CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 278 APRIL 2022

Time Has Come Today

Hans Skott-Myhre

Time has come today
The rules have changed today
I have no place to stay
I have no home
I have no home
Now the time has come
There's no place to run
I might get burned up by the sun
I've been crushed by the tumbling tide
There are things to realize
Time has come today
Time has come today

Chambers Brothers

 

I would like to take a moment in this month’s column to set a certain kind of context for the work we do in CYC. Living our lives and doing the work we do, it is sometimes difficult to make sense of the events in the world that shape our struggles and hardships. Without a doubt, we are living in a world in transition between the colonial and the postcolonial, the modern and the postmodern, industrial capitalism and virtual global capitalism, as well as the world of the nation state and the realm of global capitalist empire. The struggle between the faux democratic regimes that have masked the rule of the capitalist class in the U.S and its allies, and the rise of overtly dictatorial rule is shaping the descriptions we are being given of the choices we have for sovereignty and self-governance. We are gradually being subsumed into what Tony Sampson calls neuroculture, where our deepest desires are appropriated at a neurological level by corporate capital. We are living in an ever-proliferating open asylum where more and more of us are diagnosed and medicated. In short, we are living at the edges of an emerging world and suffering through the ambivalence not knowing what comes next.

The young people we encounter in our work live on the front lines of this ambivalence. They know the world will never be the same, They watch as adults try to force the world backwards into a semblance of what it once was and they know this cannot work. Things cannot go back, but the old world can continue to break though into the present as a form of collective PTSD flashback that haunts us and won’t seem to go away. To the degree we don’t account for this in our work, we will miss the opportunity to work with young people to shape an alternative future that puts our rampaging ghosts to rest. We need an exorcism, a ceremony, a new set of practices to move us through this transition to the other side without losing more young people to unnecessary death, pain, and despair. But first, perhaps we need to be able to see the ways in which time no longer functions in a progressive developmental linear fashion, because time is out of joint.

It is with that in mind that, like most of the world, I have been watching the Russian invasion of the Ukraine with dismay and horror at any number of levels. There is so much to say about the brutality of wars of occupation and colonization. My father, who fought the Nazis when they occupied his country as an underground Norwegian partisan in his mid-teens, once told me that to successfully occupy a country requires a willingness to be absolutely merciless. Ironically, he felt that the United States, as he knew it in the late twentieth century, was not capable of that level of brutality.

While that may or may not be true of the contemporary U.S., historically the colonization of what is now the United States was carried out with precisely that level of merciless force. Indeed, A number of Indigenous tribes in the U.S. have condemned the invasion of Ukraine, likening it to attacks on tribal nations by settler-colonists,

Yakama Nation Tribal Council members likened the Ukraine invasion to attacks on tribal nations by non-tribal people upon their arrival in 1492. The tribal council said the assault is no different than the invasion of Yakama Nation tribes.

And there is no doubt that processes of colonization and Empire building hold both structural and tactical similarities across historical periods. There are, however, an array of anomalies in this particular savage assault on the sovereignty of the Ukrainian people that also have colonial roots. Among these, I would note that the preponderance of African nations have not stepped forward to support European and American actions intended to counter the invasion.  There seems to be a colonial residue left by the European occupation of Africa in the postcolonial period, while Russia has no history of colonization in Africa.

Nations such as Kenya sees parallels between the emergence of Ukraine after the fall of the Soviet Union and the ways in which Africa was shaped during the process of decolonization. There is a recognition of the dangers of the rise of modes of colonial domination in the Ukrainian invasion by Russia, while simultaneously an understanding that there is a certain hypocrisy in the positioning of nations such as the U.S., who continue wars that assert global hegemony and colonial control in the Mideast, among other places. Kenya's UN Security Council representative Martin Kimani stated in a speech before the U.N, that

There are many people in many parts of the world who would like to see other regions gaining strength and would like to see the end of Western domination of the world order, putting it simply ... of course, no right-thinking person in Africa or anywhere in the world looks at what is going on in Ukraine now and thinks that it's a good thing ...  but many people do see the hypocrisy.

The complicated set of postcolonial conditions that creates an ambivalent response among African nations, might also be used to read the relations of countries such as India and China. These nations were also colonized by European powers such as Britain and have taken what might be generously described as an agnostic position on the invasion of the Ukraine by Russia, who despite geographic proximity never invaded or attempted to colonize either China or India.

