Although it is not often mentioned in the Child Youth Care literature in academic and more casual sources, I think we have to begin thinking about an issue that is hardly new, but that has intensified in recent years with a relatively bleak outlook for the future. Specifically, I am thinking about youth unemployment, particularly in OECD countries but also in other parts of the world. In recent months, a number of international studies (by the OECD, the International Labour Organization as well as the World Bank) have pointed to some worrisome trends in relation to youth unemployment in OECD countries. Unlike unemployment more generally, which has fluctuated significantly for many years, youth unemployment has steadily increased. And so while it is true that unemployment generally was actually at record lows throughout North America and Europe only a couple of years ago, therefore implying that the current high levels of unemployment may well reverse themselves eventually as they typically have in the past, youth unemployment has been high and growing even during times of massive, global and regional economic boom.
It is furthermore worrisome that even where unemployment is averted by
youth, the job market for new entries into the economy is hardly inspiring;
for many young people, minimum wage jobs, often
part time, typically with
no benefits, are the only prospects.
Three factors seem to make a difference in terms of successful entry and
on-going mobility within the job market for young people: first, the level
of education completed; second, the entrepreneurial spirit and knowledge of
the youth, and third, the personal networks and connections of youth in the
high-achieving areas of the labour market.
Equipped with this knowledge, we ought to pause for a moment and think about the way in which we have approached services for young people facing challenges in their lives and requiring the support of formal youth-serving sectors, such as children’s mental health, child welfare or juvenile justice services and so on. We already know that we have not been particularly successful in helping these young people achieve the highest levels of education that would allow them to compete with other less disadvantaged youth. On the positive side, educational success has moved up in the list of priorities of governments in the US, Canada and Britain in particular (perhaps elsewhere too), but outcomes have not yet reflected this increased priority. It is perhaps also important to point out that a straight comparison of educational outcomes for youth in care (or looked-after) or youth affected by mental health challenges on the one hand, and the general youth population in any particular jurisdiction is not entirely fair either; clearly academic achievement is impacted by developmental challenges and mental health issues that the education sector has been ill-equipped to address and mitigate.
But education aside, what of the other two factors that impact on a young person’s chances in this new, minimum wage, disposable labour force, economy. We do know that higher education, although clearly an advantage, is still not a sure ticket to economic success. Aside from the changing landscape of competencies for particular career tracks, factors such as personal mobility, health, and the ability to invest up-front in one’s career (cash to buy clothing, work items such as computers, tools, health & safety equipment required by law, etc.) also will impact on a young person’s success, and we already know that the young people we tend to engage with are at a disadvantage in all of these factors1. What I really worry about, however, is the degree to which youth-serving agencies and sectors are incorporating those other two major factors for economic success in their everyday services: entrepreneurial spirit and the building of networks within the economic elite (at least amongst local or regional employers).
I am aware that there are some services that do in fact focus on precisely these kinds of issues, but they are relatively small and serve only very small numbers of youth. In reality, the vast majority of youth-serving sectors continue to operate under the assumption of an old economy. By this I mean that the values and skills being promoted, enforced or rewarded are things like compliance, conformity, risk-aversion, safety-focus, citizenship. In many cases, youth are being streamed toward industries and employment sectors that have all but disappeared in the new economies of the OECD countries, including manufacturing and vocational endeavors of many different kinds. The message “you are good with your hands” remains a common one.
And yet, here we are at a time in history when many things are changing rapidly and quite profoundly; quite clearly the deal we have had from the beginning of the industrial revolution to the end of the 20th century is off (perhaps that deal ended in the late 1960s, or specifically in 1968 as many French theorists have argued compellingly).
I think it is fair to take a moment and consider the characteristics of factors that lead to economic success in this new world: being persuasive, manipulative, connected, aggressive when necessary, assertive all the time, loyal to capital more so than to individuals, companies or even nations. Having capacity to assess risk and boldly step into the fray, knowing where to find information immediately, understanding the multiple languages of communication, some based entirely on technology platforms. Engaging, disengaging and re-engaging with people, in projects, to movements. Skills in public speaking, presentation technologies, and creativity reflecting the vast array of social, fashion, business and relationship trends.
None of these things are really compatible with the values and expectations of much of the youth-serving industries. This is not to say that everything needs to change, be abandoned or re-developed, or that all that we are doing is for naught. But it is to suggest that the time to critically reflect on whether youth work, youth services and the culture of youth engagement that has entrenched itself in much of the OECD area and especially in the US, Canada and Britain, is still as relevant as it could be.
Note