56
Profiles of Resilient Survivors of Institutional Abuse in Ireland
Edel Flanagan, Alan Carr, Barbara Dooley, Mark Fitzpatrick,
Roisin Flanagan-Howard, Mark Shevlin, Kevin Tierney, Megan White,
Margaret Daly & Jonathan Egan.
Abstract
In a group of 247 survivors of institutional
abuse in Ireland, 45 cases (18%) did not meet the diagnostic criteria
for common DSM IV axis I or II disorders. This resilient group was
compared with a poorly adjusted group of 119 participants who met the
criteria for 1-3 DSM IV axis I or II diagnoses, and a very poorly
adjusted group of 83 participants who had 4 or more disorders. Compared
with the very poorly adjusted group, the resilient group was older and
of higher socio-economic status; had suffered less sexual and emotional
institutional abuse; experienced less traumatization and re-enactment of
institutional abuse; had fewer trauma symptoms and life problems; had a
higher quality of life and global level of functioning; engaged in less
avoidant coping; and more resilient survivors had a secure adult
attachment style. The resilient group differed from the poorly adjusted
group on a subset of these variables. The results of this study require
replication in other contexts. Therapeutic interventions with survivors
should focus on facilitating the use of non-avoidant coping strategies
and the development of a secure adult attachment style.
74
Power in the Narratives of Finnish Women and Men with an Intra Familial
Child Sexual Abuse Background
Merja Laitinen
Abstract
In the article the enticement process is analysed through power in the
narratives of Finnish women and men who were sexually abused in their
childhood nuclear families. The material of this sensitive interview
study consists of in-depth interviews of twenty-one victims, seventeen
women and four men, and secondary material of writings. Thematic
analysis was carried out. The categorised aspects of power were named as
arbitrary power, threatening power, coercive power, manipulative power,
compensatory power, seductive power and caring power called love. These
categorised aspects of power can be conceptualized as victimizing power
which is a remarkable part of victimization in the victim's experiences.
The victims need support in the breaking of the bond formed by power,
violence, gender and sexuality in their personal histories, and in
disentangling and interpreting its meanings. It is a question of how
adult victims with their experiences are understood in the service
system.
87
Assessing Children's Ability to Give Consent
Maurice Place & Richard Barker
Abstract
This paper explores the important issue of children's ability to give
consent, via the development of a focussed questionnaire relating to
medical matters. A questionnaire in relation to common 'medical; issues'
was developed from interviews with children and was then given to a
sample of 201 children aged 11 and 12 years. The results were compared
to those from a group of 245 university students. Of the three sections
of the questionnaire, definitions and forced choices showed some ability
to discriminate between adults and children, but using the method of
ranking of choices did not. Selecting the elements with highest
discriminatory power produced a scale that showed good effect size which
would be worthy of further exploration and use. It is clear that
determining a child's competence to consent is a challenging but
necessary task. Whilst 'objective measures' cannot give a simple answer
this study indicates that they have potential to assist in relation to
the exercise of professional judgment in this area.
97
Explaining Fathers' Involvement in Child Care:
Recent Findings from Israel
Liat Kulik & Hani Tsoref
Abstract
The study aimed to examine variables that explain perceptions of
paternal involvement in child care among 88 Jewish Israeli women with at
least one child aged 2-6. The women's perceptions of paternal
involvement in child care were examined in five domains: physical care,
education, showing love, playing with the children, and punishment.
Based on the family systems approach, we examined the extent to which
the following sets of maternal variables contribute to explaining
mothers' perceptions of paternal involvement in child care: gender role
ideology, maternal gatekeeping, desirability of control, perceived
support from the extended family, and mothers' satisfaction with their
husbands' participation in child care. The predictor variables explained
the mothers' perceptions of paternal involvement in the domain of
showing love to the greatest extent.