and con. They are part of and a result of a process of "reflexive equilibrium," in which ideas get clarified over time.
CYC in Canada is a young and small field, and there is not enough friendly, public debate or critique of ideas; students in CYC rarely learn to consider and evaluate different points of view, despite plenty of alternatives. Some programs have an ideological bias to which students are expected to conform, that is, propaganda. Not many programs teach the history of a practice, except in simplistic terms, and students as a result suffer from "recentism," the assumption that the best ideas are the newest. CYC as a field does not keep up with ideas from other parts of the world, and we do not know our history.
Like philosophy, few ideas in CYC are absolutely true, and there is more than one way to do the work – more than one method and more than one theory that is useful in any particular situation – there is also more than one acceptable ideology and belief system. Yet some instructors are intolerant of dissent from their own views or current fads, calling students "resistant," a lethal and loaded word in CYC. Agreement with the instructor should not be the educational goal.
Alternatively, you might want to know something about CYC practices and be able to think about how well those practices serve real people rather than serve ideologies. A strength of graduates ought to be their ability to implement a variety of methods, as well as understand the weaknesses of each approach. There is room for alternatives.
If one will not learn a disciplined mind and a set of tools for solving practice problems drawn from the history of the field, why major in CYC? There are alternatives. The Conference Board of Canada published a report on the "skill vacancies" in Canada, and the skills they worry about track well with CYC competencies--but they also track well with liberal arts competencies. Why not major in history, philosophy, a language art, lingistics, or something similar?
Another option is therapeutic recreation (TR). In TR you will be exposed to progressive theories of inclusion and universal design, as relevant as any "critical disabilities" study course in CYC. You will value play as a modality of human growth and therapeutic healing, and you will learn about working alongside rather than telling people what to do. You will learn to assist others using democratic methods of reciprocity. You will learn concrete skills for working with diverse people while also learning how to generalize those skills. You can also learn to work in mental health and addiction settings. You can do clinical or community work. You might have some fun, and you can do CYC with a TR education. Of course, the quality of TR instruction varies too.
Thankfully, a few Canadian CYC higher education programs include these practices and are still trying to do this work. The interesting educational, learning challenge in education is to think about more practices that are possible rather than fewer, more practices that are interesting rather than the right theory or right practice, and then to figure out how to recognize when it is working – or not. We want students with diverse ideas and practices, not just diverse students who subscribe to one view. We can be critical, but we also want to know where and how to start a practice and knowing how to recognize whether that practice is helpful to clients, is where professionalism begins.
Reference
Conference Board of Canada. (2022, March 2). Lost opportunities: Measuring the unrealized value of skill vacancies in Canada. Available from: https://www.conferenceboard.ca/temp/b551c98f-4799-4043-b420-c1f327b51b08/11534_issue-briefing_fsc-skills-vacancies.pdf