CYCAA Milestone Kibble Cal Farleys TRCT The PersonBrain Model Homebridge Allambi Youth Services Amal OACYC Waypoints Bartimaues Shift Brayden Supervision Tanager Place ACYCP Algonquin Bow Valley Centennial College Humber College Keyin College Lakeland Lambton College Lethbridge Polytechnic MacEwan University Medicine Hat Mount Royal NSCC Red River College Seneca Polytech Sheridan University of Strathclyde TMU University of Victoria
CYC-Online 146 APRIL 2011

The Consultant as Container

Judy Furnival

Laura Steckley writes: Over the last several columns, I’ve been writing about containment as an organising frame for thinking about practice – both the direct practice of caring for children and young people, and the indirect practice of supporting those doing direct practice.

This month I asked my friend and colleague, Judy Furnival, to do a guest piece for my column. Judy is the Consultancy Manager here at the Scottish Institute for Residential Child care, and she has a wealth of experience related to the containing processes provided by external consultancy. Not only did she have the good fortune to experience good consultancy when she was in direct practice, she now provides it to organisations in Scotland and further afield. I’ve always enjoyed our conversations about this subject and I thought Judy could enhance this series of columns by sharing some of her experiences.

The Consultant as Container
The first task of the residential worker is to survive the emotional, psychic and at times physical onslaught from young people in their care. This apparently simple expectation can at times seem impossible, as the level of pain and distress young people experience can often be translated into behaviour that is appallingly destructive to themselves and those who strive to enter into caring or therapeutic relationships with them.

Moreover these young people have themselves survived by tuning in to and managing the anxieties of adults and seeking out splits among them to make them wider. Most workers will recognise the experience of “having their buttons pushed” by a young person and wondering how did the young person know exactly what to say to get under their skin. When we add to this already volatile mix the reality that many workers are attracted to the job because of their own difficult life experiences, it is easy to see that at times life in a residential child care setting can resemble a boiling cauldron of emotion. A natural response when faced with this is to withdraw into a safe but sterile approach that avoids pain and connectedness by focusing on controlling behaviour through reward and punishment.

Some degree of compliance can usually be achieved through this route and when children’s pain spills out in violence or despair then they can be ejected or controlled through more restrictive conditions or medication. In some agencies workers may be left coping with a situation perpetually on the edge of chaos without even the support of such a behaviour management structure. In such cases the internal distress of young people and adults is reflected in the continuous instability of children’s placements, dangerous behaviour, low morale and high staff sickness and turnover. There are many residential settings that are able to provide a much more sensitive and containing response to the young people who live there but this can only be achieved if the adults are provided with their own containing experiences such as a clear philosophy of care, good management, regular supervision and training. Even with all these in place, however, there are times when managers, staff and young people can find themselves swept into an enactment of the tortured internal worlds that exist in residential care.

So what else can help? During my own time as a practitioner and manager I was lucky enough to have outstanding support from two external consultants who visited the therapeutic community in which I worked on a frequent and regular basis.

One was a consultant psychotherapist who was able to provide a theoretical structure to provide meaning for young people’s behaviour. Perhaps more importantly, however, he helped us to untangle the emotions evoked in us by the young people which sprang out of our own unresolved difficulties from those which were projected into us by the child. Many young workers who come into residential child care are still struggling with unresolved authority issues — I was no exception! I was the key worker for one very distressed, enraged and dangerous young woman whose life experiences had made her murderous towards adults. She was also, however, very intelligent and capable of immense warmth and loyalty to those she cared about. I found myself identifying with this young woman in her perpetual struggles with adult authority as they mirrored my own struggles with more senior authority figures among the staff group. I also really liked this young girl and respected her courage and passion. It is difficult for supervisors to deal with this kind of issue as they are caught up in the process. The consultant, however, was instrumental in enabling me to recognise that the over identification was defending me from the pain and distress that this child was experiencing she was not just a high spirited teenager with a bit of attitude!

This allowed me to accept and contain her rage, hatred and anger, even when it was focused on me, whilst maintaining the very genuine warmth, love and respect I had for her. She is now a successful manager in a family centre with a young child of her own. Until she was placed with us at the age of twelve she had experienced multiple placements including a period in secure care and had been comprehensively rejected by all the adults who had cared for her. Clearly she was a very competent and resilient young woman but her capacity for hatred and destructiveness came close to destroying her placement with us too and without the containment I experienced through consultancy her future would have been much less secure. The second consultant was an organisational psychologist who provided role consultancy for individual staff and also worked with the dynamics of the staff group as a whole. Her position on the edge of the staff group enabled her to recognise patterns in the dynamics of the group that were dysfunctional and she reflected these back to us in a supportive but clear way.