All of this is to say that, the ghosts of colonization continue to exert a powerful force in world politics within the world of the 21st century. As Faulkner put it, in Requiem for a Nun, “The past is  never dead. It’s not even past.” One of the most troubling and disconcerting aspects of life as we know it today is the way in which notions of linear progressive time, have become increasingly difficult to articulate. Time has become entangled in ways that make it ever more difficult to put the past in the past and even harder to assert the present as an entry point to the future. Our ghosts, such as colonization, genocide, fascism, and white supremacy continue to intrude with an insistence that makes them impossible to ignore. Of course, it is possible that we are in a transition that will move us beyond such horrific enactments of human depravity, but it would seem that, at least for now, our nightmares seem to be always on the edge of the daybreak of new worlds.

I think of this when I see the reassertions of white supremacy, homophobia, religious fundamentalism, and the rise of plutocracies in the U.S, and elsewhere.  Much of this is in play in the conflict in Ukraine, although it is not generally described in these terms. One might wonder why this conflict in particular has garnered so much emotional support and media attention. Why does the invasion of the Ukraine resonate so deeply with the West.    

For example, I am thinking of the Biden administration’s decision to accept 100,000 Ukrainian refugees into the U.S. There are a number of things that are puzzling about this decision. One being that the U.S. is not actually a major destination for Ukrainian refugees and its seems quite unlikely that such a capacity will be necessary. Don’t get me wrong, I am all for admitting Ukrainian refuges in those numbers or more. But I have to wonder, why Ukrainian’s refugees, when the U.S. is refusing large numbers of other desperate people from Haiti, Central and South America, and Somalia. What makes the Ukrainians uniquely situated for asylum?

In the course that I teach on cultural competence, I teach a section on White Privilege. One of the assertions that I make in the class, is that the most fundamental aspect of privilege is the ability to claim without ambivalence that you belong here, that you will never have to worry about being forced to leave where you live because you don’t belong.

In that portion of the class, I trace U.S. immigration law and policy along with legislation such as the Indian Removal Act to trace the history of who gets to belong as defined by who can be legally removed. Not surprisingly, the groups who face removal or who are barred from immigrating are overwhelmingly people of color or Indigenous. When there have been immigration restrictions on people of European origin, such as the Irish, Eastern or Southern Europeans, it was because they were considered non-white. With the expansion of whiteness to include all Europeans, those restrictions have faded away. On the other hand, they have not faded away for immigrants of color trying to seek asylum in the U.S. When read in this light, the Biden administration’s approach to Ukrainian immigration, at same time the U.S. is deporting people of color, has to be seen as another instance of we the people as, we the white people. In some respects even our acts of kindness and generosity are tinged with colonial residue that we can’t seem to move beyond.  

At the end of the day, however, perhaps one the most telling aspects of the Russian invasion is the question of land. There is no doubt that any serious effort at decolonization includes the repatriation of stolen land. And there is also no doubt that this continues to be an issue as settler states such as the U.S. and other nations continue to steal land and violate indigenous sovereignty. There are certainly still armed encounters between the state and indigenous peoples over such continued colonial practices. However, nothing on the scale of what Russia has been doing in the Ukraine. To militarily invade land in order to reestablish the previous borders of a 19th century empire is an act profoundly out of synch with the increasingly virtual mechanisms of appropriation by global capitalism. It is a reactionary anomaly unprecedented in scope and aspiration. And this is reflected in the asymmetry of response by NATO countries including the U.S. While Russia fights the war on the land, slaughters thousands of civilians, and bombs cities into oblivion, the U.S. and its allies fight the war on the terrain of virtual capital, trying to inflict pain through attacks on the economy of Russia. This is an odd war indeed, between a 19th century invasion using 21st century weaponry and a virtual war fought on the terrain of virtual capitalism. We would appear to be in a moment where, as Yeats would have it –

Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Surely some revelation is at hand

 I would argue, that for those of us working with young people, this is the world we need to take to take into account. We cannot continue to harken back to whatever world we, as adults, miss and wish to reestablish. The future is now emerging and we need to work together to bring the best of it forward, or without a doubt we will live through the worst of it. The time is now and the revelation is at hand. The question is, can we read the writing on the wall, or are we turned ever backwards to a world that can never be again. Young people are already living in the future. We need to join them there, however unsettling that might be. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App