CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 278 APRIL 2022

Case Files and Real Lives: When Children’s Lives Become Documented

Kiaras Gharabaghi

These days, I spent a lot of time reading case files for children and youth in foster care, group homes, or other types of involvements with child welfare, child and youth mental health services or youth criminal justice services. Reading case files is not an uplifting process; quite to the contrary, it is a process that exposes the enormous gulf between professional measures designed to yield accountability, safety and transparency in case management and case coordination activities on the one hand, and the lives lived by young people every day on the other hand. It is worthwhile to consider what a case file presents us with and how it shapes the narrative of young people’s lives.

In case you never had occasion to read a complete case file of a young person involved with out of home care systems, let me provide a description of what is in those files, how they are structured and organized, and what the nature of the narrative is that these files present us with. While I am drawing primarily on my experience of these files in the Canadian context, I have in fact reviewed files in other jurisdictions, and although they are differences, these are not substantively all that pronounced.

A case file is usually a large document (these days, often digital), sectioned into core areas of case management, such as assessments, social history, education, family, placements, etc. It begins with identifying information about the young person, including information about their age, where they were born, their birth family context, their cultural, racial, and spiritual identifications and associations, as well as their involvement in schools. It also provides a brief snapshot of the young person’s involvement in systems; it tells us who opened a file for the young person, when they did that, when the file was closed, and it usually provides a list of out of home placements and other services that may have been provided over time. Then we go into the sections of the file. Very often, the assessment section is near the front, and it provides us with any of the psychological, psycho-educational, or psychiatric assessments that have been completed at various times in the child’s life. The education section provides us with report cards from schools, any school reports beyond that, as well as incident reports about things that may have happened at school. The family section gives us a social history for the child, explains who the family members and sometimes other significant adults in the child’s life are, and similar kind of information.

Every placement of the child typically produces their own placement-specific files, so that the case file also has sections for daily logs, incident reports, and other information that comes directly from each of the placements. As you can imagine, for children with multiple placements, these case files are quite large, sometimes several thousand pages.

What brings these case files to life, however, is not so much the descriptive information, the reports, the daily logs, and so on, but rather the much more interesting copies of emails, notes about phone calls, and other communication records exchanged between the professionals that have been involved at various stages of the child’s life. It is in those communications that we can find the dynamic of case management and case coordination, including the tensions that emerge while children are being managed by adults with varying vested interests. Of particular note is that almost all of these communications are based on regulatory standards and the accuracies of templated forms. In other words, professionals are talking to each other about their adherence to regulations much more so than about the child. For example, there are usually countless emails from a regulator to a service provider pointing to incomplete information, such as missing dates for medical visits, or inaccurately field incident reports. Then we find revised submissions from the service provider that simply correct whatever the regulator complained about.

In some instances, the level of superficiality is truly astounding. For example, when a child identifies as racialized or Indigenous, the communication about that child is primarily focused on whether specific actions have been taken to recognize the identity of the child. It matters not so much what those actions are. But it does matter that the section of a form demanding comment on those actions is completed. For example, I often come across comments such as this:

The child identifies as Indigenous, but at the moment expresses no desire to engage this identity.

This kind of comment satisfies the needs of the case file, despite lacking any kind of substantive meaning. Case files about children with identities other than Indigenous (in the Canadian context) lack any kind of commentary on how such identities are taken up or how they might be important in a child’s life. Another very common element of the communication between professionals reflected in case files relates to the actions taken in response to various assessment reports. These are almost always limited to instrumental actions and turn out to be surprisingly uniform across case files for different children. For example, assessment reports that include diagnoses are almost always followed up with a demand that the child be referred to ‘treatment’. The nature of that treatment seems quite irrelevant. So long as there is an indication that the child was referred to a counsellor or therapist, we are good to go.

Case files tend to center documentation about decision-making much more so than documentation about everyday life. It is clear that professional systems see themselves as accountable in the context of the decisions they make. Decision-making includes a wide range of actions. Decisions to refer the child to other services, decisions to change placements, decisions with respect to family access to the child, and, at the micro level, decisions with respect to specific program choices, consequences, loss of privileges, and so on are all well documented and rationalized. In all of this, case files provide very limited information about the perspectives of the child, and virtually no information that dives into the everyday activities of the child. To the extent that they do refer to such activities, such references are problem focused. In other words, child activities that are in violation of program rules, that involve conflict with the law, or that might involve challenges at school (including suspensions) are well documented. On the other hand, a child’s relationships with friends, their everyday chatter about things of interest to them, or even their perspectives on interpersonal relationships are largely absent in the file. Similarly absent is an indication about the child’s way of being in the world, particularly as this might reflect intersectional identity characteristics. For example, nothing in the case file speaks to how a Black child might experience being Black in the communities where they are placed (in Canada, most foster homes and group homes are situated in predominantly white communities, often in rural or small-town spaces).

I am writing about case files this month because I am increasingly concerned about how these documents are used to understand child and youth experiences of ‘life in the system’. This is important, since our understanding of those experiences are major drivers of system development and transformation. Based on case files, our approach to systems will largely focus on the needs of professionals, and beyond their needs, also their vested interests. In other words, it is perhaps not surprising that child and youth serving systems feed primarily themselves. Having read dozens of case files end to end, I am realizing that the humanity of the child is really quite invisible. With an invisible humanity, it is difficult to imagine meaningful approaches to what are fundamentally human processes, including care and caring, relational engagements, and authentic acknowledgments of intersectional identities. Instead, I am experiencing case file reviews as a process that objectifies children and youth. As objects, we can measure the degree of regulatory compliance in relation to specific characteristic of the object, but we cannot create space for agency, self-efficacy, autonomy, and subjectivity. While it is true that in recent years, even case files have had to create some space for child and youth voice, that voice is itself commodified to go with the object being described. I sense no real engagement with voice as an expression of autonomous human agency. Instead, I see voice as reflected in case files as much more analogous to a battery-operated toy, whereby case files now more regularly actually ensure that there is a functioning battery in the toy that dutifully allows for voice to be audible and documented.

Perhaps most notable for me is the absence of child and youth care practice in case files. Despite most of the files pertaining to children and youth who regularly, sometimes 24 hours per day, are engaged with child and youth care practitioners, this work finds little expression in case files (beyond the program specific file and its daily logs). This means that the child’s life is essentially devoid of everyday ways of being, and specifically being in relationship with others. It is a life of appointments and referrals, incidents and problems, and efforts to ensure complete case files rather than meaningful lives. Perhaps this helps us understand why change in child and youth serving systems is rarely transformative.

Something to think about. 

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App