The experience of providing care for other people’s children draws into sharp focus some of the patterns of relationship that exist in all organisations. We all draw our understanding of relationships from our earliest family experiences. Being part of a group of people who work together closely and are dependent on each other and management for the successful completion of work can mirror early life experience and particularly relationships with siblings and parents. This is emphasised by working with young people who bring their own distorted family experiences into the psychic mix! Moreover young people desperate for positive parental models often try to push adults caring for them into sexual relationships. We all know that many people meet their partners at work and the experience of working in a very intimate way makes the development of such relationships even more likely in residential care settings. All of this combines to create a potent and confusing mix of transference, counter transference, fantasy and reality. The consultant was able to support staff to explore these dynamics safely both as individuals and also in the staff meeting. Even the most well trained and well managed staff group would hesitate to explore such areas without an external facilitator, yet it is precisely these unspoken dynamics that can cause damaging and destructive rivalries and acting out in staff groups that can have catastrophic effects on young people.

During the past few years I have had the privilege of acting as a consultant to a number of staff groups and this have given me a fuller picture of the complexity of the task. Most particularly I have become aware of the level of personal distress that is often carried by residential workers even before they begin to engage with young people. It is for example difficult enough to contend with one’s own experience of childhood trauma without then being expected to provide emotional containment for young people whose own trauma is still raw and immediate. Alternatively imagine the impact of dealing with a violently aggressive teenager if you are still coping with domestic abuse at home.

Discussing these issues with supervisors may be possible but to be honest about the depth of pain and emotion may be too difficult because of the fear of judgement. In most staff groups that I work with at least a quarter of all staff have this type of personal history. In many cases this can enrich their capacity for empathy but this is not without personal cost and having an individual safe space where they can explore these issues as they impact upon their work can be crucial for their emotional survival and continued professional effectiveness. Even for those for whom their personal experiences are not so traumatic the opportunity to reflect on how their professional practice relates to their internal world can enable them to successfully contain the children they work with without becoming punitive or overwhelmed. The simple fact of working with children of the same age as one’s own children can be acutely painful for some practitioners. They are confronted with the evidence of trauma and despair on a daily basis and cannot help comparison with their own children. This may lead to overwhelming sadness and pity for children and a confused guiltiness about the positive lives their own children enjoy. Alternatively there may be a defended reaction only to the behaviour and an unrealistic expectation that children in children’s homes show the same level of competence and pro social behaviour that their own children display. Neither of these responses is helpful as it removes the focus from the real child and consultancy can provide the opportunity to disentangle these responses from the work of responding to the individual needs and strengths of children.

Providing individual containment as a consultant is not easy. I often feel I am literally carrying away vast loads of pain and distress as I leave the residential unit. More importantly, however, this kind of engagement cannot happen in the absence of a longstanding and trusting relationship. Most residential workers (including me!) view this kind of resource with suspicion and wariness. Fear of being covertly exposed to therapy or alternatively assuming that all information is shared with mangers can make practitioners reluctant to make use of this type of individual space. What continues to impress me is that, almost invariably, once they do begin to seek out this support staff are capable of making such extraordinary use of it to face their own responses and difficulties and develop their capacity to relate effectively with young people and stay connected to their pain.

Alongside this individual support I work with groups of staff in residential units particularly in staff meetings. Being a regular participant in this environment but removed from the direct work with young people allows me to recognise some patterns as they are emerging. A number of common themes occur in residential settings as a way of managing the intolerable anxiety evoked by the job. Sometimes there are divisions within the group between staff who are seen as too “soft” and those who are considered too “rigid”. At times of crisis staff may focus on one member of the community (staff or resident) as the “problem” that needs to be ejected to restore equilibrium. Often a dysfunctional interaction between managers and staff can emerge in which managers complain about staff members’ incapacity to act autonomously while simultaneously staff are bewailing the managers’ refusal to delegate. All these patterns are common and can be recognised by most practitioners and managers in the abstract but when immersed in a particular dynamic it is difficult to recognise it for what it is without some external support. If they are not addressed and managed, however, it is the children who are ultimately damaged as staff are unable to provide them with the consistent and attuned care they require and in some cases young people may be directly affected if, for example, their placement is terminated. Inevitably in residential care these situations recur and can never be permanently resolved because the work is so inherently stressful that such self protective but dysfunctional dynamics continue to emerge in even the most reflective and well managed staff groups.

I am not suggesting that consultancy is the only or even most important source of emotional containment for staff, indeed I would suggest it is probably most effective in an organisation that already has good structures of support for staff. What I am sure of from my own experience as practitioner and consultant, as well as through others who have received good consultancy in their own organisations, is that it can provide invaluable containment and enhance practice. In fact I would argue that it is unethical to provide residential care without ensuring that such consultancy is built in to the staff support system. The skills required for undertaking consultancy already exist widely in the professional community involved with distressed children — can we afford not to use these skills to help adults survive in residential care and to enable children to flourish in their lives?

The International Child and Youth Care Network
THE INTERNATIONAL CHILD AND YOUTH CARE NETWORK (CYC-Net)

Registered Public Benefit Organisation in the Republic of South Africa (PBO 930015296)
Incorporated as a Not-for-Profit in Canada: Corporation Number 1284643-8

Board of Governors | Funding | Site Content and Usage | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Contact us

iOS App Android App