We spend a lot of time and energy trying to convey the message that
we care to the youth we work with. Because most, if not all, of the
people who are Child and Youth Care (CYC) practitioners support are low
in Attachment ability, they view all caring attempts as behaviours that
are not logical. The youth see caring behaviour as self-motivated, since
there is no logical reason to do anything for another person unless it
also provides a payoff for the carer. In the dog-eat-dog world view of a
person with low Attachment ability, everyone is self-centered and has no
need to care about anyone else unless they get some personal benefit.
When people have been nice to them in the past, it was a set-up to take
advantage of them in some way and this life lesson is very powerful.
So Child and Youth Care practitioners often hear youth say that “The only reason you are
here is because you are getting paid to do it.”
We laugh at this and reply that we do not get paid enough, or that we could make better money driving a bus, etc., but we are missing the point. What is being said is that the youth has made sense of our caring by realizing that we are getting a personal benefit, we do not really care about him.
When we do our job well it does not necessarily communicate caring, but rather merely that we are a capable “staff” (part of the nameless, faceless adult world). When we insist on hearing a “Thank you” from a youth, intending to teach good manners, it is often understood by the youth as our pay-off, so it is not because you really care, you just want to be paid for your deeds.
Youth who are ego-centric (with very good reason) are the predominate population in Child and Youth Care settings. These youth do not share the social logic of more developmentally normal youth and certainly do not see the world the same way that the adult Child and Youth Care practitioner does. They actually are quite invested in proving that we do not care for them, that we are only doing these caring behaviours for our own personal gratification, or because we are required to act this way by the job description.
Think about your own childhood; when your mother cooked a meal that you did not like, you complained and heard her say that she worked hard to prepare it and you should be thankful. The normal child typically thinks to him- self, that’s your job to cook meals, you are my mother.
Yet, if the same child gets his favourite snack or dessert one day, he feels loved in a special way, because his mom cares about him.
Child and Youth Care practitioners have to demonstrate caring by going be- yond the usual job requirements and doing special things for each youth, particularly the ones who we are the focus of our relationship building efforts. Also, we have to do things without waiting for or expecting a “Thank you” because this ne- gates the caring message.
When we join youth and families in the way that they actually think, not assuming that we already share the same “meaning-making” framework, it becomes powerful and useful for the youth/family. Our common sense function gets turned off and we begin to create meaningful communication.
So to communicate that we care, Child and Youth Care practitioners must go beyond the job specs and usual daily interactions to create a message that will confound the youth – you are behaving in a puzzling way, it does not fit my notion of why people are nice to me. When the youth starts to believe that you do care, he will need to test this behaviour. Some youth call after 10 pm to ask for a ride, knowing that the double coverage has ended. Other youth will ask for your attention when you are already too busy, much like children in normal families all suddenly need to speak to their parents when they are speaking on the phone.
To do caring things and not get paid, means that we have to vanish quickly, not stand around waiting for a thank you or even a smile. This process will change slowly, but will only work with by starting with a careful, methodical approach that confounds the existing belief system (the world is an unfriendly place and no one cares for me).
So, being a caring Child and Youth Care practitioner is not as easy as it sounds. As Bettleheim said, love is not enough.